BrainParrot

Water wealth

GS3Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 23 September 2026

Summary

  • An editorial argues that Punjab's over-extraction of groundwater is long-known. Depletion is now also widening the wealth gap between large and small farmers.
  • A study by Prof. Sandeep Kaur (Central University of Punjab, Bathinda) finds that large farmers deepen their borewells and benefit most. Small and marginal farmers bear the cost of scarcity.
  • The editorial urges using part of the electricity subsidy bill to support smallholders directly and calls "Pani Bachao, Paisa Kamao" promising despite low enrolment. The States-page report quotes an expert criticising blanket free farm electricity.

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Environment/Agriculture: groundwater, irrigation, subsidies; GS1/GS2 — inequality, farmers

Key facts for Prelims

  • DGWRA categories: Safe ≤70%; Semi-critical 70–90%; Critical 90–100%; Over-exploited >100% stage of extraction.
  • Water is a State subject. Centre's role is facilitative (e.g., NAQUIM, Atal Bhujal Yojana, Amrit Sarovar).
  • Pani Bachao, Paisa Kamao is a Punjab Direct Benefit Transfer scheme launched as a pilot in 2018. It pays farmers for electricity not consumed, below a fixed allocation.
  • Rice-wheat cropping system in Punjab: sustained by assured procurement (MSP), subsidised electricity and groundwater access.
  • Groundwater assessment is done at block level, with Central Ground Water Board (CGWB) and States jointly.

Data and details

  • Punjab's groundwater extraction rate is 152%.
  • Interventions reduced the number of "over-exploited" blocks by only five over the last two assessments.
  • 72% of Punjab's 153 blocks are in the "red zone", the highest among States.
  • Irrigation of rice and wheat consumes nearly 25 billion cubic metres a year.
  • The fraction of observation wells with water below 40 metres post-monsoon grew by two percentage points between 2022 and 2025.
  • EPW study: marginal-holding farmers use water more efficiently, but wealthier farmers can reach lower water tables and draw larger volumes.
  • As the table falls, farmers who cannot afford tubewells buy water. Wealth then moves to larger landowners, creating unregulated dependencies.
  • Discover Sustainability study (two authors from the same team): in Sangrur and Barnala, larger farms earned higher returns but had lower groundwater productivity for paddy than smaller farms.
  • Depletion raises the capital needed for irrigation, which privileges farmers with better access to finance.
  • PBPK entitles farmers to cash for every unused kilowatt-hour under a threshold. The editorial calls it promising but with low enrolment.
  • 76.47% of groundwater blocks are classified as over-exploited, the highest among States; only 13.07% are "safe".
  • Only a small share of Punjab's farmers use surface canal water. Low canal utilisation plus wheat-rice cultivation is the root cause.
  • Large farmers install more borewells with high-capacity motors. This reaches deeper aquifers, cuts cultivation costs and raises returns per unit cost.
  • Small farmers have fewer pumping motors per unit area, because most of their operational holdings are leased-in land.
  • Kaur's conclusion: large farmers, who contribute most to environmental damage, benefit most. Small and marginal farmers bear the cost of scarcity while contributing least.
  • S.K. Saluja (former Chief Engineer, Ranjit Sagar and Shahpurkandi dam projects) says blanket free farm electricity is economically crippling the smallholders it was meant to protect.
  • Saluja: capital-rich farmers got connections for new tubewells and keep deepening borewells. They run high-powered submersibles and siphon most of the groundwater, fuelling an unregulated "shadow economy".
  • Saluja: the universal subsidy enriches wealthy landlords, drains the exchequer and hastens the ruin of small farmers.
  • Kaur says the government's various schemes fall short of addressing the full scope of the problem.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Groundwater is a common-pool resource. When access depends on capital (deeper tubewells, higher-horsepower pumps), depletion hits resource-poor users hardest. Subsidised power, assured procurement and MSP-based rice-wheat cultivation make water-intensive crops rational for farmers, even as the aquifer falls. This is a classic Green Revolution legacy and a "tragedy of the commons" problem.
  • Water is a State subject. Groundwater management is primarily a State responsibility; the Centre only facilitates through technical and financial assistance.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: conservation, groundwater degradation; GS3 – Agriculture: irrigation, subsidies, cropping patterns, food security; GS1 – Society: poverty and inequality

Background primer

Dynamic Ground Water Resources Assessment (DGWRA)

What it is:
The periodic assessment of annual replenishable groundwater and extraction, done block by block. Block is the unit of assessment, and Punjab's was assessed using the GEC-2015 methodology.
Mandate:
It identifies where extraction exceeds annual recharge, so management can be prioritised. Priority goes to over-exploited, critical and semi-critical units.

"Pani Bachao, Paisa Kamao" (PBPK) — Punjab

What it is:
A "Save Water, Earn Money" scheme that links efficient electricity use to direct financial incentives. It moves away from unconditional free power towards a performance-based model.
Founded:
Launched as a pilot in June 2018 by the Punjab Government with PSPCL and the World Bank. The pilot covered Dhuri (Sangrur), Malerkotla and Fatehgarh Sahib.
Why it matters:
Make saving water financially rewarding, without cutting farmers' free-power entitlement.

Additional context

  • Punjab's categorisation has been consistently poor over the years. The 2017 assessment recorded 109 of 138 blocks as over-exploited.
  • National picture: Over-exploited and critical units remain concentrated in Punjab, Haryana, Delhi, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Telangana and Gujarat. Nationally, over-exploited units fell from 17.24% (2017) to 11.13% (2024).
  • Stress drivers: Water-intensive agriculture and energy subsidies are cited among the reasons for persistent over-exploitation in Punjab, Haryana and Delhi.
  • Other State measures: The Punjab Preservation of Subsoil Water Act, 2009 prohibits sowing paddy nursery and transplanting before notified dates. Punjab has also passed the Punjab Water Resources (Management and Regulation) Act, 2020 and constituted a Punjab Water Regulation and Development Authority.
  • Central measures: The CGWB runs the National Aquifer Mapping Programme (NAQUIM) to delineate and characterise aquifer systems. Atal Bhujal Yojana (₹6,000 crore) is a community-led, demand-side groundwater management scheme in water-stressed areas of seven States: Gujarat, Haryana, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh. Punjab is not among them.

Mains dimensions

  • Causes. The rice-wheat monoculture was built by assured procurement, subsidised power and free groundwater, which made HYV, fertiliser and mechanisation low-risk. Farmers avoid alternative crops because of uncertain storage, prices, processing and supply chains, which have gone relatively unaddressed. Low use of surface canal water adds to the load on aquifers.
  • Equity dimension. Depletion is a regressive process. Capital-rich farmers go deeper and earn more per unit cost, while small and leased-in farmers either buy water or lose access. This creates a water-market dependency that transfers wealth upwards (EPW study; Sangrur/Barnala evidence).
  • Subsidy design. A blanket free-electricity subsidy benefits those with more tubewells and larger pumps. Saluja's critique is that the universal subsidy funds a system that enriches large landowners and drains the exchequer.
  • Policy fixes (editorial). Use part of the electricity subsidy bill to support smallholders directly, collectivise irrigation infrastructure and support crop transition. Make benefits follow the cultivator, including tenants, so that welfare subsidises access to water rather than extraction. Build on PBPK, which the editorial calls promising despite low enrolment.
  • Limits of current action. State efforts exist, but the scale of demand overwhelms the efficiency gains. Prof. Kaur says the schemes fall short.
  • Cross-cutting. Link to food security, since Punjab is a procurement hub, and to the climate sensitivity of recharge.

Possible Mains question

**GS3 (Agriculture/Environment), 15 marks:** "Free power and assured procurement have made Punjab's groundwater crisis not only an ecological problem but also an equity problem. Discuss, and suggest a policy mix to protect both farm incomes and aquifers."

Related topics

  • MSP and procurement policy; crop diversification
  • Atal Bhujal Yojana, Jal Shakti Abhiyan, NAQUIM, CGWB
  • Direct Benefit Transfer and subsidy rationalisation (power subsidy)
  • Green Revolution and its regional effects
  • Common-pool resources and water governance (State subject)

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 23 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs