Zones of worry
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 26 September 2026
Summary
- The Centre's seventh draft notification (27 July 2026) would bring 9,993.7 sq km across 131 villages in Keralam under the Western Ghats ESA. The objection deadline was 25 Sept.
- Hill farmers, the Idukki Diocese of the Syro-Malabar Church and farmers' groups fear livelihood and land-use impacts. Conservationists say the fears are exaggerated.
- Keralam has formally asked the Centre to limit the ESA to forests (8,590.69 sq km, 98 villages). The editorial argues that Karnataka's outright rejection of the framework is hard to sustain without an alternative.
Key facts for Prelims
- ESAs are notified under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, by the MoEFCC (Section 3, with Rule 5(3) procedure).
- Eco-Sensitive Zones around Protected Areas are notified separately from the Western Ghats ESA. The National Wildlife Action Plan (2002–2016) guidelines treat up to 10 km around National Parks and Sanctuaries as the general principle, with the extent varying case by case.
- Western Ghats spans six States: Gujarat, Maharashtra, Goa, Karnataka, Kerala, Tamil Nadu. It is a UNESCO World Heritage Site (inscribed 2012).
- Gadgil panel: WGEEP (2011). Kasturirangan: HLWG (2013). Oommen V. Oommen: Kerala's committee.
- Kasturirangan report: about 37% as ESA; revenue village as unit; ban on mining, quarrying and sand mining; no new thermal power; Red industries banned.
- Kerala State Biodiversity Board approves cadastral maps used by the State's re-fixing proposal (as per the Oommen approach in the article).
- Existing laws cited by conservationists: Forest Act and Wildlife Protection Act.
- Draft notification of 2026: seventh; objections deadline 25 Sept.
Data and details
- Seventh draft (27 July 2026): 9,993.7 sq km across 131 villages: 9,107 sq km forest and 886.7 sq km non-forest. The feature prints the non-forest figure as "8,86.7"; the two parts add up to 9,993.7.
- Idukki has 51 villages in the latest draft. All its grama sabhas passed resolutions seeking exclusion.
- First draft (10 March 2014): 123 revenue villages in Keralam, mainly Idukki and Wayanad.
- Kasturirangan Committee (2013): ESA of 13,108 sq km covering 123 villages. A Ministry draft later reduced this to 9,993.7 sq km.
- State's ask: 8,590.69 sq km across 98 villages, limited to forests and leased forest plantations. The Special Secretary (Environment and Climate Change), M.G. Rajamanickam, placed it before the Centre on Thursday. Minister Sunny Joseph briefed on Friday.
- Keralam's forest cover is 29.15% of its area. The Minister called the case "unique" for small size and dense population, with existing stringent laws on forest, environment, paddy fields and wetlands.
- CM V.D. Satheesan will lead a delegation to Delhi if needed. The State wants a final notification, as every notification from 2014 to July 2026 has been a draft.
- Tashkent Paikada (settler farmer, Melukavu, Kottayam): after 2013 people cut trees, farmland was abandoned and land prices fell.
- Joseph Thomas (85, Udayagiri): fears eventual displacement.
- Bincy Tomy (Melukavu panchayat president): loans, land transactions and marriage prospects affected.
- Anil Sebastian (Rubber Producers' Society, Edamaruku): nearest forests are about 30 km north and 50 km south of Melukavu.
- Idukki Diocese of the Syro-Malabar Church, with the High Range Samrakshana Samiti, has led protests since 2013. Fr. Jins Karakkatt says habitations and farmland must be fully excluded.
- Alex Ozhukayil (Kerala Independent Farmers Association): inclusion would move villages from State Revenue jurisdiction to a Central regime, needing central clearance for almost every activity.
- N. Badusha (Wayanad Prakruthi Samrakshana Samiti): fears about houses and wells are baseless propaganda. Forest laws already exist.
- V.S. Vijayan (Gadgil panel member): the panel was misunderstood. It only urged organic farming and non-polluting industry and gave communities a decisive role.
- Oommen: the latest draft excludes farmland and plantations.
- Mathew Varghese (All India Kisan Sabha) wants the Ghats excluded from the UNESCO World Heritage Site status. He says UNESCO guidelines require exclusion where livelihoods are disrupted. This is his claim.
- The Travancore administration's Grow More Food campaign (early 1940s) drew migrants to the high ranges.
- 2014 Lok Sabha: Joyce George, LDF-backed Independent and the Samiti's legal adviser, won the Idukki seat.
- Draft rules: mining, quarrying and sand mining prohibited. There is no restriction on repair, extension or renovation of existing houses, or on change of ownership.
- The Karnataka Assembly unanimously repudiated the Kasturirangan Report. Objections:
- Accuracy of 2012 satellite data for natural vs human-dominated landscapes.
- The rule that an entire revenue village goes into the ESA if at least 20% of its area is sensitive.
- After the Centre's 2013-14 directive to begin ground-truthing, Karnataka saw bipartisan opposition. The editorial says interests such as mining stoked displacement fears.
- The Assembly's resolution proposes completing an alternative map.
- State positions as of mid-2026 (per the editorial):
- Gujarat is reportedly close to agreement.
- Tamil Nadu has no substantive disagreement.
- Kerala wanted to cut its ground-truthed 9,993 sq km to 8,805 sq km. The States_01 report puts the State's latest submission at 8,590.69 sq km.
- Maharashtra and Goa want 378 and 21 villages omitted.
- The Centre's 2024 decision to let ESAs be notified State by State increases pressure on Karnataka without legally binding it to its neighbours' choices.
- Karnataka has the largest share by area of the proposed ESAs.
Static–dynamic linkage
- An ESA is a regulatory device. ESAs are notified by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change under the Environment Protection Act, 1986. It limits activities such as mining and polluting industries without changing land ownership.
- The dispute is a conservation vs livelihoods trade-off:
- Villages fear loss of land use and credit.
- Conservationists see it as a way to regulate damaging activity.
- States face local costs while the national benefit accrues to the whole country (the editorial's point), so they have an incentive to negotiate the area down.
- Process matters: repeated draft notifications under the EPA keep the status in limbo.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: conservation, environmental regulation (Environment Protection Act, 1986), eco-sensitive areas; GS1 – Geography: Western Ghats; GS2 – Federalism: Centre–State friction on environment.
Background primer
Western Ghats ESA (Gadgil and Kasturirangan processes)
- What it is:
- A proposed ESA across six Western Ghats States. Gujarat, Maharashtra, Goa, Karnataka, Kerala and Tamil Nadu.
Notification process
Oommen V. Oommen Committee (Kerala)
Additional context
- The Karnataka Legislature unanimously rejected the Centre's seventh draft in its present form. It sought to restrict ESA to notified forests and to conduct a cadastral survey before final demarcation.
- Seven drafts have been issued since 2014 without a final notification.
- Karnataka had earlier opposed the Kasturirangan panel report, citing livelihood impacts.
Mains dimensions
- Two framings of the same hills: The article presents a fragile ecosystem needing protection and a lived landscape of farms and homes. Residents ask whether an ESA regime can accommodate those who live there.
- Perception vs text of the draft: The draft excludes farmland and plantations (Oommen), permits repair, extension and renovation of houses and changes in ownership, and bans only mining, quarrying and sand mining. Yet after 2013 fear itself cut trees, left farms abandoned and lowered land prices.
- Uncertainty as the cost: Seven drafts without a final notification prolong uncertainty for villagers, banks and businesses (access to loans and land transactions). Keralam wants a final notification.
- Federal bargaining: The editorial says States bear local costs while the country captures the benefit, so each State pushes for a smaller ESA. Gujarat, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Goa and Kerala show a range of positions. Karnataka's rejection without an alternative is the weak point.
- Science and mapping: Disputes over 2012 satellite data and the 20% revenue-village rule point to ground-truthing and cadastral maps (the Oommen approach) as the route.
- Politics: Church-backed agitation, the Idukki 2014 result, farmer groups, and conservationists' charge of "vested interests" show how the issue shapes local politics.
- Heritage angle: The farmers' link to UNESCO World Heritage status adds an international-commitment dimension.
- Way forward: Field-verified, cadastral-map-based demarcation, clear permitted-activity lists, and early final notification with community participation (Gadgil's bottom-up idea).
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "The Western Ghats Ecologically Sensitive Area notification has been in draft form for over a decade. Examine the reasons for the impasse and suggest a way to reconcile conservation with livelihoods."
Related topics
- Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 (Sections 3 and 5) and Environment (Protection) Rules, 1986
- Eco-Sensitive Zones around Protected Areas; Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972
- EIA Notification, 2006 and Category 'A' projects
- Biological Diversity Act, 2002 and State Biodiversity Boards
- UNESCO World Heritage Sites in India
- National Green Tribunal
- Forest Rights Act, 2006 and Gram Sabha role
- Environmental federalism (Union vs State powers)
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 26 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs