What protections do workers in India have in case of layoffs?
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 20 November 2026
Summary
- As India marks the first anniversary of its four Labour Codes on 21 November, two experts discuss what protection a retrenched worker actually has.
- The experts are K.R. Shyam Sundar (former HRM professor, Xavier School of Management, Jamshedpur) and Rahul Charkha (Partner, Economic Laws Practice). Nivedita Varadarajan moderated.
- The trigger is the rising number of layoffs, with AI adoption and heavy corporate investment in AI infrastructure adding to job-security fears.
- The discussion covers severance pay and its taxation, the adequacy of one-time compensation, and unemployment insurance models abroad. It also covers social security for gig, platform and informal workers, and what the new Codes changed.
Key facts for Prelims
- Four Labour Codes effective 21 Nov 2025, subsuming 29 laws: Code on Wages 2019, Industrial Relations Code 2020, Code on Social Security 2020, OSH&WC Code 2020.
- The IR Code replaces labour courts with Industrial Tribunals (per the article). The Code provides for Conciliation Officers and Industrial Tribunals.
- Retrenchment compensation: 15 days' average pay per completed year of service.
- Worker Re-Skilling Fund: employer pays 15 days' last drawn wages per retrenched worker within 45 days.
- Prior government permission threshold for lay-off/retrenchment/closure is 300 workers (earlier 100).
- Gig/platform workers are defined for the first time in the Code on Social Security, 2020. Aggregators contribute 1–2% of turnover, capped at 5% of payouts.
- e-Shram portal: launched 26 Aug 2021; National Database of Unorganised Workers.
- ESI (Employees' State Insurance) is a social-insurance scheme for workers and their families (named in the article). Labour is a Concurrent List subject.
- Reservation wage (article definition): the wage below which a worker will not sell their labour.
- The Labour Codes were due for a one-year anniversary on 21 Nov 2026 (per the article).
Data and details
- Severance pay is legally mandated only for certain sectors and is otherwise customary. The article says the rules apply only to three industries: coal mining, plantations and manufacturing. This leaves out service workers, IT workers and informal workers.
- IT is described as having had some of the worst layoffs in the last five years, without proper legal procedure being followed.
- Tax treatment (Charkha):
- Roughly one-third of severance is taken as tax.
- Severance is treated as "profit in lieu of salary", i.e. salary.
- A specific provision brings even the non-salary component of the termination package under tax as "income from other sources".
- The government's view is that it is salary received in advance and so taxable.
- The employment termination letter has several components. For a long time tax applied only to the salary component, which is the smaller part of the package.
- Foreign unemployment-insurance models cited:
- Germany: earnings-linked insurance, with payouts a percentage of prior earnings.
- USA: funded by a payroll tax, with an employer experience rating based on claims history and payroll changes, and a federal-state funding mix with its own administrative challenges.
- UK and Singapore: other schemes.
- Sri Lanka and many European countries are said to have stricter severance rules.
- The article says India's ESI hospitals are disproportionately few relative to the number of beneficiaries. It calls this "a serious loss" in bureaucracy, governance and vision.
- Gig/platform and informal workers are mentioned in the new Codes, and some state governments are forming laws for them.
- Proposed opt-in premium: gig workers pay a small premium against loss of revenue, matched by the aggregator and the customer.
- The Industrial Relations Code is said to have bundled multiple adjudicating authorities and removed labour courts. The article questions whether tribunal vacancies are filled on time and whether presiding officers are efficient.
- Unlike in Europe, the article says, even a single worker's layoff can trigger the whole machinery.
- Supporting argument: the traditional joint family was a cushion, and India has no unemployment relief system.
- Future labour-market governance, Shyam Sundar says, will sit more with the Skills Ministry than with the Labour or Commerce Ministries. He adds that "we are a huge failure" at implementing the infrastructure.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Layoff vs retrenchment (static):
- Indian law uses "retrenchment" for termination of service for reasons other than punishment.
- "Lay-off" is the temporary inability of an employer to provide work.
- The article notes that "layoff" is an Americanised term. In India the worker's experience (stigma, secrecy, barred premises) differs from the Western "pink slip, settle dues and leave" model.
- Labour on the Concurrent List: Labour falls under the Concurrent List, so both the Centre and states must frame and align their rules. This matters for uneven implementation of the Codes.
- Constitutional anchor (textbook): Directive Principles on the right to work and a living wage (Arts. 41, 43), and Art. 21 (dignity) underpin labour welfare. Unemployment relief is a DPSP aspiration, not an enforceable right.
- Two policy philosophies in the debate:
- Flexibility for firms ("ease of doing business").
- Income security for workers (severance, unemployment insurance, social security).
- Shyam Sundar argues the reforms served the first more than the second.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Economy: Employment, labour reforms, inclusive growth | GS2 – Governance/Social Justice: Welfare schemes for vulnerable sections, social security | GS2 – Polity: Concurrent List subjects, adjudicating bodies and quasi-judicial forums
Background primer
Four Labour Codes
- What it is:
- Four Labour Codes (the Code on Wages 2019, the Industrial Relations Code 2020, the Code on Social Security 2020 and the OSH&WC Code 2020) took effect on 21 November 2025, rationalising 29 existing labour laws.
Industrial Relations Code, 2020 – retrenchment provisions
- What it is:
- the Code governing trade unions, retrenchment, lay-off, closure and industrial disputes.
Code on Social Security, 2020 (gig/platform/informal workers)
- What it is:
- the framework extending social security beyond the organised sector.
Employees' State Insurance (ESI)
- What it is:
- a statutory insurance scheme for workers and their families (the article's example of a social security scheme).
Additional context
- The IR Code introduces Fixed Term Employment, with benefits equal to permanent workers. Gratuity eligibility for fixed-term employees is cut from five years to one. This is relevant to the article's question of which contract type a worker holds.
- The Labour Codes' uniform definition of "wages", with a 50% ceiling on exclusions (a PIB explainer places this under the IR Code), means retrenchment compensation, gratuity and social security contributions are computed on a larger wage base.
- A PIB Year-End Review (30 Dec 2025) reported 31.42 crore worker registrations and a platform-worker module with 14 aggregators onboarded. This bears on the article's point about e-Shram building the database.
- The Code on Social Security defines "gig work", "platform work" and "aggregators" for the first time in Indian labour law.
Mains dimensions
- Gap between law and coverage: Statutory severance covers only three industries (coal, plantations, manufacturing), so IT/services and informal workers fall outside. Layoffs in IT over five years allegedly skipped due legal process. The Codes' reach is therefore narrower than the workforce's exposure to AI-linked retrenchment.
- Employer practice vs best practice: Most employers prefer pay in one stroke and close the file. Progressive practice includes counselling, legal help, retraining, testimonials and employment-exchange registration. The Worker Re-Skilling Fund (15 days' wages) is the statutory step in this direction.
- Adjudication capacity: Replacing labour courts with Industrial Tribunals is justified as efficiency. The article asks whether vacancies are filled and presiding officers are competent, so institutional capacity matters more than structure.
- Taxation of severance: The government treats it as advance salary (profit in lieu of salary, then income from other sources). Critics see a roughly one-third haircut on a payment meant to cushion health-insurance loss and lost income.
- Unemployment insurance models: Germany (earnings-linked), USA (payroll tax with experience rating, federal-state) and UK/Singapore. India lacks any unemployment relief system and historically relied on the joint family. Options are tax-funded assistance for vulnerable workers or an insurance model, with urban parameters different from those of rural employment schemes.
- Social security for gig and informal workers:
- Legal recognition exists and e-Shram supplies the database.
- Charkha proposes extending existing insurance, or an opt-in premium matched by aggregator and customer.
- Shyam Sundar argues for a two-pronged approach: bring workers into the traditional net and build citizen–agency synergy.
- Delivery capacity (ESI hospitals) lags.
- Federalism: Labour is a Concurrent List subject and states are legislating for gig workers, so there is a risk of fragmented standards.
- Way forward: an unemployment-insurance design suited to India, extension of severance/procedure to services and IT, enforcement capacity, and a shift of labour-market governance towards skilling.
Possible Mains question
**GS3 (Economy) / GS2, 15 marks:** "Rising layoffs linked to AI adoption have exposed gaps in India's worker-protection framework. Examine how far the new Labour Codes address retrenchment and income security, and suggest what a workable unemployment-support system for India could look like."
Related topics
- Industrial Disputes Act 1947 (lay-off, retrenchment, closure) and its replacement by the IR Code
- Code on Social Security: EPFO, ESIC, gratuity, maternity benefit
- Gig economy: e-Shram, aggregators, state gig-worker laws (e.g. Rajasthan, Karnataka)
- Unorganised sector: informal employment, rural employment-guarantee schemes, DPSP Arts. 41/43, Concurrent List labour entries
- AI and the future of work: skilling and re-skilling policy
Topics: GS3Economy
All current affairs of 20 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs