Resignation turned removal proceedings infructuous: ex-judge
Source: The Hindu, 21 November 2026
Summary
- Former Allahabad High Court judge Justice Yashwant Varma wrote to the Lok Sabha Secretary-General that parliamentary proceedings to remove him are "infructuous" because he has resigned. The inquiry began after burnt cash was found at his residence last year.
- The letter is dated September 10 and responds to the report of the inquiry committee constituted by Speaker Om Birla. The Lok Sabha Secretariat circulated it among MPs on Thursday.
- He maintained his innocence, denied that the currency was his or removed with his knowledge, and said resignation is not an admission. He declined to comment on the report and argued that, having left office, there is no constitutional or statutory basis for further steps.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 124(4): Supreme Court judge removed by the President on an address by both Houses on proved misbehaviour or incapacity. Article 124(5): Parliament regulates the procedure.
- Article 217(1)(b): High Court judges removed in the manner of Supreme Court judges. Article 218 extends Article 124(4)–(5) to High Court judges.
- Article 217(1)(a): a High Court judge may resign by writing to the President.
- Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968: governs investigation and proof of misbehaviour or incapacity.
- Notice threshold: 100 Lok Sabha MPs or 50 Rajya Sabha MPs; the presiding officer admits or rejects.
- Inquiry committee: Supreme Court judge + High Court Chief Justice + distinguished jurist.
- Special majority: majority of total membership + two-thirds of members present and voting, in each House.
- The word "impeachment" does not appear in the Constitution for judges.
Data and details
- Justice Yashwant Varma resigned from the Allahabad High Court on April 9.
- His letter is dated September 10, addressed to Lok Sabha Secretary-General Utpal Kumar Singh, and was circulated to MPs on Thursday.
- It responds to the report of the inquiry committee constituted by Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla. The cash was found at his residence "last year".
- He says there is "no constitutional or statutory jurisdiction or basis" for further steps, which would be "infructuous and without any basis in law".
- He reiterated innocence and denied that the currency belonged to him or was removed with his knowledge.
- His position: resignation is not to be read as an acknowledgement or admission of any allegation or finding.
- He declined to engage with the merits of the report and refused to furnish comments on it.
Static–dynamic linkage
Judges of the higher judiciary enjoy security of tenure to protect independence. They can be removed only for proved misbehaviour or incapacity, by an order of the President after a special-majority address by both Houses. The question here is whether a parliamentary inquiry can continue once the judge has resigned. Justice Varma says it cannot, because there is no office left from which to remove him. The case shows how the constitutional machinery for removal can be sidestepped by a resignation. It leaves open questions of accountability, benefits and any parallel criminal or other legal process.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Judiciary — independence and accountability; removal of Supreme Court/High Court judges (Articles 124, 217, 218); Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968; Parliament's powers.
Background primer
Removal of High Court and Supreme Court judges
- What it is:
- Articles 124 and 218 deal with removal of Supreme Court and High Court judges. The grounds are proved misbehaviour and incapacity, which the Constitution does not define. Article 124(5) lets Parliament regulate the procedure for the address and for investigation and proof, which it did through the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968. Article 218 applies Article 124(4) and (5) to High Court judges.
- Why it matters:
- The process is meant to protect judicial integrity without allowing political interference. The Constitution does not use the word "impeachment" for judges.
Additional context
- How the case began: A fire in March 2025 at Justice Varma's Delhi residence led to the discovery of substantial unaccounted cash. A three-judge in-house inquiry reported "strong inferential evidence" suggesting his control over the funds and recommended removal proceedings.
- Parliament's motion: After the in-house committee's prima facie report, 146 MPs moved a motion for his removal under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968.
- Court on the process: In a January 2026 ruling dismissing Justice Varma's challenge to the Speaker's unilateral committee, the Supreme Court observed that rejection of a notice in one House does not incapacitate the other House from proceeding.
- Effect of resignation, per one explainer: The formal impeachment process effectively becomes infructuous, and a voluntary resignation generally preserves pension and post-retirement benefits, unlike removal.
- Record: As of April 2026 coaching-source reporting, no judge has been impeached so far.
Mains dimensions
- Accountability gap: Resignation before a vote ends the constitutional route without any finding in Parliament. The inquiry committee's report exists, but the judge argues that the Houses have no basis to act on it now that he has left office.
- Jurisdictional question: His argument is that the removal power attaches to an office and lapses when the office is vacated. This tests whether Parliament's inquiry can serve any purpose, such as a public record, once the judge has left.
- Independence vs accountability: The stringent removal threshold protects judges from political pressure. Combined with a resignation exit, it can leave serious allegations unresolved, as this case shows.
- Resignation and benefits: Unlike removal, resignation can preserve pension and other benefits, which weakens the deterrent effect.
- Transparency: The judge's letter, dated September 10, reached MPs only when the Secretariat circulated it on Thursday. This raises the question of how open the in-house and parliamentary processes are, and of reform of the in-house procedure and a statutory judicial complaints mechanism.
- Ethics (GS4): Probity, transparency and "unaccounted cash" in a constitutional office. A resignation is not an admission, but the institutional trust cost is real.
- Way forward: Clarify by law whether proceedings can continue after resignation, define misbehaviour, set timelines for admission and inquiry, and consider a permanent judicial accountability body.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The constitutional process for removal of higher-court judges strikes a balance between judicial independence and accountability, but is it adequate? Discuss with reference to the recent case of resignation during parliamentary removal proceedings."
Related topics
- Judicial independence: security of tenure, collegium, NJAC debate
- In-house procedure for complaints against judges; Judicial Standards and Accountability Bill (past proposals)
- Powers and privileges of Parliament; role of the Speaker and Lok Sabha Secretariat
- Probity in public life and GS4 case studies
- Article 124 and Article 217 (appointment, tenure and conditions of service)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 21 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs