Judicial Review, Judicial Activism and Public Interest Litigation
In 1979 a newspaper reported that thousands of undertrial prisoners in Bihar had spent more years in jail than the maximum sentence for the offences they were charged with. None could afford a lawyer. An advocate, Kapila Hingorani, filed a petition for them, and the Supreme Court heard it. That case, Hussainara Khatoon, captures the three ideas of this topic. Judicial review gives courts the power to test laws and executive acts against the Constitution. Judicial activism is the proactive use of that power to protect rights and push the other organs to do their duty. Public interest litigation (PIL) lets anyone approach the court for those who cannot.
Based on: NCERT and standard textbooks; reviewed by the BrainParrot team. How we make our notes
- 1. 1. Judicial review: meaning and origin
- 2. 2. Why judicial review matters
- 3. 3. Constitutional provisions behind judicial review
- 4. 4. Scope and grounds of judicial review
- 5. 5. India and the USA: "procedure established by law" and "due process of law"
- 6. 6. Judicial review of the Ninth Schedule
- 7. 7. Judicial activism: meaning and origin
- 8. 8. Why judicial activism: justification and triggers
- 9. 9. Tools and techniques of judicial activism
- 10. 10. Landmark examples of judicial activism and PIL
- 11. 11. Activism, restraint and overreach
- 12. 12. Criticism of judicial activism and the separation of powers
- 13. 13. Public interest litigation: meaning and origin
- 14. 14. Features of PIL
- 15. 15. Scope of PIL: what the Supreme Court will entertain
- 16. 16. Principles of PIL laid down by the Supreme Court
- 17. 17. Misuse of PIL and the Court's response
- 18. 18. Achievements of PIL
- 19. 19. Recent developments (as of November 2026)
- 20. For Mains: Analysis
- 21. Quick Revision
- 22. Common Exam Traps
1. Judicial review: meaning and origin
Judicial review is the power of the judiciary to examine the constitutionality of legislative enactments and executive orders of both the Union and the State governments. If a law or order is found to violate the Constitution (ultra vires), the court declares it illegal, unconstitutional and invalid (null and void), and the government cannot enforce it.
Origin in the USA. The doctrine was laid down in Marbury v. Madison (1803) by Chief Justice John Marshall, the first case in which the US Supreme Court struck down an Act of Congress. The US Constitution does not mention judicial review; the Court built it by interpretation.
Position in India. The Constitution neither uses the term "judicial review" nor expressly provides for it. The courts infer the power from Articles 13, 32, 136 and 226 (Section 3) and from the written, federal character of the Constitution. It is exercised by both the Supreme Court and the High Courts; subordinate courts do not decide the constitutional validity of laws.
The Supreme Court has gone further and declared judicial review a basic feature of the Constitution (Indira Nehru Gandhi, 1975; Minerva Mills, 1980; L. Chandra Kumar, 1997; I.R. Coelho, 2007). So it cannot be curtailed or excluded even by a constitutional amendment. The basic structure itself is judge-made: the Constitution neither defines nor lists it (see Basic Structure).
Three kinds of judicial review. Justice Syed Shah Mohammed Quadri classified judicial review into:
- Review of constitutional amendments.
- Review of legislation of Parliament and the State legislatures, and of subordinate legislation (rules, regulations, notifications).
- Review of administrative action of the Union, the States and authorities under the State.
Some famous uses. Golaknath (1967); Bank Nationalisation (R.C. Cooper, 1970); Privy Purses (Madhav Rao Scindia, 1970); Kesavananda Bharati (1973); Minerva Mills (1980); the NJAC case (2015); and the electoral bonds case (2024) (Section 10).
Sign up free to read every section of this note, test yourself with topic-matched MCQs, and revise with spaced-repetition flashcards.
Get started free