BrainParrot

‘En masse exclusion of voters unconstitutional’

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 5 October 2026

Summary

Supreme Court judge Justice Ujjal Bhuyan, speaking at NALSAR, Hyderabad on Sunday, said any process that disenfranchises millions is intrinsically arbitrary. He said it violates universal adult suffrage (Article 326) and the right to equality (Article 14). He called the right to be a voter a constitutional right within the Basic Structure, and said that except for dead voters, no name can be deleted without notice and hearing. The remarks came as the SIR had led to about 13.3 crore deletions. The Front-page item (p.1) was a short pointer to this report.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Universal adult suffrage, Article 326, Basic Structure, electoral rolls

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 326: adult suffrage; Article 14: equality before the law. The judge said mass disenfranchisement violates both.
  • Voting right vs. freedom of voting: the first is statutory/constitutional (debated); the second is Article 19(1)(a).
  • Government of India Act, 1935: "partial franchise" with property, tax, residence, literacy and other qualifications in 'Part A' States.
  • Basic Structure doctrine: the judge placed the right to be a voter within it.
  • Rule stated: except for a dead voter, a name once enlisted cannot be deleted without notice and hearing.
  • Universal adult franchise (as described by the judge): the right of every adult citizen to vote free of qualifications of sex, race, religion, wealth, education or social status, subject only to narrow, reasoned exceptions.
  • NALSAR University of Law is in Hyderabad (venue of the speech).

Data and details

  • SIR has so far led to about 13.3 crore deletions.
  • Justice Rohinton F. Nariman (former SC judge) had pointed to an "astounding figure" of 90 lakh disenfranchised voters in West Bengal alone. He questioned why it did not prompt the Court to stay the SIR. He called the exclusion, and delay in deciding appeals, "a completely illegal knocking out of the common man".
  • Under the 1935 Act, 'Part A' State voters accounted for only about 14% of the population.
  • The judge said: no authority can tinker with universal adult suffrage, no court can condone it, and "no amount of whataboutery" can justify mass exclusion.
  • He called citizenship and franchise intertwined, and the vote the only way an ordinary citizen participates in governance.
  • He said the Constitution does not provide for two classes of citizens, those with and without voting rights. He added that no one is above the Constitution and that the right to vote is intertwined with India's long struggle for freedom.
  • The Constituent Assembly, while embracing universal adult suffrage, found the 1935 Act's restrictions arbitrary and retrograde (as recorded in the article).

Static–dynamic linkage

The Constitution adopted adult suffrage without property, literacy, gender or caste conditions. The news raises a long-running legal question: whether the right to vote is only statutory or also constitutional. It also asks what procedural safeguards (notice, hearing, appeal) protect electors against deletion from the roll.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental Rights (Article 14), Representation of the People Acts, electoral reforms; Basic Structure doctrine; GS1 – Society/History: Freedom Struggle and the franchise

Background primer

Universal Adult Suffrage (Article 326)

What it is:
Article 326 mandates elections on the basis of universal adult suffrage and ensures every citizen aged 18 or above can be registered as a voter. Legal disqualifications include non-residence in the constituency, unsoundness of mind declared by a court, specified criminal convictions and corrupt electoral practices.
Mandate:
Equal vote value for every adult citizen. In the judge's words, a billionaire and a rickshaw puller, or a temple priest and a manual scavenger, have equal votes.

Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls

What it is:
A comprehensive, door-to-door verification and update of electoral rolls by the ECI to produce accurate, error-free voter lists.

Additional context

  • Status of the right to vote in case law: In Kuldip Nayar (2006), a five-judge Bench characterised the right to elect as statutory rather than an independent Fundamental Right. Earlier decisions (Ponnuswami 1952, Jyoti Basu 1982) also treated voting as a statutory right. Rajbala (2015) described voting as a constitutional right. Justice Bhuyan's statement that the right to be a voter is constitutional and within the Basic Structure aligns with the second line of thought.
  • Freedom of voting: Freedom of voting, meaning the expression of a choice including NOTA, is recognised under Article 19(1)(a).
  • Basic Structure: The doctrine originates in Kesavananda Bharati (1973). The Supreme Court has since treated free and fair elections as part of the Basic Structure (e.g., Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain, 1975).
  • Notice and hearing in ECI's own norms: In all proposed deletions, except confirmed deaths, ECI guidance requires a notice to the elector and a reasonable opportunity of hearing. Rule 21A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 also provides for notice, inquiry and hearing before deletion. This parallels the judge's "except a dead voter" remark.
  • Supreme Court on SIR: In ADR v. ECI (27 May 2026), a bench led by CJI Surya Kant upheld the Bihar SIR as traceable to Article 324 read with Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950, and as proportionate and procedurally safeguarded. The Court also noted that SIR decisions are subject to judicial review. It ordered that persons deleted on citizenship grounds be referred to the competent authority, with restoration of voting rights if they are found to be citizens. The judgment's summary on the Supreme Court's website also describes the right to vote as a constitutional right that is not absolute. Justice Bhuyan's remarks must be read against this ruling.

Mains dimensions

  • Rights approach: A process that leaves millions without a vote creates "second class citizens". The judge sees this as arbitrary under Article 14 and as striking at the Basic Structure.
  • Constitutional vs. statutory right: The judge's view pushes beyond Kuldip Nayar and bears on the court's review of ECI action.
  • Procedural fairness: Deletion without notice and hearing is unsustainable. The Nariman remark on delayed appeals shows that remedies matter as much as rights.
  • Historical context: The 1935 Act's restricted franchise (about 14% of the population) is contrasted with the Constituent Assembly's universal franchise. This links the vote to the freedom struggle.
  • Judicial speech and propriety: A sitting judge's public remarks on a contested public-policy issue raise questions about judicial restraint and institutional balance (analytical angle; the article reports only the remarks).
  • Way forward: Clear appeal timelines, restoration mechanisms, data-driven checks against inflated deletions, and consistent notice-and-hearing safeguards.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Is the right to vote a constitutional right or merely a statutory right? Examine in the light of the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls and recent judicial observations."

Related topics

  • Article 14 and arbitrariness (manifest arbitrariness doctrine)
  • Basic Structure doctrine and free and fair elections
  • Kuldip Nayar (2006), Rajbala (2015) and Article 19(1)(a) on freedom of voting
  • Government of India Act, 1935 (franchise) and the Constituent Assembly debates
  • Cross-reference: ECI constitutional mandate editorial; ERO/ERONET notice-disposal note

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 5 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs