Overweight and weak
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 26 September 2026
Summary
- This editorial argues that the 81st UN General Assembly session (Guterres's last) was dominated by superpower rancour, not solutions. Its sharpest evidence is who skipped or was excluded, and what was said.
- It says the UN, at 81, "seems overweight, weak and unrepresentative", and that this year matters because a reformed UN and the next Secretary-General must be chosen together.
- It faults India for skipping the UNGA speech and side-line summits just as it campaigns for a UNSC seat. It argues India's balancing, rules-based voice is needed more than ever.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 97 of the UN Charter: the Secretary-General is appointed by the General Assembly on the recommendation of the Security Council.
- GA resolution 79/327 (5 September 2025) sets the current SG selection steps.
- Guterres's term ends on 31 December 2026. The next SG takes office on 1 January 2027 for a five-year, renewable term.
- UNSC: 15 members, 5 permanent with veto and 10 non-permanent elected for two years by a two-thirds UNGA vote.
- Regional split of the 10 elected seats: 5 Africa/Asia, 1 Eastern Europe, 2 Latin America and Caribbean, 2 Western Europe and Others.
- The UNGA President is elected for one year by regional rotation. The 81st session's President is Khalilur Rahman (Bangladesh), from the Asia-Pacific Group.
- India's UNSC campaign for 2028-29 uses the SHANTI vision. The rival Asia-Pacific candidate is Tajikistan, with elections in June 2027.
- India's last UNSC term was 2021-22.
- The article names the Delhi BRICS Summit, hosted by India shortly before UNGA-81.
Data and details
- UNGA-81 is Guterres's final session as UNSG, after a tenure the article calls marked by a record number of crises, conflicts, pandemics, climate disasters and the arrival of AI.
- One study recorded more than 65 conflicts across 35 countries in 2025, the highest since 1946. The article says there have not been so many conflicts since the Second World War.
- Drivers of UN weakness listed: polarisation on every major issue, wars by global superpowers in violation of the UN Charter, nuclear threats, and unilateral and illegitimate sanctions.
- The UN is 81 years old and is described as "overweight, weak and unrepresentative of the world".
- Khalilur Rahman (Bangladesh's Foreign Minister) is President of UNGA-81 and will oversee the UNSG's selection. The article calls this important for South Asia.
- Leaders at the heart of the conflicts in Ukraine, Gaza and the Persian Gulf failed to suggest solutions.
- U.S. President Trump spoke of the possible "annihilation" of Iran, defended U.S. actions in Venezuela, and again claimed to have brokered peace in several conflicts, including the 2025 four-day India-Pakistan war. The article says this was "much to India's chagrin".
- Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian called the U.S. and Israel "murderers, terrorists and assassins".
- Notably absent: the Russian President skipped the session, and the U.S. denied visas to the Palestinian delegation.
- The EU-led Partnership for Multilateralism (P4M), meant to build multilateralism beyond superpower hegemony and co-sponsored by India and a few other countries, was "drowned out" by the rancour.
- India launched a campaign for a second two-year non-permanent UNSC term in 2028-29. PM Modi nonetheless skipped the UNGA speech and the side-line multilateral summits, having just hosted the Delhi BRICS Summit.
- The article describes India as a balancing power speaking for a rules-based order based on the UN Charter, diplomacy and dialogue.
Static–dynamic linkage
- UNGA vs UNSC. The UNGA is the UN's deliberative, near-universal organ (one state, one vote). The UNSC holds the primary responsibility for international peace and security under the Charter. The P5's veto and unrepresentative composition (a 1945 power structure) are the core of the "weak and unrepresentative" critique.
- Article 97 appointment. The Secretary-General is appointed by the GA on the Security Council's recommendation. The P5 can therefore shape the choice, but the GA formally appoints.
- Why the editorial calls it a decisive year. The UNSG succession and UNSC reform overlap in time, and the UNGA President (from South Asia) presides over the GA's side of the process.
- India's stake. India's non-permanent seat bid is tied to its larger claim for a permanent seat in a reformed UNSC.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: Important international institutions, agencies & their mandates; effect of policies of developed countries on India; India and multilateral groupings. Prelims: UN organs, UN Charter, current events of international importance.
Background primer
United Nations (UN)
- What it is:
- Universal inter-governmental organisation for international peace and security, development, human rights and international law.
- Founded:
- 1945, after the Second World War, under the UN Charter, to prevent another global war.
- Members:
- 193 member states. Six principal organs: General Assembly, Security Council, ECOSOC, Trusteeship Council, International Court of Justice, Secretariat. HQ New York.
- Mandate:
- Maintain international peace and security, develop friendly relations among states, promote cooperation on economic, social and humanitarian problems, and promote human rights.
- Why it matters:
- Collective security and rule-based cooperation in place of unilateral power politics. The article says current wars "in violation of the UN charter", nuclear threats and unilateral sanctions have eroded this.
UN General Assembly (UNGA) and its President
- What it is:
- The main deliberative and policy-making organ, with all member states represented.
- Why it matters:
- A forum where every state has a voice. Its resolutions are generally recommendatory.
UN Security Council (UNSC)
- What it is:
- The UN organ with primary responsibility for peace and security. It is the only UN body whose decisions member states are obligated to implement under the Charter.
- Founded:
- 1945, under the UN Charter.
- Why it matters:
- A small executive body able to act quickly. Critics say it reflects 1945 power realities.
Office of the UN Secretary-General (UNSG)
- What it is:
- Chief administrative officer of the UN. Appointed by the General Assembly on the recommendation of the Security Council under Article 97.
Additional context
- Who presides over the SG selection. The 80th-session PGA, Annalena Baerbock, conducted the process until 8 September 2026. The 81st-session PGA, Khalilur Rahman, has conducted it since.
- Rahman's election. He won the secret ballot on 2 June 2026, 99 votes to 91 for Andreas Kakouris of Cyprus. His one-year term began on 8 September. The 81st session fell to the Asia-Pacific group.
- Session theme. "Restoring Trust, Managing Transformation: A United Nations that Delivers for All". His six priorities are peace and security, SDG acceleration, climate action, human rights, governance of emerging technologies including AI, and UN reform.
- Bangladesh precedent. He is the second Bangladeshi to hold the post, after Humayun Rasheed Chowdhury in 1986-87.
- Role of the P5 in the choice. The five permanent members may veto any candidate and play a decisive role in shaping the recommendation, but the appointment is ultimately made by the Assembly. Since 1996 the Council has voted unanimously to recommend a single candidate.
- India's UNSC history and campaign. India has served eight times as a non-permanent member (1950–51, 1967–68, 1972–73, 1977–78, 1984–85, 1991–92, 2011–12, 2021–22).
- SHANTI launch. India launched its campaign on 13 July 2026 at UN headquarters, where EAM S. Jaishankar unveiled the SHANTI vision. SHANTI stands for Securing Holistic Advancement through Norms, Trust and Integrity. It covers peacekeeping, maritime security, terrorism financing, responsible AI, sustainable development and global institutional reform.
- The contest. The Asia-Pacific Group has one seat in this cycle. India faces Tajikistan in elections scheduled for June 2027.
- Peacekeeping credentials. India has contributed nearly three lakh personnel to about 50 UN peacekeeping missions and has over 4,300 serving in 10 missions.
- Pre-arranged support. India and Japan have an understanding on mutual support for their non-permanent candidatures in 2028-29 and 2033-34.
- G4. India is part of the G4 (with Brazil, Germany and Japan), which supports expansion of both permanent and non-permanent seats.
Mains dimensions
- Crisis of legitimacy. The article's evidence includes wars by great powers against the Charter and unilateral sanctions. Leaders central to the Ukraine, Gaza and Gulf conflicts offered no solutions. The Russian leader's absence and the U.S. refusal of visas to the Palestinian delegation show the Assembly being used as a stage, not a forum.
- Representation deficit. "Unrepresentative" refers to a 1945 power structure. Only one expansion (1965) has occurred, and the P5 veto is untouched. This links to the G4 case for permanent seats.
- Leadership transition as an opportunity. The SG selection (Article 97, resolution 79/327) coincides with a South Asian PGA. The question is whether reform and the SG choice can be bundled, and whether P5 politics will override the stated push for transparency and gender balance.
- Weakness in conflict resolution. The 65+ conflicts in 35 countries in 2025 show the Council's paralysis. Great-power wars and a President of one P5 state claiming credit for peace deals sit awkwardly with Charter-based mediation.
- India's strategic positioning. India presents itself as a balancer for a rules-based order and the Global South. Its UNSC bid and its co-sponsorship of P4M signal this. A critique is the optics of Modi skipping UNGA and the side-line summits during a campaign that depends on one-to-one lobbying of UNGA members. Voting is by two-thirds secret ballot.
- Delicate diplomatic equations. Trump's repeated claim of mediating the 2025 India-Pakistan war cuts against India's position on bilateralism, and the article notes India's chagrin.
- Way forward. Text-based Intergovernmental Negotiations on UNSC reform, restraint on veto use in mass-atrocity situations, working-method transparency, and coalition-building (P4M, G4, Global South).
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The United Nations is increasingly seen as weak, polarised and unrepresentative of the contemporary world. In this context, discuss the significance of the 2026 UNSG selection for UN reform and examine how India can balance its non-permanent UNSC campaign for 2028-29 with its long-standing demand for permanent membership."
Related topics
- UN Charter: Chapters VI and VII, Articles 23 and 27 (composition and veto), Article 108/109 (Charter amendment).
- UNSC reform: G4, L.69, Uniting for Consensus, Intergovernmental Negotiations (IGN).
- UN80 reform agenda and UN financing.
- India and peacekeeping; India's past UNSC terms and the 2021-22 term priorities.
- BRICS (Delhi Summit) and Global South diplomacy.
- India-Pakistan 2025 conflict and the third-party mediation debate.
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 26 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs