BrainParrot

Toxic cost of power

GS3Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 21 November 2026

Summary

  • A ground report finds fly-ash slurry from Telangana's 4,000-MW Yadadri Thermal Power Station (YTPS), run by TG Genco, discharging into the Thungapahad stream (Annameru). The stream joins the Krishna river near Veerlapalem, Nalgonda district.
  • Locals report fish and livestock deaths, a collapse in fishers' incomes and rising respiratory cases. A pollution board inspection earlier this year found the plant's ash-water recovery system (AWRS) non-functional.
  • The story traces a decade of opposition, NGT and EIA interventions, and the plant's eventual clearance. It exposes the gap between the zero-discharge promise and ground reality, set against a fly-ash regime of 100% utilisation that is over 25 years old and weakly enforced.

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Environment: pollution, EIA, thermal power and waste management; GS2 — governance/regulators

Key facts for Prelims

  • EIA Notification 2006 (Environment (Protection) Act, 1986): Category A (Central/EAC) vs Category B (SEIAA/SEAC); four stages: screening, scoping, public consultation (public hearing), appraisal. Thermal power plants fall under Schedule item 1(d).
  • Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC): appraises Category A projects; public hearing proceedings are part of the appraisal record.
  • Fly Ash Notification (MoEFCC): first issued 1999; current framework S.O. 5481(E) of 31 Dec 2021 (amended 30 Dec 2022 and 1 Jan 2024). It mandates 100% ash utilisation by thermal plants; at least 80% annually and a 100% average over a three-year cycle; compensation of Rs 1,000 per tonne for unutilised ash; construction agencies within 300 km must use ash-based products.
  • Bottom ash is transported as slurry to the ash pond; fly ash is captured by electrostatic precipitators (ESP) and stored in airtight silos for cement makers.
  • PLF (Plant Load Factor) = ratio of actual generation to maximum possible generation.
  • NGT: statutory body (NGT Act, 2010) that suspended YTPS's environmental clearance in 2022.
  • Amrabad Tiger Reserve (Telangana; part of the Nagarjunsagar-Srisailam Tiger Reserve) was cited in the NGT case about the plant's proximity.
  • Singareni Collieries Company Limited (SCCL) is the contracted coal supplier. G9 is the contracted grade; G15/G16 are lower grades.
  • Krishna river: the Thungapahad stream joins it near Veerlapalem; the downstream stretch reaches the Prakasam Barrage (Andhra Pradesh). The Pulichintala project (on the Krishna) is cited for stagnation.
  • Agencies named: Telangana Pollution Control Board; Central Electricity Authority (CEA) as source of PLF data; Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change.

Data and details

  • 4,000 MW = five 800 MW units; location Veerlapalem village, Nalgonda district, Telangana. The operator is TG Genco; the five chimney towers loom over the site.
  • Four units commissioned. The first unit began operations in January 2025 and the final unit's launch is "now being publicised".
  • Project cost escalated to ₹36,000 crore. The decade-long dispute was followed by clearance in April 2024.
  • Thungapahad stream (Annameru, "stream of food") is 30–35 km long. It originates at Pedda Devulapalle Balancing Reservoir (Tripuraram mandal), which gets inflow from the Nagarjuna Sagar left bank canal. It irrigates fields and joins the Krishna near Veerlapalem. Near the confluence, the Veerlapalem-II Lift Irrigation scheme for tail-end ayacut is being built under the Nagarjunasagar project.
  • Complaint to the Telangana Pollution Control Board in May this year → inspection → show-cause notice to TG Genco the following month (June).
  • The team found the AWRS non-functional and discharging large amounts of ash-laden water into the stream. It also found ash stored near the system contributing to air pollution, and no effluent or sewage treatment plant on the premises. Five months later, "little appears to have changed".
  • EC held up for a year after K. Babu Rao of Scientists for People flagged passages of the EIA plagiarised from academic papers. Clearance came in 2017.
  • Conservation Action Trust (Mumbai) approached the NGT over proximity to the Amrabad Tiger Reserve and ambiguity over coal linkages. In 2022 the NGT suspended the EC and ordered fresh EAC appraisal. It held that the shift from a 50:50 imported/domestic coal mix to 100% indigenous coal warranted fresh assessment.
  • Second public hearing in November 2023 under revised terms of reference; EC granted April 2024.
  • 10,913 tonnes of ash a day at 85% PLF; 14 cement companies had indicated demand for 12,230 tonnes a day.
  • Proposed ash pond: 25.164 million tonnes, said adequate for 25 years.
  • A. Ajay (TG Genco Director, Civil) said the plant followed zero discharge, with an ETP to recycle water so effluents would not reach the stream or the Krishna.
  • Political backing came from Miryalguda MLA Bathula Lakshma Reddy (Congress), who called the plant a "modern temple". Former BRS MLA N. Bhaskar Rao accused NGOs of exaggerating pollution concerns, and Congress district president K. Shankar Naik praised TG Genco. Most leaders, sarpanches and residents of 10 surrounding villages supported it. Andhra Pradesh villages downstream of the Krishna, within the 10-km radius, were not represented.
  • N. Harinder (Human Rights Forum) says he was silenced by the authorities when he raised this exclusion.
  • Nageshwar Rao says the contamination will compromise Krishna water quality up to Prakasam Barrage.
  • Land compensation (per resident V. Nageshwar Rao): against ₹2 lakh per acre earlier, residents were offered ₹5–6.3 lakh plus a plant job. Even people cultivating forest land without titles were offered monetary compensation. He says jobs and enhanced compensation helped turn opinion in the project's favour.
  • Fishers (Dubba Thanda): catch fell from 1–2 quintals/day (₹4,000–5,000) to days with under ₹500; nets bring up wet ash; skin wounds/itching reported. Hundreds of fishing families depend on the river.
  • A differently abled shepherd (M. Saidulu, Thalla Veerappagudem) says about 15 sheep died after drinking from the stream.
  • Dr Nageshwar Rao Adavath (Damarcherla PHC) reports at least 4–5 cases daily of allergic bronchitis, asthma and lung infections, with a definite rise compared with three years ago.
  • Wadapally village, downstream, once drew drinking water from the Krishna; 50–60% of residents now buy water from outside. The river stagnates after the Pulichintala project. Chemical leaching from an abandoned Deccan Chromates dump adds to the problem (per Harinder).
  • Research links heavy metals and alkaline compounds in fly ash to skin and eye irritation, diarrhoea and other health risks, including cancer.
  • 731 acres of planting near the ash pond and coal storage, plus a 100-metre-wide tree barrier on either side of the stream across 142 acres. Residents say these commitments are unfulfilled. There is little evidence of the promised green cover.
  • Contract coal: G9 grade, GCV 4,600–4,900 kcal/kg from SCCL. Reportedly received: G15/G16, around 2,500–3,000 kcal/kg. Lower-grade coal means more ash, while cement-industry demand stays constant.
  • A 4,000-MW plant at 85% PLF on 3,000 kcal/kg coal could generate about 21,000 tonnes of fly ash a day (over 75 lakh tonnes a year). The 14 cement companies' stated demand of 12,230 tonnes/day covers about 45 lakh tonnes a year.
  • Harinder: moving 12,230 tonnes a day in 10-tonne trucks needs one truck leaving every minute. Locals see only 200–300 trucks a day near the ash pond (Konda Lakshman Goud: "ash in our faces").
  • TG Genco CMD S. Harish: contamination was due to a single leakage five months ago; the plant is running at 50% PLF; one of two ash ponds is already full; cement companies' uptake is only 40%. He proposes raising the ash dyke height and comprehensive tenders with penalty clauses to ensure 100% disposal.
  • CEA data: YTPS average PLF 35.62% between 1 April and 17 November this year (versus the CMD's 50% claim). The article says Google Earth satellite images from December 2025 disprove the claim of a one-time leakage.
  • Shripad Dharmadhikary: shut the plant until a viable ash management system exists. The 100% utilisation law is over 25 years old. Boards, governments and district administrations are reluctant to act. Ash ponds are for emergency storage only. Illegal dumping often happens during monsoon. Ash already deposited will keep contaminating the Krishna for years.

Static–dynamic linkage

The static concept is prior environmental clearance as a promise that must be enforced after commissioning. Under the EIA Notification 2006, a thermal plant (a Category A project) goes through scoping, public consultation (including a public hearing) and expert appraisal. Conditions then bind the operator: zero discharge, treatment plants, green belts. Post-clearance monitoring is the weakest link. Regulators (SPCB, CPCB, MoEFCC) must act when conditions are breached. The Fly Ash (Ash Utilisation) Notification adds a waste-management layer: the generator is responsible for 100% ash utilisation. In this case the news shows each layer under strain. Public consultation left out downstream stakeholders. Conditions on green cover and effluent treatment are reported by residents as unmet. Ash utilisation depends on third-party (cement industry) demand that does not match supply. This is a classic "polluter pays / precautionary principle" and "right to a clean environment (Art. 21)" problem.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 — Environment: conservation, EIA, pollution & degradation. GS2 — statutory/regulatory bodies; accountability. Prelims — Environment: pollution, EIA, national institutions.

Background primer

EIA Notification, 2006 (prior environmental clearance)

What it is:
the notification under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 that makes prior environmental clearance (EC) mandatory for listed projects. It decentralised clearances into Category A (national-level appraisal) and Category B (state-level appraisal).
Why it matters:
a precautionary, participatory approach that integrates environmental costs and local voice before irreversible investment.

Fly Ash Utilisation / Ash Utilisation Notification (MoEFCC)

What it is:
a notification under the Environment (Protection) Act that makes coal/lignite thermal plants responsible for utilising the ash they generate in an eco-friendly manner.
Mandate:
every coal or lignite-based plant is primarily responsible for 100% utilisation of the ash (fly ash and bottom ash) it generates. Utilisation must not fall below 80% in any year, and plants must average 100% over a three-year cycle. A longer first cycle applies to plants starting below 80%.
Why it matters:
to ensure 100% utilisation and impose the polluter-pays principle, and to conserve topsoil by promoting ash-based building materials.

National Green Tribunal (NGT)

What it is:
a specialised statutory tribunal under the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010 for speedy disposal of environmental cases, with the Principal Bench in New Delhi and regional benches.
Mandate:
it hears civil cases on substantial environmental questions under the specified environmental laws. In this story it appears as the forum that suspended the YTPS clearance in 2022 and ordered fresh appraisal.
Why it matters:
the Act relates to the right to a healthy environment under Art. 21 and aims to provide a specialised, expert forum.

State Pollution Control Boards (SPCB) / CPCB

Additional context

  • Design assumptions at the EC stage (2022 EAC minutes): YTPS was planned to burn 13.28 MTPA of G9-grade coal with 30% ash content at 85% PLF, sourced from SCCL mines, generating 3.98 MTPA of total ash. Of this, fly ash is 80% (3.18 MTPA) and bottom ash 20% (0.80 MTPA).
  • Ash handling design: bottom ash is discharged as slurry through a pipeline into an ash pond of about 400 acres (out of a 2,800-acre project area).
  • Site: the pre-feasibility summary described the site as mostly reserved forest, semi-agricultural and partly revenue land. The Krishna river is the plant's water source.
  • Power-sector context: in a 2025 Telangana Electricity Regulatory Commission order, the DISCOMs stated a contracted thermal capacity of 9,791 MW and said they were adding another 4,000 MW from YTPS.

Mains dimensions

  • Regulatory failure after clearance: the EIA process ends at the grant of EC, but compliance is policed by SPCBs. The AWRS was found non-functional, there was no ETP/STP on site, and a show-cause notice in June produced little change five months later. Zero discharge, tree barriers (731 acres + 142 acres) and ash utilisation are conditions, not outcomes. The reluctance of boards and district administrations to act, noted by Dharmadhikary, is the core governance gap.
  • Contested numbers and accountability: the CMD's 50% PLF versus CEA's 35.62%; "single leak" versus satellite evidence from December 2025; 12,230 t/day demand versus about 21,000 t/day potential generation (a shortfall of about 30 lakh tonnes a year); 12,230 t/day would need a truck a minute but only 200–300 trucks a day are seen. This shows why independent data (CEA, satellite imagery) matters for enforcement.
  • Fuel-quality mismatch: contracted G9 coal versus reported G15/G16. Lower calorific value means more ash per unit of power, so ash targets are hard to meet even with good intentions. A coal-quality clause belongs in power-plant planning and coal-supply agreements.
  • Public participation deficit: the 2023 hearing was dominated by political leaders and supporters. Downstream Andhra Pradesh villages within the 10-km radius were not represented, and a dissenting member says he was silenced. Inter-state impacts of river pollution are not captured by a local hearing. A resident says jobs and compensation (₹5–6.3 lakh against ₹2 lakh per acre) swung opinion, raising questions about informed consent.
  • Process integrity: plagiarised EIA passages, and a source quoted as saying nobody knows who selected the site, with a stream running through it. The NGT suspended the EC in 2022 because the coal mix changed from 50:50 to 100% indigenous. Yet clearance was granted in April 2024 and operations began in January 2025.
  • Livelihood and health costs: collapsing fish catch, livestock deaths, respiratory disease, skin and eye ailments, and a contaminated downstream drinking-water source. This raises Art. 21 (right to health and a clean environment), social justice, and the polluter-pays principle.
  • Energy vs environment/development trade-off: a ₹36,000 crore plant serving the State's power demand versus local ecology. The political leaders' framing ("modern temple") against the local view ("ash in our faces") illustrates the tension; new coal capacity also raises a climate/transition question.
  • Way forward: enforce environmental compensation for ash non-utilisation under the 2021 notification; third-party audit of ash dykes and effluent systems; real-time monitoring and public disclosure; stricter coal-quality clauses; remediation of the stream; compensation to affected fishers; inclusion of downstream stakeholders in hearings.

Possible Mains question

**GS3, 15 marks:** "Despite a 100% fly-ash utilisation mandate and a participatory EIA process, thermal power plants continue to pollute surrounding water bodies. Critically examine the reasons and suggest institutional reforms for better enforcement."

Related topics

  • EIA 2006 process; draft EIA reform debates; post-clearance monitoring and compliance
  • National Green Tribunal Act, 2010; Art. 21 and the right to a healthy environment
  • Polluter pays principle; precautionary principle; public trust doctrine
  • Water (Prevention & Control of Pollution) Act, 1974; Air Act, 1981; CPCB/SPCBs
  • Fly ash management: Ash Utilisation Notification 2021, legacy ash; FGD norms for thermal plants
  • Krishna river basin and inter-state water issues
  • Coal grading, coal linkages and the transition debate (just transition)

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 21 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs