BrainParrot
PolityGS2

Fundamental Duties

Rights and duties are two sides of one coin: my right to life is your duty not to harm me. Yet the Constitution that came into force in 1950 listed rights for citizens and duties for the State (the Directive Principles), but no duties for citizens. That gap was filled only in 1976, in the middle of the Emergency, when Part IVA and Article 51A were added. These notes cover the origin, the eleven duties, why courts cannot enforce them, and how laws and judges still give them force.

(Directive Principles are covered in Directive Principles of State Policy; Article 21A and the Right to Education in Fundamental Rights I; the national anthem case of Bijoe Emmanuel in Fundamental Rights I (freedom of silence) and Fundamental Rights II (freedom of conscience); the sources of the Constitution in Salient Features.)

Based on: NCERT and standard textbooks; reviewed by the BrainParrot team. How we make our notes

In this note
  1. 1. 1. Origin and background
  2. 2. 2. The eleven Fundamental Duties (table)
  3. 3. 3. Features of Fundamental Duties
  4. 4. 4. Swaran Singh Committee: what was accepted and what was not
  5. 5. 5. Verma Committee (1999) and laws that enforce the duties
  6. 6. 6. Criticism and significance
  7. 7. 7. Courts and Fundamental Duties (cases table)
  8. 8. 8. Duties, Rights and Directive Principles compared (table)
  9. 9. 9. Recent developments
  10. 10. For Mains: Analysis
  11. 11. Quick Revision
  12. 12. Common Exam Traps

1. Origin and background

The original gap. The framers placed Fundamental Rights in Part III and the duties of the State in Part IV (Directive Principles of State Policy). They did not feel it necessary to write down the duties of citizens. A later official review of the Constitution suggested three reasons:

  • the framers had themselves lived these values in the freedom struggle and took them as part of the Indian way of life;
  • the Preamble already implied the duties needed to secure justice, liberty, equality and fraternity;
  • every Fundamental Right carries an in-built obligation that can be read out of it.

The source: the USSR. The idea of listing citizens' duties was inspired by the Constitution of the erstwhile USSR. Socialist constitutions gave rights and duties equal weight.

Other democracies. The constitutions of the USA, Canada, France, Germany and Australia contain no specific list of citizens' duties. The Japanese Constitution is perhaps the only democratic one with such a list.

The Emergency and the Swaran Singh Committee (1976). During the internal emergency (1975–77), the ruling Congress Party, through its President D.K. Borooah, set up the Sardar Swaran Singh Committee on 26 February 1976 to study amendment of the Constitution in the light of experience. Among its proposals was a separate chapter of eight duties, stressing that citizens have duties to perform besides enjoying rights; the ruling party said the Emergency had brought out this need.

The 42nd Amendment Act, 1976. The Congress Government accepted the idea and enacted the 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1976.

  • It added a new Part IVA, with only one article, Article 51A.
  • Article 51A set out ten duties (the Committee had suggested eight).
  • It came into force on 3 January 1977.
  • The ruling party called the earlier omission a "historical mistake" that it was now correcting.

Why the government said it was needed.

  • H.R. Gokhale, then Law Minister, argued that on the eve of the Emergency in June 1975 "a section of the people showed no anxiety to fulfil their fundamental obligations of respecting the established legal order", and that the new chapter "would have a sobering effect on these restless spirits".
  • Indira Gandhi, then Prime Minister, said the moral value of the duties would be "not to smother rights but to establish a democratic balance by making the people conscious of their duties equally as they are conscious of their rights".

Survival after the Emergency. The Opposition strongly opposed the inclusion. But the Janata Government of Morarji Desai, which used the 43rd (1977) and 44th (1978) Amendments to undo many 42nd-Amendment changes, left Article 51A untouched. This suggests a broad consensus that the duties were desirable.

The eleventh duty (2002). The 86th Constitutional Amendment Act, 2002 added clause (k): a duty on every parent or guardian to provide opportunities for education to a child or ward aged six to fourteen. The same amendment created the Right to Education (Article 21A) and rewrote Article 45. Clause (k) came into force on 1 April 2010.

Link with the UDHR. Listing duties also brought the Constitution in line with Article 29(1) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948): "Everyone has duties to the community in which alone the free and full development of his personality is possible." The Preamble and the Directive Principles also draw on the ideals of the UDHR.

Timeline

YearEvent
1976Swaran Singh Committee recommends eight duties; 42nd Amendment adds Part IVA, Article 51A, with ten duties
1977Article 51A in force (3 January)
200286th Amendment adds the eleventh duty, 51A(k) (in force 1 April 2010)
2003Supreme Court (Ranganath Mishra) directs the Centre to act on the Verma Committee's recommendations
2. The eleven Fundamental Duties (table)
3. Features of Fundamental Duties
4. Swaran Singh Committee: what was accepted and what was not
5. Verma Committee (1999) and laws that enforce the duties
6. Criticism and significance
7. Courts and Fundamental Duties (cases table)
8. Duties, Rights and Directive Principles compared (table)
9. Recent developments
For Mains: Analysis
Quick Revision
Common Exam Traps
Unlock the full note, MCQs and flashcards

Sign up free to read every section of this note, test yourself with topic-matched MCQs, and revise with spaced-repetition flashcards.

Get started free