BrainParrot

The case for accountable lottery regulation in India

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 26 September 2026

Summary

  • K. Ashok Vardhan Shetty, a retired IAS officer, former Vice-Chancellor of the Indian Maritime University and Member of the Justice Kurian Joseph Committee on Union-State Relations, argues that India should regulate lotteries rather than prohibit them.
  • He proposes two amendments to the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998:
    • clarify Section 5 to undo the Supreme Court's "all-or-nothing" reading in B.R. Enterprises (1999);
    • insert a new Section 4A so that States can run common (multi-State) lotteries.
  • He points to Kerala's public-operator model as a template.

UPSC relevance: GS2/GS3 — Centre-State legislative relations, gambling regulation, State finances

Key facts for Prelims

  • Lotteries organised by the Government fall under Entry 40, Union List. The Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998 permits States to organise lotteries subject to Section 4 conditions.
  • Section 5 lets States bar other States' lotteries; Section 6 lets the Centre prohibit lotteries that violate Sections 4 and 5.
  • Gambling, including State lotteries, is res extra commercium and sits outside Article 19(1)(g) (right to trade) and Article 301 (freedom of trade, commerce and intercourse). The same logic applies to potable alcohol.
  • B.R. Enterprises v. State of U.P. (1999): the "all-or-nothing" rule on Section 5.
  • Securities regulation analogy: legality rests on disclosure of risk, regulation of intermediaries and punishment of fraud, while adult choice is preserved.

Data and details

  • Fiscal: Kerala earned ₹2,883.80 crore in FY 2023-24, made up of ₹1,129.71 crore net lottery surplus and ₹1,754.09 crore State GST. It channels surpluses into health care and welfare.
  • States running lotteries: A Lok Sabha reply of 14 March 2023 named nine States: Arunachal Pradesh, Goa, Keralam, Maharashtra, Mizoram, Nagaland, Punjab, Sikkim and West Bengal.
  • States that chose total prohibition: Tamil Nadu (2003) and Karnataka (2007).
  • International norm:
  • Lotteries are legal in nearly four-fifths of countries.
  • Blanket bans survive mainly in strict Sharia-based jurisdictions (Saudi Arabia, Iran, Brunei) and in closed ideological regimes such as Cuba.
  • About 70% of lottery jurisdictions use the public-operator model. Under the concession model, the State regulates but a private concessionaire operates.
  • Lotteries operate in 45 of 50 US States plus Washington DC, all 10 Canadian provinces and three territories, all six Australian States and both mainland territories, and all 16 German Länder.
  • Cross-border cooperation examples: Powerball (US), Lotto 6/49 (Canada), Australian lottery blocs, and DLTB (Germany).
  • Prohibition precedent: US Prohibition (1920–33) under the Eighteenth Amendment and the Volstead Act, repealed by the Twenty-First Amendment. It fuelled black markets (Al Capone's syndicates), corrupted institutions, cost excise revenue and raised enforcement costs.
  • Rhetorical evidence:
  • Napoleon III's reply that tobacco brought in 100 million francs a year in taxes.
  • Napoleon Bonaparte's remark on vices as "very good patriots" (attribution uncertain).
  • Emerson on tobacco carrying the load of armies.
  • Harms of lotteries:
  • A burden on poorer households.
  • Compulsive play and loss-chasing from rapid draws and instant games.
  • Distorted risk perception from giant jackpots.
  • Credit sales, opaque odds and manipulative advertising.
  • Harms of bans:
  • Smuggled tickets, matka, satta, single-digit rackets and offshore portals, run through cash agents and mule accounts with no audits, no age limits, no secure prize funds and no remedy for fraud.
  • Lost lottery surplus and GST.
  • Lost livelihoods for poor or disabled vendors.
  • Higher enforcement costs.
  • Class asymmetry: SEBI found that the vast majority of day traders and F&O traders incurred losses, yet the state does not test competence before admitting retail traders.
  • Proposed amendments:
  • Amend Section 5 so it applies "whether or not the prohibiting State organises a lottery of its own", with destination-State consent decisive and uniform treatment (admit all outside lotteries or exclude all).
  • A new Section 4A to authorise two or more States to set up a common lottery by agreement, pooling players, prizes, technology and costs.
  • Section 4 and distribution: Section 4 allows States to sell tickets directly or through distributors or agents. The article says departmental operation is more transparent and enables retail through small vendors, persons with disabilities, women's SHGs and cooperatives.

Static–dynamic linkage

The legal pivot is Entry 40 of the Union List, which covers lotteries organised by the Government. Parliament used it to enact the 1998 Act, which sets conditions for State lotteries. The Court treats gambling, including State lotteries, as res extra commercium, outside Articles 19(1)(g) and 301. Sections 5–6 then let States and the Centre exclude outside lotteries. B.R. Enterprises read Section 5 narrowly, so the State–Centre trade-off became ban-everything or allow-all-comers.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Centre–State legislative relations, judicial interpretation, regulatory framework | GS3 – Economy: mobilisation of State resources, vices and revenue

Background primer

Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998

What it is:
An Act of Parliament to regulate lotteries. It defines a lottery as a scheme for distributing prizes by lot or chance among persons who buy tickets.
Founded:
Act No. 17 of 1998, dated 7 July 1998. The Centre enacted it under Entry 40 of the Union List to lay down the conditions under which State Governments organise, conduct or promote lotteries.

B.R. Enterprises v. State of U.P. (1999)

Additional context

  • In State of Karnataka v. State of Meghalaya (2022), the Supreme Court held that lotteries are a species of "betting and gambling" under Entry 34 of the State List. It also held that Entry 40 of the Union List covers only regulation of lotteries, not taxation, so State legislatures can tax lotteries organised by other States under Entry 62 of the State List.

  • Meghalaya's Original Suit No. 1 of 2021 under Article 131 challenges Sections 5 to 9 of the Act. Its challenge to Sections 6–9 concerns the penal consequences of contravening Section 5. On 11 May 2023 the Supreme Court held the suit maintainable.

Mains dimensions

  • Federalism:
  • Lottery regulation is a Union Entry, but States bear the local enforcement burden.
  • A State directly oversees its own lottery, but only indirectly oversees another State's operations within its territory. The article treats this gap as the case for excluding outside lotteries.
  • Authorisation in one jurisdiction does not confer rights in another. Federal peers (US, Canada, Australia, Germany) leave lotteries to constituent units and allow voluntary cooperation.
  • Judicial interpretation: B.R. Enterprises forced a revenue-versus-regulation trade-off, so Tamil Nadu and Karnataka gave up the option of accountable public lotteries.
  • Fiscal federalism: The argument is set against persistent State fiscal stress, with Kerala as proof that surpluses plus GST can fund health and welfare.
  • Equity and paternalism:
  • Bans hit the poor while affluent citizens can day-trade, use leveraged derivatives or speculate in crypto.
  • Regulation with disclosure and anti-fraud enforcement is more even-handed.
  • Counterpoints:
  • Lotteries burden poorer households and encourage compulsive play (the article's own list).
  • Smaller north-eastern States may fear exclusion from larger markets. The article says compulsory access is no remedy and offers Section 4A pooling instead.
  • It concedes that marketing agents can give guaranteed revenue, but argues for departmental operation.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Supreme Court's 'all-or-nothing' reading of Section 5 of the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 1998 has pushed States towards prohibition. Critically examine, and suggest a regulatory framework that balances State revenue, federal autonomy and consumer protection."

Related topics

  • Seventh Schedule: Union Entry 40; State List Entries 34 (betting and gambling) and 62 (taxes on luxuries, betting and gambling)
  • Articles 19(1)(g), 298, 301–307, and Article 131 (original jurisdiction)
  • Directive Principle on prohibition (Article 47) and State experience with prohibition
  • GST treatment of lotteries and online gaming
  • Fiscal federalism and State own-revenue sources
  • Justice Kurian Joseph Committee on Union-State Relations

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 26 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs