BrainParrot

State of anticipation

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 30 September 2026

Summary

  • On September 28 the J&K Assembly passed a resolution urging the Centre to restore "full Statehood" to the nearly seven-year-old Union Territory.
  • Chief Minister Omar Abdullah moved it. It followed earlier Assembly resolutions on autonomy and special status.
  • All parties except the 29 BJP MLAs in the 90-member House backed it.
  • The editorial argues that the downgrade was unprecedented and unhealthy. It says the Centre should reward the peaceful 2024 election by empowering the legislature.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Federalism, Union Territories, J&K reorganisation

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 370 was abrogated on 5 August 2019. The J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019 created UT J&K (with legislature) and UT Ladakh (without).
  • Article 3 empowers Parliament to form new States and alter the boundaries or names of existing States.
  • UT legislatures: Puducherry under Article 239A and Delhi under Article 239AA (69th Amendment). J&K's UT model was compared to Article 239A, while Delhi's Article 239AA has its own limits on the Assembly's powers.
  • The UT has a Lieutenant Governor, not a Governor.
  • The Constitution Bench ruling is titled In Re: Article 370 of the Constitution (2023).

Data and details

  • The Assembly resolution was passed on September 28. The UT is nearly seven years old. The special status had lasted close to 70 years.
  • The House has 90 members. The 29 BJP legislators did not support the resolution. The ruling alliance parties, Congress, CPI(M) and Independents backed it. So did the Opposition PDP, J&K Peoples Conference, AAP and Awami Ittehad Party.
  • Earlier resolutions: the greater autonomy resolution of June 26, 2000, and the special status resolution of November 6, 2024.
  • The editorial calls it a rare bid by Mr. Abdullah on Statehood since he won the election two years ago.
  • The Centre's three-step path is delimitation, election, Statehood. The Supreme Court wanted Statehood restored "as soon as possible". The PM promised it "at the appropriate time", in Parliament and outside.
  • 2024 election: 63.88% voting, and the editorial calls it the most peaceful in three decades, "not a bullet fired". The region went through three decades of militant violence.

Static–dynamic linkage

A State is a constituent unit of the federation with its own constitutionally guaranteed legislature and executive (Part VI). A Union Territory is administered under Part VIII (Article 239). Parliament can create, alter or merge States under Article 3. Whether Parliament can permanently convert a State into a UT is the deeper federal question. The Supreme Court did not conclusively decide it in 2023. The Centre's own "delimitation → election → Statehood" sequence is the roadmap against which the delay is judged.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Federal features of the Constitution; Parliament's power to reorganise States (Article 3); Union Territories; judicial directions vs. executive assurances.

Background primer

Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019

What it is:
A Parliamentary law passed in August 2019 (Rajya Sabha on 5 August, Lok Sabha on 6 August) that bifurcated the State of J&K into two Union Territories, J&K and Ladakh.
Founded:
It came alongside the Presidential orders under Article 370 that ended the State's special status. The President issued the Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 2019 on 5 August 2019.
Members:
UT J&K has an Assembly like Delhi and Puducherry, with a Lieutenant Governor in place of a Governor. Ladakh is a UT without a legislature. Leh and Kargil districts went to Ladakh. The J&K Assembly has a five-year term.
Mandate:
As framed in the 2019 Bill (Section 32), the Assembly can legislate on State and Concurrent List subjects except "public order" and "police". This is similar to the Puducherry model under Article 239A (Delhi's legislature is under Article 239AA).
Why it matters:
The stated case was fuller integration, since Article 370 was said to hinder complete integration and development.

In Re: Article 370 of the Constitution (Supreme Court, December 2023)

What it is:
A five-judge Constitution Bench unanimously upheld the abrogation, holding that J&K had no internal sovereignty and Article 370 was temporary.

Mains dimensions

  • Federal and democratic deficit: The editorial calls the downgrade of a full State to a UT unprecedented. An elected Assembly operating under a UT framework (with the LG and no authority over public order and police) cannot fully answer to voters.
  • Reciprocity argument: Voters shunned boycott politics in 2024, with 63.88% turnout and a violence-free poll. The editorial says the Centre should reciprocate by empowering the legislature they voted for.
  • A chain of commitments unmet: The Centre's own three-step roadmap, the Supreme Court's "as soon as possible", and the PM's promise "at the appropriate time" all point to restoration. The editorial says the wait has been too long and the Court's direction should be respected without delay.
  • Security-conditionality critique: The editorial backs Mr. Abdullah's view that tying Statehood to the end of militancy gives Pakistan and state-sponsored terrorism a say in an Indian constitutional decision.
  • Legislature vs. streets: An empowered House should be the forum for dialogue with the Centre, so that J&K does not drift away from the federal and democratic process.
  • Cross-party consensus: Support came from ruling and Opposition parties, including regional rivals, with only the BJP's 29 MLAs not supporting. This shows the demand is not one party's agenda.
  • Counter-view to weigh: The government's case rests on security and normalcy. Ladakh's separate UT status is a distinct question that the Court did not tie to statehood.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The restoration of Statehood to Jammu and Kashmir is as much a test of Indian federalism and judicial-executive accountability as it is a question of security. Discuss."

Related topics

  • Article 370, Article 35A and the 2019 Presidential orders
  • Articles 3 and 4: Parliament's power to reorganise States
  • Articles 239A and 239AA: Delhi/Puducherry legislatures and LG-government relations
  • Asymmetric federalism: Article 371 series, Fifth/Sixth Schedules
  • Delimitation Commission and its role in J&K

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 30 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs