The ECI’s constitutional mandate is under strain
Source: The Hindu, 5 October 2026
Summary
The author argues that the Election Commission of India (ECI) is facing unprecedented public criticism over its Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. He calls the SIR legally unsupported, a mass disenfranchisement that violates Article 326, and the product of unilateral decisions by the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC). He draws on the Constituent Assembly's reasons for creating a central, executive-independent Election Commission, and says the accountability mechanisms against the CEC are weak.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections vested in the ECI. Article 324(5): the CEC is removable like a Supreme Court judge (linked to Article 124(4)).
- Article 326: elections to the Lok Sabha and Assemblies are on adult suffrage. It provides for registration of eligible citizens, subject to disqualification under law. The article says its scheme is to include voters, not exclude them.
- Section 21 of the RP Act, 1950:
- 21(1): preparation of the roll by reference to the qualifying date.
- 21(2): revision before each general election and each by-election, and in any year if the ECI directs.
- 21(3): a "special revision" for any constituency or part of one, for reasons recorded, in such manner as the ECI thinks fit.
- Rule 25, Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: a revision under Section 21(2) may be intensive, summary, or partly intensive and partly summary.
- Neither the Act nor the Rules uses the term "special intensive revision" (author's argument).
- Section 16 of the 2023 Act: immunity for the CEC and ECs from civil or criminal liability. The author notes even the President of India lacks such lifelong immunity.
- Draft Article 289 in the Constituent Assembly debates concerned the Election Commission.
- Presiding officers of the two Houses can disallow a removal motion at the threshold (as stated in the article).
Data and details
- Media reports cited: about 13 crore voters removed from the rolls across the country by SIR operations. The author calls it perhaps the biggest disenfranchisement exercise in any democracy.
- Two Election Commissioners have said they were not kept in the loop on crucial decisions taken by the CEC.
- The ECs themselves have called some CEC acts "illegal and unconstitutional" (per the article).
- The Draft Constitution proposed a decentralised machinery with a CEC in each province for State legislature rolls and polls, and a Centre-level CEC for Parliament, President and Vice-President elections.
- Ambedkar moved a new Article to centralise the machinery because provincial CECs, mostly nominees of Chief Ministers, had carried out large-scale deletion of voters regarded as opponents of the ruling party.
- Shibban Lal Saxena feared a future ruling party would appoint a staunch loyalist as CEC. He proposed that the President's appointee be approved by Parliament by a two-thirds majority, on the US Senate confirmation model.
- Opposition parties are preparing an impeachment (removal) motion against the CEC for serious misconduct. Misbehaviour must be proved.
- The author says the same complaint (mass deletion without adherence to law) has resurfaced almost 80 years later.
Static–dynamic linkage
The Constitution makes the ECI an independent constitutional authority under Article 324. It holds superintendence, direction and control over the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections. Where Parliament has made a law (the RP Act, 1950 and 1951, and the rules under them), the ECI must act within it. Article 324 is a residuary power for matters the statute does not cover. Article 326 sets universal adult suffrage as the basis of elections to the Lok Sabha and Assemblies. The news is an instance of the tension between the ECI's plenary power and the limits imposed by statute, the Constitution and collegial decision-making.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI), Representation of the People Acts, electoral reforms; GS2 – Polity: Separation of powers / accountability of independent institutions
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- A permanent constitutional body. Article 324 makes it the body that oversees national and state elections. The power of superintendence, direction and control covers elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Founded:
- Established in 1950 to ensure free and fair elections. The article adds the Constituent Assembly background (see Section 4).
- Members:
- One Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and as many other Election Commissioners (ECs) as the President decides. Currently one CEC and two ECs. Appointed by the President on the recommendation of a Selection Committee: the Prime Minister (chair), the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM. The term is six years or until age 65.
- Mandate:
- Prepare and revise electoral rolls and conduct elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Why it matters:
- The election machinery must sit outside executive control. The article attributes this to the Constituent Assembly.
CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023
- What it is:
- The law on appointment, tenure and removal of the CEC and ECs. It repealed the 1991 Act on conditions of service.
Additional context
- Explainers report that on 27 May 2026 the Supreme Court (bench led by CJI Surya Kant), in the ADR v. ECI batch on the Bihar SIR, upheld the constitutional and legal validity of the ECI's SIR. The Court held the exercise justified under Article 324 read with Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950. This ruling predates the article, which argues the opposite on the legal basis. It rejected the argument that "special revisions" are only for isolated constituencies, and allowed scaling up statewide or nationwide where systemic inaccuracies require it. It said the measures bear a reasonable nexus to their objectives and have sufficient safeguards against arbitrary exclusion. The article's Section 21 argument has to be read against this ruling.
- A UPSC-explainer source puts total deletions at about 13 crore, with about 14 crore projected once ongoing phases finish. It says the deletion share rose from about 8% in Bihar (Phase I) to over 13% in Phase II and past 15% in Phase III.
- On the appointment framework: the 2023 law removed the CJI from the selection process laid down in the Anoop Baranwal case. Commentary notes that the committee's composition gives the ruling side a 2:1 majority. The law is under challenge in Jaya Thakur v. Union of India. Reports say that on 23 September 2026 the Supreme Court referred the petitions to a five-judge Constitution Bench.
Mains dimensions
- Historical-constitutional intent: The Constituent Assembly centralised the machinery precisely to prevent executive-linked authorities from deleting opponents' voters. The author sees the current SIR as a recurrence of that danger.
- Legality of SIR: He argues Section 21(3) is limited to "any constituency or part", so a statewide or nationwide special intensive revision has no statutory basis, and Article 324 cannot override statute. (Counterpoint: the Supreme Court's reported ruling upholding SIR, in 2b.)
- Rights dimension: Article 326 aims at inclusion, but about 13 crore deletions suggest exclusion is the real effect. This raises Articles 14 and 326 and the Basic Structure.
- Institutional functioning: Unilateral CEC decisions bypass collegiality. The author argues a decision by the CEC alone is not valid in law, and everything that flows from it lacks legal validity.
- Accountability gap:
- Removal needs proven misbehaviour and a special majority.
- Presiding officers can stop a motion at the threshold.
- Section 16 of the 2023 Act gives lifelong immunity.
- The author concludes there is no effective check on an "omnipotent" ECI.
- Reform pointers: Parliamentary or broader-based confirmation of appointments (Saxena's idea), a collegial decision-making protocol, and a clear statutory basis for any large-scale revision.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Election Commission's independence is as much about how it exercises its powers as about how it is constituted. Discuss in the light of the controversy over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls."
Related topics
- Article 324 plenary power: its scope and limits (statute vs. residuary power)
- Anoop Baranwal case and the 2023 appointment law
- Article 326, universal adult suffrage and the right to vote
- Removal of constitutional office-holders (Article 124(4) procedure)
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: revision types and deletion safeguards
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 5 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs