Opposition seeks CEC’s exit for ‘illegal conduct’
Source: The Hindu, 24 September 2026
Summary
- An Indian Express exposé reported that two of the three Election Commissioners (ECs), Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, recorded formal objections at least 14 times over 10 months. Their complaint was that major decisions were taken in the name of the full Commission without their knowledge, and they called many of these decisions "unauthorised and illegal".
- The Opposition sought the removal of CEC Gyanesh Kumar and moved to Parliament and the Supreme Court. The Election Commission (EC) said all its decisions were lawful and unanimous. The BJP said the notes show democratic deliberation.
- Former CECs and ECs asked the EC to disclose which decisions were unanimous and which were by majority.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of elections in the ECI. This covers Parliament, State Legislatures, and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- The Constitution does not fix the number of ECs. The President fixes it, so the "three-member" Commission is by notification and law, not by constitutional text.
- Article 324(5): The CEC is removable like a Supreme Court judge; other ECs only on the CEC's recommendation.
- The CEC cannot overrule the majority. In a multi-member Commission the majority view prevails when unanimity is not possible.
- Section 21(3), RP Act 1950: special revision of electoral rolls. Section 16 bars non-citizens from enrolment. Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 govern procedure. Form 6 is the application form for new voters (changes to it need amendment of the Rules, per Joshi's reported objection).
- Article 326 guarantees universal adult suffrage for citizens aged 18 and above, subject to disqualification by law.
- ERO (Electoral Registration Officer) is the statutory authority on voter eligibility. BLO (Booth Level Officer) does field verification. ERONet / ECINet are the EC's digital platforms.
- ASDDO category: Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate and Others (used in Karnataka's SIR).
- Official: Cabinet Secretary T.V. Somanathan (to whom both ECs wrote). Goa and West Bengal are the two State examples cited.
Data and details
- Two ECs recorded objections at least 14 times in 10 months. The editorial dates them between October 2025 and August 2026.
- Joshi proposed an audit in May to certify that no one except the statutory authorities has credentials to change the database.
- In August, Sandhu recorded that State-level officials do not have "proper and complete access" to the ERONet portal.
- Sandhu also flagged that the EC's director general of IT, Seema Khanna, "does not have any legal authority" to restrict statutory authorities' access.
- When a new officer took charge of the EC's administration division and issued a work-allocation order that threatened to concentrate these powers further, the two ECs wrote separately to the Cabinet Secretary.
- Form 6 was altered to ask whether the applicant, parents or grandparents "exist" in the roll at the last SIR. Joshi warned in May that a statutory form cannot be changed without amending the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. Sandhu called it "unauthorised and illegal" in August and demanded its removal. The editorial adds that by July the form carried these questions.
- Goa: 97 voters found eligible by local EROs after a Supreme Court-mandated hearing were left off the final roll. The centrally controlled software had no way to record the ERO's decision, although the CEO's office wrote to the EC eight times seeking a rollback option.
- Sandhu asked who authorised the West Bengal commission to file appeals against voters whom judicial tribunals had already included. 38 lakh appeals are pending, of which 16.1 lakh seek to remove voters whom judicial officers had included. The question remains unanswered.
- About 60 lakh electors were flagged for software-generated "logical discrepancies", many of them dubious, and 27 lakh names were deleted.
- Over nine in 10 appeals against deletion decided so far have restored the electors.
- The Hindu's analysis found that 24 of 70 Delhi seats have fewer electors in draft rolls than actually voted a year and a half ago.
- Justice Dipankar Datta, as part of a two-judge Bench, held in his opinion on Wednesday that the 2023 Act's replacement of the CJI (whom the Anoop Baranwal judgment had placed on the selection panel) with a Union Minister fails the "perception test". That panel chose Mr. Kumar as CEC. The editorial says Mr. Kumar must resign and the Court must halt further deletions until the roll database is audited. It adds that the Supreme Court had earlier upheld SIR without adequately confronting its design.
- BJP (Patra) placed Mr. Kumar's takeover as CEC in February 2025.
- EC (source-based clarification): all decisions, including SIR, were unanimous with the approval of both ECs and the CEC.
- EC (written statement): written notes and internal checks are standard practice; every officer is authorised to give suggestions. It cited around 40 new initiatives and said selective internal notes over 10 months show "one part of the picture". It said its platforms such as ECINet run under strict data-security protocols with audit controls.
- BJP (Sambit Patra): the communications show deliberation ending in unanimous decisions. The Supreme Court has upheld SIR's legal validity multiple times. In West Bengal, the TMC won 13 of the 20 Assembly seats with the highest elector deletions, Congress 1 and the BJP 6. He listed post-retirement careers of former ECs:
- K.V.K. Sundaram, Nagendra Singh and R.K. Trivedi received Padma honours; Trivedi later became Governor.
- V.S. Ramadevi became Governor.
- T.N. Seshan contested on a Congress ticket.
- M.S. Gill became a Union Minister.
- Former CEC S.Y. Quraishi: decisions that are neither unanimous nor majority-backed are illegal. The EC should publish the list of decisions by unanimity or majority. He also called SIR illegal and "dubious" and said it should be reversed. He had called it "highly undesirable" about a year and a half earlier.
- Former EC Ashok Lavasa (resigned in 2020 after differences within the Commission): the EC should disclose the dates of notes and letters and the action taken. The only way to refute the two ECs is to produce records showing they were present at the meetings.
- Former CEC O.P. Rawat: the two ECs should not have waited 10 months. The EC gives complete independence, so they could have gone public immediately.
- Rahul Gandhi called "vote chori" a crime and said the BJP, RSS and EC had committed "treason".
- K.C. Venugopal sought a Supreme Court-monitored probe.
- Mamata Banerjee announced a jono jagaran campaign and demanded re-polls in West Bengal, Bihar, Haryana and Madhya Pradesh.
- Two removal motions have been filed in Parliament. The Opposition asked the Supreme Court to take suo motu cognisance.
- Prakash Raj launched an "SIR Resistance Tour" from Ramanagar, Kalaburagi. He claimed 5,21,950 voters in Kalaburagi district are in the ASDDO category and only around 25,000 had submitted Form 6. He asked why an existing voter must re-register to stay on the roll. The tour ends with a Bengaluru conference on 30 September.
- At the launch of The Delimitation Debate: The Union and its Units, CPI(M)'s John Brittas alleged SIR and delimitation are linked. Jairam Ramesh said the Monsoon Session had not been prorogued 41 days after being adjourned sine die, and claimed the government lacks a two-thirds majority for the amendment on 33% women's reservation after a 2011 Census-based delimitation. He also said Bills are planned around 11 October. SP's Javed Khan cited his party's 37 of 80 seats in UP in 2024. These are partisan claims.
- Panel suggestions: smaller States (Sanjeev Chopra); a French-style two-round system so the winner has at least 50% of votes polled (Raja Sekhar Vundru). The Hindu's editor said the book frames delimitation as a question of democratic and federal principles, not a North-South conflict.
Static–dynamic linkage
The Election Commission is a constitutional body with plenary powers over elections. Its independence rests on three things: how its members are appointed, how secure their tenure is, and how the Commission takes decisions collectively. The news tests the third pillar. Under the 2023 Act, business is to be unanimous where possible, and a disagreement is settled by majority. If two of three members say they were bypassed, the question is whether a decision is a valid act of "the Commission" at all. A related question is whether the EC's centralised IT system has overridden the statutory authorities, the Electoral Registration Officers (EROs), who decide eligibility. This is the static issue behind the SIR dispute: who legally decides who is a voter.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission, Art. 324); statutory/regulatory bodies; Representation of the People Act; electoral reforms; GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability of institutions.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- A permanent, independent constitutional body established on 25 January 1950 under Article 324. It holds the superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures, and the offices of the President and Vice-President.
- Mandate:
- Conduct elections, prepare and revise electoral rolls, enforce the Model Code of Conduct, and exercise plenary power under Article 324 where the law is silent. Mohinder Singh Gill v. CEC (1978) held Article 324 to be a plenary power that lets the EC act even where the law is silent.
- Why it matters:
- Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975) declared free and fair elections part of the Basic Structure. The Commission must therefore be insulated from the executive.
The CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023
- What it is:
- Act No. 49 of 2023, which received Presidential assent on 28 December 2023. It repealed the 1991 Act.
- Mandate:
- Governs appointment, conditions of service, term and business of the Commission. All business is to be conducted unanimously, and a difference of opinion between the CEC and the other ECs is decided by majority.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- A focused, time-bound exercise by the ECI to update and verify the accuracy of electoral rolls. It involves house-to-house verification by Booth Level Officers (BLOs).
Additional context
- Gyanesh Kumar's appointment as CEC was the first under the 2023 Act. Kumar and Sandhu had been appointed ECs under the same Act in March 2024. Rahul Gandhi, as a member of the selection committee, submitted a dissent note.
- Vivek Joshi was earlier Registrar General of India and Census Commissioner.
- During the West Bengal SIR, a Supreme Court bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justices Dipankar Datta and Joymalya Bagchi directed the ECI to publicly display the names of voters placed on the "logical discrepancies" list so that they could submit documents or objections.
- In ADR v. ECI (27 May 2026, 2026 INSC 564), the Supreme Court upheld the Bihar SIR. It held the exercise traceable to Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950 read with Article 324, founded on a legitimate purpose and proportionate.
- The Supreme Court has observed that SIR outcomes cannot be used for any purpose other than elections, such as determining citizenship or denying welfare benefits.
- Rule 21A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 mandates notice, inquiry and hearing before deletion. This is the procedural yardstick against which the "deletion before verification" criticism is measured.
- Under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, claims for inclusion are made in Form 6, objections in Form 7 and corrections in Form 8.
Mains dimensions
- Collective decision-making as a legal requirement: The 2023 Act demands unanimity where possible and majority otherwise. If the two ECs were bypassed, the validity of "Commission" decisions is open to challenge. The EC's reply that all decisions were unanimous rests on records that are not public, hence the demand for disclosure by Quraishi and Lavasa.
- Centralisation vs statutory authority: The ECs' complaints (centralised database, limited ERONet access, software overriding EROs, the Goa case of 97 voters) show the statutory ERO's decision being overridden by IT architecture. That is a rule-of-law problem, since eligibility is a statutory function.
- Rule-making by executive order: Altering Form 6 without amending the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 raises the issue of delegated powers. It also raises the Article 324 question of whether plenary power can override rules made under statute.
- Burden of proof and franchise: The editorial argues that SIR deletes before verification and puts the burden on the citizen, which defeats universal adult franchise. Data: 27 lakh deleted in West Bengal; over nine in 10 decided appeals restored voters; 16.1 lakh appeals filed to remove included voters. Counter-view: the Supreme Court upheld SIR as proportionate, and the EC says it protects roll purity.
- Timing of dissent: O.P. Rawat's criticism that the ECs waited 10 months raises the ethics of dissent in constitutional bodies, which can be weighed against Lavasa's 2020 resignation. The BJP says internal dissent is healthy deliberation.
- Accountability gap: Only the CEC has constitutional protection. ECs are removable only on the CEC's recommendation. This can inhibit dissent. It is also why the Opposition's removal motions face a special-majority bar.
- Institutional trust and polarisation: Re-poll demands, "vote chori" and "treason" rhetoric, and the BJP's counter-attack over past ECs' careers show the Commission's credibility becoming a partisan issue. Way forward: publish a decisions register (unanimous or majority), an independent audit of the electoral roll database, a statutory independent secretariat, equal removal protection for all commissioners, and a broader selection panel.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The independence of the Election Commission depends not only on how its members are appointed but on how it takes decisions. In light of recent disagreements within the Commission over the Special Intensive Revision, critically examine the safeguards for collective decision-making and statutory accountability in the ECI."
Related topics
- Article 324, 324(5), Articles 325–329; Representation of the People Acts 1950/1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
- CEC and Other ECs Act, 2023; Anoop Baranwal (2023); T.N. Seshan (1995); Mohinder Singh Gill (1978)
- Removal of CEC vs removal of SC judges (Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968)
- Delimitation (Articles 82/170), women's reservation; linked notes on the 2023 Act challenge (Justice Datta's opinion)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 24 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs