Trade deal unlikely till U.S. probes India’s competitors also over excess capaci...
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 23 September 2026
Summary
- A person familiar with the process says India and the U.S. are unlikely to sign a trade deal until the U.S. launches fresh Section 301 investigations and concludes them, with tariffs on India's competitors such as Pakistan, Sri Lanka and the Philippines.
- A deal is therefore highly unlikely around Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal's visit for the G-20 trade ministerial beginning September 30.
- A new U.S. law that allows up to 100% tariffs on the top importers of Russian oil adds to the complexity.
Key facts for Prelims
- Section 301 belongs to the U.S. Trade Act of 1974. The USTR conducts the investigations.
- IEEPA (1977) was the statute under which the U.S. imposed "reciprocal" tariffs. The U.S. Supreme Court held that application unlawful (February 2026).
- MFN (Most Favoured Nation) is the WTO principle of non-discriminatory tariff treatment. The U.S. instead uses executive-tariff measures.
- Section 232 is the national-security basis for U.S. tariffs, for example on steel, aluminium and auto parts.
- Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974 is a temporary balance-of-payments tariff surcharge, capped in the statute at 150 days.
- Article 23 of the Indian Constitution (Right against Exploitation) prohibits forced labour. The Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act, 1976 is the related law.
- G-20 trade ministerial: Goyal is to attend in the U.S. (G-20 hosted by the U.S.).
Data and details
- Section 301 "excess capacity" probes were opened in March 2026. A separate set of forced-labour 301 probes was also launched in March 2026.
- Pakistan was not on the excess-capacity probe list. The person familiar with the process quoted in the article calls that a "strategic mistake".
- Pakistan, Sri Lanka and the Philippines were subject to the forced-labour 301 probes but not the excess-capacity ones. India was subject to the excess-capacity probe.
- Pakistan is tariffed at 10% as a result of the forced-labour 301 investigation.
- India is likely to be tariffed at 8% in the excess-capacity probe, bringing the overall rate back to 18%.
- No similar legal instrument currently exists to raise the competitors' rates back to their earlier levels.
- A February 6 India–U.S. joint statement announced an Interim Agreement on trade.
- Under the interim deal, India's general rate would have been 18%. Competitors' rates would have been: Pakistan 19%, Vietnam 20%, Sri Lanka 20%, Bangladesh 19% and the Philippines 19%.
- After the tariffs were scrapped, these competitors trade with the U.S. on an MFN basis.
- An announcement of fresh 301 investigations against competitor countries is likely in the near future, though the timelines and subject matters have not been decided.
- The Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act was signed into law last Friday. It enables up to 100% tariffs on the top five importers of Russian oil, including India and China.
- India is the second-biggest market for Russian crude.
- Reports suggest the bill was originally scheduled for after the midterm elections but was rushed through for the September 24 Xi–Trump meeting in Washington, DC.
- Commerce Secretary Rajesh Agrawal spoke at the Global Fintech Fest 2026 earlier in September.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Trade agreements rest on the principle of non-discrimination. Under the WTO's Most Favoured Nation (MFN) rule, a country gives every member the same tariff treatment. Preferential agreements are the exception.
- The U.S. no longer applies a flat MFN-based system. After its Supreme Court struck down the IEEPA-based "reciprocal" tariffs, the executive has rebuilt tariff differentials using other statutes: Section 301, Section 232 and Section 122.
- India's goal is a relative advantage over competitors in the U.S. market. That depends on the legal instruments available to the U.S. to tariff those competitors.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: India and bilateral groupings/agreements; effect of policies of developed countries on India's interests; GS3 – Economy: external sector, trade policy, WTO principles
Background primer
Section 301 of the U.S. Trade Act, 1974
- What it is:
- A provision of the Trade Act of 1974 that lets the U.S. Trade Representative investigate foreign trade practices and impose trade measures in response to unfair practices. It allows unilateral tariffs or trade restrictions, often bypassing the WTO's dispute settlement mechanism.
- Why it matters:
- It gives the executive a statute-based route to respond to practices it regards as unfair, without Congress passing new law.
IEEPA (International Emergency Economic Powers Act, 1977) and the Supreme Court ruling
- What it is:
- A law that lets the U.S. President block assets, restrict financial transactions and regulate imports and exports after declaring a national emergency.
Most Favoured Nation (MFN) tariff
Additional context
- The forced-labour Section 301 probe covered a very large set of economies. The USTR announced final measures on 23 July 2026 after investigating 60 economies, including India.
- An additional 10% duty was imposed on imports from India, a reduction from the 12.5% initially proposed on 2 June 2026.
- The Commerce Ministry estimates about 45% of India's exports to the U.S. remain outside the duty, with the other 55% attracting it.
- The pending excess-capacity probe: In March 2026 the USTR launched Section 301(b) investigations against 16 trading partners, including India, over structural excess capacity in manufacturing. A separate forced-labour Section 301 probe covering 60 economies was launched in the same month. The USTR is still investigating India's excess capacity, which could lead to further tariffs.
- India's legal position on forced labour: India prohibits forced labour under Article 23 of the Constitution and the Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act, 1976.
Mains dimensions
- Legal shift. The Supreme Court ruling removed the IEEPA route for country-specific tariffs. The administration is rebuilding differentials through multiple statutes (301, 232, 122), so a bilateral deal depends on which tools are available against which competitors.
- Relative advantage. For India the key is not the absolute tariff but the gap relative to competitors. With the interim deal's 18%, India had an edge over Pakistan (19%), Vietnam (20%), Sri Lanka (20%), Bangladesh (19%) and the Philippines (19%). That edge disappears when everyone trades on MFN terms.
- Asymmetric probes. Pakistan, Sri Lanka and the Philippines were probed for forced labour but not for excess capacity, so their rates cannot be raised through the same instrument. India is the one facing the excess-capacity probe. This mismatch is the "central challenge".
- Geopolitics (Pakistan). Pakistan being tariffed lower than India is politically sensitive in New Delhi's calculus.
- Energy–sanctions overlay. The Graham Act exposes India, the second-largest buyer of Russian crude, to tariffs of up to 100%. This links trade to energy security and strategic autonomy.
- Negotiating architecture. India's MFN-based system and the U.S. executive-tariff system do not align. Any deal needs a preferential-access structure with differentials.
- Multilateral timing. The G-20 trade ministerial and the Xi–Trump meeting show that the U.S. is balancing multiple trade tracks at once.
Possible Mains question
**GS2 (IR) / GS3 (Economy), 15 marks:** "After the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling on IEEPA tariffs, the U.S. has turned to Section 301 and other statutes to rebuild its tariff architecture. Analyse the implications for India's bilateral trade negotiations and its competitiveness in the U.S. market."
Related topics
- WTO: MFN, national treatment, dispute settlement; Generalised System of Preferences
- Bilateral Trade Agreement vs. FTA; rules of origin
- India's energy security and Russian oil imports; sanctions and secondary tariffs
- Balance of payments, exports and the exchange rate
- India–U.S. relations (strategic partnership, Quad); Pakistan factor in India's trade calculus
Topics: GS2Economy
All current affairs of 23 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs