EC releases video for EROs on SIR notice disposal; no written instructions so fa...
Source: The Hindu, 5 October 2026
Summary
The ECI added three options to its ERONET portal that let Electoral Registration Officers (EROs) dispose of SIR notice cases without hearings or documents. It is explaining them through an eight-minute demonstration video made by its IT Department, with no written instructions circulated so far, sources told The Hindu. The options are available in the 10 States/UTs where the third SIR phase is under way. They follow EROs' demands since the notice phase began, and allegations that centralising ERONET under ECINET curtailed EROs' powers.
Key facts for Prelims
- ERO: final authority over preparation of electoral rolls in his constituency (as per the article).
- BLO: booth-level officer who collects documents door-to-door and uploads them.
- ERONET: ECI portal used by EROs; ECINET: ECI's unified platform that absorbs ERONET (see 2a).
- ECI "ERO" decisions: Section 22, RP Act, 1950 (correction, transposition, deletion).
- Categories in SIR notices named in the article: "logical discrepancies" and "no mapping". Other categories named: Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate (plus "suspected foreigners", which the ERO says was later withdrawn).
- The ECI has prescribed a list of 12 documents for electors served notices over logical discrepancies and no mapping.
Data and details
- Three new ERONET options: (1) mark an elector "found OK" for the final roll without uploading a hearing order, where a notice was generated and the BLO has uploaded documents; (2) mark an elector eligible after uploading a hearing order, using the option "Proceed marking this elector as eligible without BLO documents", where the BLO collected no documents; (3) at the notice-generating stage, for "no mapping" and "logical discrepancies" electors in the draft roll, choose between "without hearing" and "with hearing".
- Earlier, a hearing order (with reasons) was needed only to mark an elector "found not eligible".
- Scale: third-phase SIR is under way in 10 States/UTs. Final rolls are already published in nine of the 16 States and three UTs where SIR is running, and in 13 States/UTs where it finished in the first two phases.
- West Bengal: 27 lakh of the 60 lakh electors served notices were left out of the final roll. Over nine crore notices have been served so far in the second and third phases.
- The eight-minute video was recorded on October 1 and shown to Delhi EROs at a meeting on Saturday. Delhi EROs could access the options from September 30.
- The EC's September 26 release said noticed persons need not visit centres, BLOs would collect documents door-to-door, and hearings would be online only in exceptional cases.
- Delhi: all 33.1 lakh notices already carry hearing venue and time. The notice phase runs till November 30, and the final roll is pushed to December 4.
- Other final-roll dates: Haryana, Maharashtra and Telangana in November, Tripura in February 2027. The notice phase is under way in only nine States, with five final rolls due later this month.
- More than 350 electors in Delhi were marked "found ineligible". The Delhi CEO cautioned EROs against choosing the option without proper verification (reported September 27).
- EROs still cannot reverse a case once an elector is marked ineligible.
- No written instructions had been circulated; the video is the only communication so far.
- An unnamed ERO said SIR instructions have been a mix of written and oral, many later withdrawn. He gave the example of "suspected foreigners": EROs were first told to identify them, then, mid-enumeration in Delhi, told not to. He said that although the RP Act authorises him to decide, SIR guidelines have differed, and he will wait for written communication.
Static–dynamic linkage
Under the RP Act, 1950, an ERO is a statutory authority who decides on inclusion and deletion in the roll. The ECI superintends under Article 324 and can issue directions. The news raises the question of how far centralised software and oral or video instructions can shape a statutory officer's discretion, and whether instructions given this way are transparent and accountable.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI), RP Act 1950 and Registration of Electors Rules 1960; GS2 – Governance: e-governance, accountability and discretion of statutory officers
Background primer
Electoral Registration Officer (ERO), Assistant ERO (AERO) and Booth Level Officer (BLO)
- What it is:
- The roll for each constituency is prepared and revised by an ERO, an officer of the State government; AEROs assist him. AEROs can perform all the ERO's functions subject to his control.
- Why it matters:
- Decisions on a citizen's name sit with a local statutory officer who acts after inquiry. The ECI guides but does not decide individual cases.
ERONET and ECINET
Additional context
- A UPSC-explainer source reports that Maharashtra's Chief Electoral Officer sought changes to ECINET to preserve EROs' statutory discretion in resolving voter-data discrepancies during SIR, amid concerns over centralised software controls.
- The same source says centralised software often lacks effective rollback mechanisms for local EROs to reinstate incorrectly flagged electors. This is relevant to the article's point that EROs cannot reverse a case once marked ineligible.
- Rule 21A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 requires the ERO, before deleting a person on grounds such as non-residence, to make every endeavour to give a reasonable opportunity to show cause.
- Appeals against ERO decisions under Rules 20, 21 and 21A lie under Section 24 of the RP Act: the first appeal goes to the District Magistrate (or equivalent officer), and the second to the Chief Electoral Officer. Each appeal must be presented within fifteen days.
- The Supreme Court upheld the SIR order by its order dated 27 May 2026.
Mains dimensions
- Statutory discretion vs. central control: The Act vests decisions in the ERO. Allegations that ECINET curtails field officers' powers, and EROs' own demand for these options, show the tension between centralised IT systems and statutory autonomy.
- Rules by video: No written instruction means weak accountability, hard-to-audit decisions, and legal uncertainty for officers and electors alike.
- Retrospectivity and fairness: The options arrive after final rolls were published in 13 States/UTs where SIR finished in the first two phases, and in nine States/UTs in the current phase. In these States, officers could not clear cases without hearings or documents. The West Bengal figure (27 lakh of 60 lakh noticed left out) shows the cost.
- Asymmetry: EROs can now mark electors eligible without documents, but cannot undo an "ineligible" marking. This raises the case for a rollback and appeal mechanism.
- Shifting guidelines: The "suspected foreigners" reversal shows instability in rules during a live exercise.
- Way forward: Written, published instructions; audit trails; restoring EROs' ability to correct errors; a transparent appeal route.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 10 marks:** "Examine how centralised digital platforms and informal instructions may affect the statutory discretion of Electoral Registration Officers during electoral roll revision."
Related topics
- Section 22 and Section 24 of the RP Act, 1950; Rules 20, 21 and 21A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
- ECINET and e-governance in electoral administration
- Delegated legislation, administrative directions and legal accountability
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 5 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs