BrainParrot

All-too fallible

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 18 November 2026

Summary

  • India voted against a proposed global moratorium on the death penalty at the UN, in line with its past position.
  • India defends retention as a sovereign decision backed by judicial safeguards. The editorial argues those safeguards do not work in practice and urges a formal suspension of executions and a review of death-penalty laws.

UPSC relevance: GS2 Polity — Judiciary, criminal justice, India at UN; GS4 — ethics of punishment

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art. 21 (life and personal liberty) is the constitutional anchor of limits on the death penalty. Arts. 72 and 161 give the President and Governors clemency powers.
  • "Rarest of rare" doctrine: Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980).
  • Law Commission of India's 262nd Report (2015), headed by Justice A.P. Shah: recommended abolishing the death penalty for all crimes except terrorism and waging war.
  • Parliament has expanded the number of capital offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).
  • Death sentences by sessions courts require High Court confirmation.
  • Project 39A is the source the editorial cites for the Supreme Court's release of death-row prisoners (2016–2025).

Data and details

  • India last executed convicts in 2020 (the Delhi gang-rape and murder case).
  • 574 people were on death row on 31 December 2025, the highest since 2016. The editorial attributes this to trial court rulings.
  • Per Project 39A, the Supreme Court released 38 persons from death row during 2016–2025. They had spent eight years there on average, and some had endured more than two decades.
  • The Supreme Court has increasingly restricted capital punishment, per the editorial.
  • Only a small group of countries worldwide execute more people than India.
  • Research cited has found no evidence of additional deterrence over life imprisonment.
  • The Law Commission 2015 report (Justice A.P. Shah) said the death penalty "fails to achieve any constitutionally valid penological goals". It recommended abolition for all crimes except terrorism and waging war.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The death penalty sits where the right to life (Art. 21), the criminal law (IPC, now BNS) and executive mercy powers meet. The Supreme Court allows it only in "rarest of rare" cases and requires High Court confirmation of sessions court death sentences.
  • The editorial's argument is that infallible procedure is impossible. Flawed evidence, false testimony and unequal access to competent counsel produce wrong or disproportionate outcomes in a punishment that cannot be reversed.
  • Internationally, India's stated line is that each State has the sovereign right to decide its own legal system and penalties, and that the death penalty is not prohibited by international law.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Judiciary, rights (Art. 21), executive clemency (Arts. 72/161); GS2 – IR: India's positions at international institutions (UNGA); GS2/GS4 – criminal justice reform and ethics of punishment.

Background primer

Capital punishment framework in India

What it is:
Death as a sentence for specified offences, awarded after conviction by a court. Statutory offences are now under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).

UN General Assembly moratorium resolution

What it is:
A recurring resolution that calls on States to establish a moratorium on executions "with a view to abolishing" the death penalty.

Law Commission of India and the death penalty

What it is:
An advisory body that reviews and recommends law reform.

Additional context

  • The UN General Assembly resolution on a moratorium (A/RES/79/179) was adopted on 17 December 2024 with 130 votes in favour, 32 against and 22 abstentions.
  • In 2022, a moratorium draft was approved in the Third Committee by 126 in favour to 37 against, with 24 abstentions, and India voted against it.
  • India has also told the UN that death sentences must be confirmed by a superior court and that the accused can appeal to a superior court or the Supreme Court.

Mains dimensions

  • Sovereignty vs international norm: India's UN vote rests on its right to determine its legal system. The editorial accepts the legal validity of distinguishing judicial executions from extrajudicial killings, but finds the claim that due process protects those facing execution weak.
  • Fallibility of the system:
  • Flawed evidence, false testimony and unequal access to competent legal representation all feed into outcomes.
  • The Supreme Court's release of 38 persons from death row (2016–2025) after an average of eight years shows that trial-court errors do get caught, but only after long suffering.
  • Trial courts continue to impose the sentence, which is why death row population is at its highest since 2016 (574).
  • Penal populism: Parliament widened capital offences under the BNS, especially after outrage over sexual violence. The editorial says this responds to public anger without fixing poor policing and low conviction rates, which is what actually weakens deterrence.
  • Escalation risk: Research suggests very harsh punishments for non-fatal crimes could push offenders to escalate violence, including killing witnesses.
  • Way forward (editorial):
  • Formally suspend executions and commission a review of penalty statutes and treatment of death-row prisoners.
  • Exempt offences that do not involve intentional killing from the penalty.
  • Abolish in law while improving investigation, prosecution and legal aid.
  • Counter-view: Retentionists argue for deterrence and for public sentiment on terrorism and heinous crimes. The 2015 Law Commission itself kept terrorism and waging war outside its abolition recommendation.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "India continues to retain the death penalty and opposes a UN moratorium, citing judicial safeguards. Critically examine whether these safeguards are adequate, with reference to recent trends in death sentences and the Law Commission's recommendations."

Related topics

  • Mercy petitions: Arts. 72/161 and Supreme Court guidelines on delay and clemency
  • Article 21 jurisprudence; ICCPR and its Second Optional Protocol
  • Police reforms, witness protection and legal aid (NALSA/Legal Services Authorities Act)
  • Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and criminal law overhaul; penal populism
  • Law Commission of India: functions and reports

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 18 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs