BrainParrot

What is Karnataka’s objection to the ESA?

GS3Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 27 September 2026

Summary

  • On Sept 22, the Karnataka Legislature unanimously passed a resolution rejecting the Kasturirangan Committee report on the Western Ghats in its current form. This responded to the seventh draft ESA notification published July 27 by the Union Environment Ministry, which gave the State 60 days to object.
  • The resolution asks for one year to conduct a physical survey and wants Karnataka's portion not finalised until then. The State will set up a high-level committee headed by a retired judge with all stakeholders.
  • It is the seventh time Karnataka has rejected the draft, which was first published in 2014.

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Environment: conservation, ecologically sensitive areas, development vs. ecology; GS2 — Federalism

Key facts for Prelims

  • Kasturirangan HLWG: reviewed the Gadgil (WGEEP) report; set up in 2012, reported in 2013.
  • Gadgil panel (WGEEP): the entire Western Ghats as ESA (about 1.29 lakh sq km), with Ecologically Sensitive Zones 1, 2 and 3.
  • Kasturirangan: the Western Ghats (1.64 lakh sq km) divided into natural and cultural landscapes. Of the natural landscape, 59,940 sq km (37% of the area) was proposed as ESA.
  • States covered: Keralam, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Goa, Maharashtra and Gujarat. Karnataka has the largest ESA area, spread across 10 districts.
  • Banned activities (report): mining, quarrying, sand extraction, red-category industries, thermal power plants, and buildings beyond 20,000 sq m; also township and area development projects.
  • Regulated: infrastructure and development projects need environmental clearances; hydroelectric projects allowed with conditions. Projects within 10 km of ESA needing clearance are regulated under the EIA Notification, 2006.
  • Other recommendations: financial arrangements and incentives for Green Growth, and a decision-support and monitoring centre.
  • Western Ghats: the article describes them as recognised by UNESCO as one of the world's ecological hotspots.
  • Karnataka terms: Bagair Hukum (land cultivation), deemed forest, forest rights and land grants.
  • "Keralam model": physical verification by the State and submission to the Centre.

Data and details

  • Draft timeline: first published in 2014. The seventh draft was published July 27 with a 60-day window. The resolution was passed Sept 22 and is the seventh rejection by Karnataka.
  • Area per report (sq km, villages): Karnataka 20,668 (1,576); Maharashtra 17,340 (2,159); Keralam 13,108 (123); Tamil Nadu 6,914 (135); Gujarat 449 (64); Goa 1,461 (99). Total 59,940 sq km over 4,156 villages.
  • Current draft: 56,825 sq km after Keralam's ground survey cut its area to 9,993 sq km. Maharashtra and Goa villages rose, Karnataka's fell, and the total is 4,402 villages. About 41% of the Ghats is natural landscape, and the 37% subset is biologically rich with low fragmentation and low population density, and contains protected areas, World Heritage Sites and tiger and elephant corridors.
  • Karnataka's contentions: ESA should cover only notified forest and other forest areas. It should not cover plantations, agriculture, horticulture, residential or public areas. The areas were demarcated with satellite data, not a joint survey. There is no accurate bifurcation of revenue and forest land and no livelihood alternatives. Entire villages should not be included when about one-fifth of a village's area may be forest.
  • Ground reality: fears of restrictions on agriculture, housing and daily activities by "zealous" forest officials. Misinformation claims that building or renovation will be halted, though no such restriction is proposed. There is also concern about loss of land value and lower agricultural investment.
  • Karnataka's response: unanimous resolution in both Houses cutting across party lines, asking for one year to carry out a physical survey and for no finalisation until then. A high-level committee headed by a retired judge will review shortcomings and suggest modifications. Legislators urged following the Keralam model.
  • Public consultations were held in the Malnad region, and there have been widespread protests.
  • Finalisation process: the actual ESA area is to be finalised on the basis of State government recommendations, stakeholder views and the ESA Expert Committee.
  • Further Karnataka demand: appeals and legal cases should also be considered in the demarcation, and the above issues should be examined by an expert committee through a physical survey.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • An Ecologically Sensitive Area (ESA) is a notified region where certain activities are banned or regulated under environment law to protect fragile ecosystems. The draft notification procedure gives States time to object.
  • The core tension is between ecological protection and livelihoods, shown by the Gadgil and Kasturirangan reports. The States' objections turn on how land is classified, how boundaries are drawn (satellite versus ground survey) and whether people's rights are recognised.
  • The Western Ghats are biologically rich and fragile and spread over six States, so a uniform national decision needs State cooperation.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 — Environment: Conservation, environmental pollution and degradation, EIA; Western Ghats biodiversity; GS2 — Centre–State relations in environmental governance

Background primer

Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel (Gadgil, 2011) and High Level Working Group (Kasturirangan, 2012–13)

What it is:
two expert reviews on protecting the Western Ghats. The HLWG was constituted to advise the government on the recommendations of the earlier Gadgil-led WGEEP.
Members:
the Gadgil panel was chaired by Prof. Madhav Gadgil and the HLWG by space scientist K. Kasturirangan.
Mandate:
WGEEP recommended declaring the entire Western Ghats an ESA, with three levels of categorisation and a Western Ghats Ecology Authority. The HLWG recommended notifying a smaller ESA and regulating activities in it.
Why it matters:
the Western Ghats are fragile and biologically rich. The HLWG separated natural landscapes (to be protected) from cultural landscapes that have sustained lives but lost their original character, and it demarcated the ESA using satellite data (the data Karnataka contests).

Mains dimensions

  • Ecology versus livelihoods: the Western Ghats are a biodiversity hotspot and a water source. Fear of livelihood loss produces political resistance to every draft. Kasturirangan's targeted regulation (not a blanket no-go zone) tried to balance this, but the villages, plantations and revenue land remain contested.
  • Methodology and legitimacy: Karnataka's complaint that satellite mapping replaced a joint survey, and that revenue/forest land and legal categories (Bagair Hukum, deemed forest) were not reconciled, goes to the legitimacy of ESA boundaries. This explains the demand for a physical survey and the Keralam model.
  • Cooperative federalism: the Centre notifies, but States hold land and forest administration and must support implementation. Seven drafts since 2014 show repeated failure of consensus. The Keralam ground-survey route reduced its area from the report figure to 9,993 sq km and shows negotiated adjustment is possible.
  • Misinformation and trust: local leaders spread unfounded fears about housing restrictions. Clear communication and community consultation are needed.
  • Governance design: differences between Gadgil (zonation, regulatory authority) and Kasturirangan (landscape split, activity bans, EIA link) show competing regulatory philosophies. Possible way forward: joint verification, livelihood alternatives and incentives for Green Growth, and a monitoring centre as the report suggests.

Possible Mains question

**GS3, 15 marks:** "The Western Ghats Ecologically Sensitive Area proposal has been repeatedly resisted by States despite its ecological rationale. Examine the differences between the Gadgil and Kasturirangan approaches and suggest how conservation and livelihood concerns can be reconciled."

Related topics

  • Ecologically Sensitive Areas and Zones; Environment (Protection) Act, 1986; EIA Notification, 2006
  • Biodiversity hotspots and UNESCO World Heritage Sites in the Western Ghats; tiger and elephant corridors
  • Forest Rights Act, 2006; deemed forest concepts
  • Centre–State relations in environmental governance
  • Western Ghats disasters (landslides) and carrying capacity debates

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 27 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs