HC orders CBI probe into corruption charges linked to Punjab CM’s office
Source: The Hindu, 6 October 2026
Summary
On Monday the Punjab and Haryana High Court, hearing a PIL, directed the CBI to investigate corruption allegations linked to Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann's office. The allegations were raised by the Enforcement Directorate (ED). The Bench held that a fair and transparent probe was needed and that it was dissatisfied with the Punjab Police's handling. The CBI must register an FIR and proceed at once, and report the outcome to the court within two months. Congress's Partap Singh Bajwa, Leader of the Opposition in the Punjab Assembly, demanded the CM's resignation, saying the AAP government projects Mann as an "honest" CM. BJP's Sambit Patra, in New Delhi, asked AAP's Arvind Kejriwal and Mann to clarify on the allegations.
Key facts for Prelims
- CBI: no constitutional status. Established by an MHA resolution (1963), based on the DSPE Act, 1946. Section 6 of the DSPE Act requires State consent to exercise powers in a State. Entry 2 of List II (Police) gives States jurisdiction over policing.
- State of West Bengal v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights (2010), a Constitution Bench ruling, settled that a High Court can direct a CBI probe without State consent.
- Only the High Court (Art. 226) or the Supreme Court (Art. 32) can entrust an investigation to the CBI this way. This implicitly takes away the power of magistrates and special courts to do so.
- Kazi Lhendup Dorji v. CBI (1994): withdrawal of general consent does not affect pending investigations.
- Writ jurisdiction: Article 226 (High Courts, wider than Art. 32); a PIL is a form of public-interest jurisdiction.
- The ED works under the PMLA, 2002 and the FEMA, 1999.
Data and details
- Order: Monday (5 Oct 2026). Bench: Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor.
- Allegations raised by the ED against public servants and private individuals linked to the AAP government: corruption in transfers and postings, policy manipulation, cash for tenders, and "other such serious irregularities".
- The petition alleges senior Punjab officers' involvement in scams: cash for transfers, cash for favourable policies and cash for tenders. No investigation had been held despite the ED sharing information with Punjab Police.
- Court directions: the CBI to register an FIR and "proceed forthwith"; a report on the outcome within two months. The Bench said it was "not impressed" with Punjab Police's conduct so far.
- Reactions:
- Congress's Partap Singh Bajwa, Leader of the Opposition in the Punjab Assembly, demanded Mann's immediate resignation. He said the verdict raised serious questions on the functioning of the State government and the CM's own responsibility.
- Bajwa also asked why the HC needed an independent agency if the government were truly "imandaar" (honest).
- BJP's Sambit Patra, in New Delhi, asked AAP national convenor Arvind Kejriwal and Mann to clarify.
Static–dynamic linkage
Policing is a State subject, so the CBI can ordinarily investigate in a State only with that State's consent (DSPE Act, Section 6). Constitutional courts are the exception. The Supreme Court has held that a High Court can direct a CBI probe under Article 226 even without State consent. The reasoning is that the courts' power of judicial review cannot be cut down by a statutory consent requirement. It also holds that such a direction does not violate federalism or separation of powers. This power is used sparingly, when the State machinery appears unable or unwilling to investigate impartially. That is the ground the Bench relied on here.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Judiciary (writ jurisdiction, Art. 226); Federalism (Centre–State relations in policing); Statutory bodies (CBI, ED); Accountability. Also GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability.
Background primer
Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)
- What it is:
- The Centre's premier investigating agency for corruption and certain serious crimes. It functions under the Delhi Special Police Establishment (DSPE) Act, 1946.
- Founded:
- The Home Ministry set up the CBI by resolution in April 1963.
- Members:
- A police force of the Union government, drawing on central and State cadres. Its legal footing is Entry 80 of the Union List, which allows extension of police powers to other States with their permission.
- Mandate:
- Under Section 5 the Centre can extend its powers to States for specified offences, but Section 6 restricts this without that State government's consent.
- Why it matters:
- Policing is a State subject, so the law lets the agency operate within a State only with the State's consent.
Enforcement Directorate (ED)
- What it is:
- A central agency that investigates money laundering and foreign-exchange violations (PMLA, 2002; FEMA, 1999). It does not itself investigate the underlying ("predicate") corruption offence. It passes information on such offences to the police or other agencies. The article says the ED shared information with Punjab Police and that no investigation followed.
Additional context
- The ED had reportedly sent three letters to the Punjab DGP seeking registration of an FIR, but state police took no action.
- The ED's claims concern alleged cash-for-transfers involving the Officer on Special Duty to the Chief Minister.
- Legal position on consent: A Constitution Bench held that a High Court direction under Article 226 to the CBI to investigate an offence within a State, without that State's consent, neither impinges on federalism nor violates separation of powers.
- The High Court's Article 226 power cannot be taken away, curtailed or diluted by Section 6.
- Withdrawal of general consent does not affect pending investigations, nor does it limit a High Court's power to order a CBI probe.
- Caution on use: Such orders should not be passed as a matter of routine, or merely because a party alleges wrongdoing by the local police. The power is used sparingly and only in exceptional circumstances.
Mains dimensions
- Federalism and the CBI: Policing is a State subject, and several States have withdrawn general consent. Court-ordered probes are the constitutional route around that, but they raise "judicial overreach" and federal-balance concerns. The Supreme Court's reasoning is that judicial review cannot be curbed by Section 6.
- Failure of the first responder: The Bench's displeasure with Punjab Police, and the reported non-action on ED communications, show police dependence on the political executive. This links to police reforms (Prakash Singh case), and fixed tenures.
- Agency credibility: ED and CBI are often accused of political selectivity, especially against Opposition-ruled States. The court-ordered route shifts legitimacy to the judiciary. The Opposition and the ruling party both read the order in partisan terms.
- Corruption in transfers and postings: this undermines civil-service neutrality, Supreme Court directions on civil-service boards and fixed tenures (T.S.R. Subramanian, 2013), and administrative efficiency.
- Accountability: Bajwa's demand for resignation shows political accountability is being pursued through the Opposition and the courts, not within the State's own institutions.
- Way forward: time-bound investigations (here, a report in two months), an independent prosecution system, State vigilance bodies with real autonomy, and a clear protocol between the ED and State police on predicate offences.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Constitutional courts have increasingly directed CBI investigations into State-level allegations even without State consent. Examine the constitutional basis, the limits and the federal implications of this trend."
Related topics
- Article 226 vs Article 32; PIL jurisprudence
- DSPE Act, 1946 (Sections 5, 6 and 6A); Lokpal and Lokayuktas
- Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988; PMLA, 2002 (predicate offence and ED's role)
- Police reforms (Prakash Singh); civil-service transfers and postings (T.S.R. Subramanian)
- Centre–State relations in policing; withdrawal of general consent by States
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 6 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs