Dissent in the Commission
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 27 September 2026
Summary
- Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi reportedly recorded formal objections to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls over about 10 months. One note went to the Cabinet Secretary. The Opposition has demanded the removal of CEC Gyanesh Kumar.
- Their objections covered centralised control of the rolls (ERONet), an altered Form 6, and software that could not record ERO decisions.
- Opposition parties, Left groups, trade unions and farm outfits are building a campaign. The INDIA bloc is to meet in Delhi on Sept. 30. Congress has asked the Supreme Court to take suo motu cognisance.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324(1): superintendence, direction and control of elections vested in the ECI. Art. 324(2): the President appoints the CEC and ECs, subject to any law made by Parliament.
- Art. 324(5): the CEC can be removed "in like manner and on the like grounds" as a Supreme Court judge. The parliamentary procedure for this is in the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968, and only then does the President order removal. Grounds are proved misbehaviour or incapacity.
- Art. 324(5): an EC or Regional Commissioner cannot be removed except on the CEC's recommendation.
- Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (March 2023, five-judge Constitution Bench): until Parliament legislated, appointments would be on the recommendation of a committee of PM, LoP (Lok Sabha) and CJI. The PIL was filed in January 2015.
- 2023 Act: in force January 2024; Selection Committee is PM + LoP + a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM; Search Committee headed by the Law Minister prepares a panel of five.
- Section 16, 2023 Act: protects a person who "is or was" CEC or EC from civil or criminal proceedings in court for acts or words done in the course of official duty. It does not expressly use the words "arrest", "investigation" or "police custody", so it is not blanket immunity from arrest.
- Section 18, 2023 Act (carried forward from the 1991 Act): the Commission decides unanimously where possible. Otherwise it follows the majority opinion, each Commissioner carries equal weight, and the CEC has no special veto.
- S.S. Dhanoa v. Union of India (1991) and T.N. Seshan (Constitution Bench, upheld a multi-member EC): vast discretionary powers with no checks should not rest with one person. ECs "must have a say in decision-making", and the Court rejected the argument that their role is only to advise the CEC.
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: Form 6 is the statutory form for new voters. The two ECs said it cannot be changed without amending these Rules.
- 2023 Act has no automatic-succession clause: the senior-most EC does not automatically become CEC. Every CEC appointment goes through the fresh appointment process, unlike the earlier convention.
- Split verdict: a Division Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and S.C. Sharma split on the Union's plea for a larger-bench reference of the challenge to the 2023 Act. One question is whether replacing the CJI with a Cabinet Minister is valid.
Data and details
- Timeline of dissent: objections recorded at least 14 times over about 10 months, according to The Indian Express expose cited in The Hindu. Opposition sought the CEC's removal on Sept 23.
- Appointments: Sandhu was appointed with Gyanesh Kumar on March 14, 2024, after the retirement of EC Anup Chandra Pandey and the abrupt resignation of EC Arun Goel. Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury gave a formal dissent note in the committee. Joshi was appointed on Feb 17, 2025, after Kumar was elevated to CEC. Rahul Gandhi objected in the committee meeting.
- May: Joshi proposed an audit to certify that no one except the concerned statutory authorities has credentials to change the voter database.
- August: Sandhu recorded that State-level officials lack "proper and complete access" to the ERONet portal. He said the EC's Director General of IT has no legal authority to restrict access given by law to statutory authorities.
- Form 6: altered to ask whether the applicant or parents/grandparents "exist" in the last SIR roll. The ECs warned in May. In August Sandhu called it "unauthorised and illegal" and sought its immediate removal.
- West Bengal: Sandhu questioned who authorised the Commission to appeal against voters whom judicial tribunals had included. 38 lakh appeals are pending.
- Goa: 97 voters found eligible by EROs after a Supreme Court-mandated hearing were left off the final roll because the centrally controlled software had no mechanism to record ERO decisions. The CEO's office wrote eight times seeking a rollback option.
- Sandhu: retired 1988-batch IAS (Uttarakhand), born 1963; MBBS (Govt Medical College, Amritsar), MA History (Guru Nanak Dev University), law degree. Chief Secretary of Uttarakhand July 2021–January 2024, credited with overseeing ideation for the UCC. Earlier NHAI Chairman and Additional Secretary, Higher Education. As Commissioner, Ludhiana MC, he received the President's Medal. Secretary, Lokpal, Feb 5–Mar 14, 2024. Retires July 2028.
- Joshi: born May 21, 1966 (UP); 1989-batch IAS (Haryana); mechanical engineer (IIT Roorkee); master's in International Business (IIFT); MA and PhD in International Economics (Graduate Institute, Geneva). Financial Services Secretary; Registrar General and Census Commissioner; member-secretary, Fifth State Finance Commission of Haryana. Appointed EC at 58 after voluntary retirement. Brother Vineet Joshi (1992 batch) is Secretary, Higher Education. Term runs to February 2031.
- Succession arithmetic: if Kumar demits in January 2029, Joshi becomes senior-most. If Kumar leaves before July 2028, Sandhu is senior-most because he was appointed first.
- Congress allegation (Jairam Ramesh): the online Form 6 was altered in July without notification or rule amendment, and only the Union government can amend it. He asked the Supreme Court to take suo motu cognisance, and the BJP (president Nitin Nabin) called this a "manufactured lie".
- Opposition unity: Mamata Banerjee said the INDIA bloc will meet in Delhi on Sept 30. CPI(M) general secretary M.A. Baby wrote to her about unity against the CEC. She also spoke to LoP Rahul Gandhi and expects regional parties to join. She said Kumar's "days are numbered".
- Wider campaign: the Left, Samyukt Kisan Morcha (SKM), trade unions and student/youth groups are stepping up protests. AISA says the Form 6 edit targets Gen Z. CITU cites disenfranchisement of poor and migrant workers. SKM demands removal and prosecution, and calls the CEC's conduct "treason".
- CPI(ML) Bihar survey (2025 SIR): the party lost Aigaon by 95 votes and Ziradei by 2,626.
- Aigaon, 3 booths: of 204 voters deleted before SIR, 46 (22.5%) still lived in their villages.
- Aigaon, 4 booths: of 665 deleted during SIR, 77 were living in the village. More than 2,000 may be wrongly excluded across Aigaon.
- Ziradei, 9 booths: 122 of 665 deleted during SIR still lived in the village, and 15 of 189 deleted before SIR.
- Press freedom: Delhi Police detained Frontline's Vedaant Lakhera and The Wire's Mohammad Irfan while they covered a Jantar Mantar protest on Friday. Both wore press IDs. Lakhera was taken to Parliament Street police station and told to delete a photo, which he did not do. Irfan was held for several hours at Dwarka. The Press Club of India condemned this. AISA said police were not allowing protests around Jantar Mantar.
- Political proximity allegation (Kerala): former Keralam Chief Secretary Jiji Thomson said Kumar suggested, on a 2015–16 flight, that he contest the 2019 Lok Sabha polls from Pathanamthitta on a BJP ticket, adding that he would likely get a Cabinet berth as a minority-community candidate. Thomson called it a "friendly suggestion", not an offer.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Article 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of elections in the ECI. Its independence depends on three things: how members are appointed, how they are removed, and whether it works collegially.
- The CEC has judge-like security of tenure. An EC can be removed only on the CEC's recommendation, so the two ECs are structurally more vulnerable than the CEC.
- The Commission decides by consensus or majority, and the CEC has no casting veto. This is why experts ask why the two ECs did not force a full-Commission vote.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission, Art. 324); appointment, tenure and removal; statutory vs. constitutional protections; Representation of the People Act and electoral reforms
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- a permanent constitutional body under Art. 324 for the conduct of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President. It is also responsible for managing the preparation of electoral rolls.
- Founded:
- 25 January 1950. It became multi-member briefly in 1989, the extra posts were abolished in 1990, and the multi-member structure was restored permanently in 1993. The Supreme Court upheld this structure in the T.N. Seshan case.
- Members:
- one CEC plus such number of other ECs as the President fixes; currently one CEC and two ECs. Decisions are by consensus or majority vote.
- Mandate:
- conduct elections and prepare and maintain electoral rolls, with quasi-judicial functions.
- Why it matters:
- the Constituent Assembly intended an independent ECI, as the Supreme Court noted in 2023.
CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023
- What it is:
- the statute on appointment, tenure and service conditions of the CEC and ECs. It repealed the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of Election Commissioners and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991.
- Why it matters:
- it fills the Art. 324(2) vacuum. Critics say the committee is government-dominated because it replaced the CJI with a Cabinet Minister.
Additional context
- Vision IAS (25 Sept 2026) reported that the Opposition planned to move a motion in Parliament to remove the CEC. It restated that removal follows the Supreme Court judge procedure on grounds of proved misbehaviour or incapacity.
- This route has been tried before. A notice signed by 130 Lok Sabha and 63 Rajya Sabha members was filed on 12 March 2026 under Art. 324(5) read with Art. 124(4) and the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968. The Speaker and the Rajya Sabha Chairman refused to admit it under Section 3 of the 1968 Act. This shows the presiding officer's gatekeeping role at the admission stage.
- Removal requires a motion passed by both Houses in the same session. It needs a majority of total membership of each House plus at least two-thirds of members present and voting.
- The Law Commission's 255th report (2015) recommended amending Art. 324(5) to give ECs the same removal protection as the CEC. PRS had also flagged this lack of parity in the removal procedure when the 2023 Bill was introduced.
- Critics note that the 2023 Act's Selection Committee (PM + a Cabinet Minister he nominates, versus the LoP) gives the executive a 2:1 majority. The Supreme Court itself noted this structure while examining the challenge to the Act in May 2026.
Mains dimensions
- Institutional independence: the three safeguards (appointment, removal, collegiality) all drew scrutiny at once.
- Appointments: the two ECs were chosen under a committee where the executive holds a 2:1 majority, and the Opposition recorded dissent on both appointments. The Supreme Court's Anoop Baranwal model gave the CJI a seat, which the 2023 Act replaced.
- Removal: the CEC is protected like a judge, but ECs depend on the CEC's recommendation. This asymmetry is why dissenting ECs are exposed.
- Collegiality: Dhanoa and Seshan warn against one-person control. The reported centralisation of roll management, with field officers lacking access, tests that principle.
- Rule of law within the Commission: the objections are legal, not merely policy-based. A statutory form was altered without amending the Rules. The DG (IT) restricted access that statute gives to EROs. Software could not record ERO decisions. This is an "administrative technology overriding statutory authority" argument.
- Why the process failed internally: experts, including former ECs, ask why the ECs did not call a full-Commission meeting and use a majority vote. The CEC has no veto. The weakness is that dissent went through notes and the Cabinet Secretary, not through the Commission's own voting mechanism.
- Accountability options and limits:
- Parliamentary removal needs a special majority in both Houses, proof of misbehaviour or incapacity, and an inquiry, so it is an extremely hard route.
- Section 16 shields official acts from court proceedings. Whether it covers arrest is textually unsettled, so demands for arrest or prosecution are legally contested.
- Suo motu cognisance is a possible but uncertain route.
- Federal and ground-level effects: field officers (EROs/BLOs) and State CEOs bear statutory duties. The Goa and West Bengal examples show central software and central appeals overriding local statutory decisions.
- Democratic climate: opposition unity (INDIA bloc meeting), labour and farm-group mobilisation, and the detention of two journalists at a protest raise concerns about space for dissent. The BJP's counter-narrative is that the allegations are manufactured.
- Succession and perception: with no automatic seniority succession, the next CEC is a fresh choice made by the same committee. This could affect how independent Commissioners behave. The Kerala claim of political overtures is a perception issue, and Thomson himself called it only a "friendly suggestion".
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The independence of the Election Commission rests on constitutional safeguards, statutory design and institutional conventions. In light of recent disagreements within the Commission, critically examine whether the 2023 framework for appointment, removal and decision-making adequately protects its autonomy."
Related topics
- Art. 124(4) and the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 (removal procedure); other bodies with judge-like removal (CAG, UPSC, SC/HC judges)
- Representation of the People Acts, 1950 and 1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960; Form 6/Form 7
- Anoop Baranwal; Dhanoa; Seshan; collegium-style appointments to constitutional bodies
- Special Intensive Revision and voter exclusion
- Suo motu jurisdiction and PILs; freedom of the press and the right to protest (Arts. 19(1)(a), 19(1)(b))
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 27 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs