India’s green law needs baselines, not snapshots
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 16 November 2026
Summary
- On August 22 the Supreme Court set aside the National Green Tribunal's December 2017 judgment. That judgment had held the organisers of the 2016 World Culture Festival responsible for damage to the Yamuna floodplain.
- The Court's reasoning: liability under "polluter pays" needs attribution to a polluter. The floodplain was already damaged, and the Tribunal should have asked whether the preparatory work caused additional damage, which it did not answer.
- The author agrees with the principle but argues the reasoning leaves a gap. Section 17(2) of the NGT Act (apportionment of liability) was ignored, and the evidence relied on to exonerate the organisers is weak.
- The author proposes a mandatory baseline survey at the time public land is handed over.
Key facts for Prelims
- National Green Tribunal Act, 2010: Section 15 covers relief, compensation and restitution. Section 17 covers liability, and Section 17(2) allows equitable apportionment where damage is the combined effect of several activities. Section 20 requires the Tribunal to apply sustainable development, the precautionary principle and polluter pays.
- "Restoration" returns a site to its previous state, which is what Section 15 provides for. "Upgrade" betters it and is outside Section 15, as the author argues.
- Polluter pays presupposes an identifiable polluter. Liability attaches to the party to whom harm is attributable, not to whoever occupies the site later.
- The International Court of Justice, in its 2018 compensation ruling over a protected wetland on the Costa Rica–Nicaragua border, found the earlier condition unproved, reduced the claim, and still awarded a sum. The article offers this as a precedent for approximation over acquittal.
- The land was allotted by the Delhi Development Authority (DDA). The appellant was Vyakti Vikas Kendra India, which runs the Art of Living International Centre.
Data and details
- The festival ran from March 11 to 13, 2016, on 25 hectares of active floodplain upstream of the DND flyway in Delhi.
- The Supreme Court judgment of August 22 set aside the NGT's December 2017 judgment. The Authority must refund the ₹5 crore the organisers deposited as environmental compensation.
- On March 9, 2016, two days before the festival, the NGT allowed it to proceed on condition of a ₹5 crore deposit and restoration costs. That interim order recorded the floodplain as "drastically tampered with". It rested on a single site visit by a committee appointed 18 days earlier and gave no reasons.
- The promised reasons never came. The Tribunal clarified a month later that every argument was open, then declined for 20 months to revisit its finding because the organisers had not appealed.
- Evidence the land was already damaged:
- an April 2014 expert report described the floodplain as ruined;
- the NGT's July 2015 order recorded its restoration directions as unimplemented;
- in December 2015 the organisers reported construction debris across 25 to 30 acres, which the Authority permitted them to remove.
- In November 2016 the first committee said it could not assess the site's ecological condition before the event, four months after describing it in confident detail. It still recommended a full ecological upgrade, which the NGT ordered, adding the cost of a biodiversity park that never existed on the land.
- The Court's framing asks whether preparatory work from December 2015 to February 2016 caused additional damage to an already damaged floodplain. It holds the Tribunal should have answered that question.
- Section 17 is reproduced in full in the judgment, yet subsection (2) plays no part in the analysis.
- The material used to exonerate the organisers came from a second committee. It was constituted in July 2017 and comprised officials of the Authority and two state irrigation departments. Its findings:
- grass and standing water on site, no debris;
- no significant wetland in the allotted area;
- little difference in before-and-after Google Earth images;
- no soil compaction.
- Weaknesses the author identifies in that material:
- The wetland finding is circular. The case was that wetlands and hollows were filled and levelled, so an inspection 16 months later would find no wetland either way.
- The image comparison rests on the satellite photograph of September 5, 2015, which the judgment itself treats as unreliable a few pages earlier.
- The compaction finding was not scrutinised with the rigour applied to the first committee. The record discloses no method, depth or comparison ground.
- Ramps, roads, compacted earth and pontoon bridges were built on the site. The organisers do not deny that preparatory construction took place.
- Nobody asked for the organisers' own contracts, bills for earth and fill, machinery logs and compaction specifications.
- Manoj Misra, who brought the case before the Tribunal in 2016, did not live to see it decided. The case took about ten years.
Static–dynamic linkage
- The "polluter pays" principle makes the party responsible for environmental harm bear the cost of remedying it. It is only as strong as the evidence of causation.
- Where the original condition of a site is unrecorded, attribution fails. This lets earlier degradation shield later damage, so the most degraded commons are the easiest to degrade further.
- The NGT Act provides a tool for combined or cumulative causes (equitable apportionment, Section 17(2)). Courts should consider it before reaching an "acquittal".
- Restoration (Section 15) returns land to its earlier condition. Upgrading it beyond that is a different thing.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: conservation, environmental impact and pollution; principles of environmental law | GS2 – Polity: statutory quasi-judicial bodies (NGT), judiciary | Prelims – Environment: Polluter Pays, Precautionary Principle, floodplains and wetlands
Background primer
National Green Tribunal (NGT)
- What it is:
- A tribunal for effective and expeditious disposal of cases on environmental protection and conservation of forests and natural resources, including enforcement of legal rights relating to the environment and relief and compensation for damages.
- Founded:
- Established under Section 3 of the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010 (No. 19 of 2010), in force from 18 October 2010.
- Why it matters:
- specialised, expert-backed adjudication of environmental disputes, with a restorative as well as compensatory role.
Polluter Pays Principle
Additional context
- The NGT's 13 January 2015 judgment in Manoj Mishra v. Union of India (OA 6 of 2012) set directions for the rejuvenation of the Yamuna in Delhi. The article spells the name "Manoj Misra".
- The same judgment applied the polluter pays principle to dumping on the Yamuna bank. It fixed ₹5 lakh as the liability of whoever dumps debris or waste there, including the owner of the debris.
- The NGT's later orders summarising its Yamuna directions prohibit dumping of construction debris on the floodplain and bar edible-crop cultivation there.
- The expert committee behind the 2015 judgment recommended removal of encroachments and solid waste, reclaiming the floodplains, and biodiversity parks in four phases.
- The NGT's original ₹5 crore "environmental compensation" against the Art of Living Foundation for the Yamuna floodplain is listed among its landmark judgments.
Mains dimensions
- Polluter pays needs attribution: the Supreme Court is right that liability must attach to the party responsible. But where the baseline is unknown, rigid attribution can let the harm go unremedied.
- NGT's procedural failings: the interim order was passed without reasons, was based on one site visit, and was never revisited for 20 months. The committee later said it could not assess the pre-event condition. Poor process weakens environmental enforcement and gives grounds for reversal.
- Remedy overreach: ordering an "upgrade" and a biodiversity park goes beyond restoration under Section 15, and the NGT's power does not extend to that.
- Section 17(2) ignored: the statute already provides equitable apportionment for combined or indistinguishable damage. Not discussing it leaves a gap the Act had closed.
- Asymmetric scrutiny of evidence: the first committee's findings were tested with rigour, while the exonerating committee's findings (an official-only panel, a circular wetland finding, a discredited image, an undocumented compaction check) were not. Nobody sought the engineering records (contracts, fill bills, machinery logs).
- Degraded commons problem: the more degraded a commons, the more safely it can be degraded further, so past failure to protect the river becomes a defence for the next occupier.
- Way forward:
- require a baseline survey, at the applicant's cost, on the day possession of floodplain or comparable public land changes hands (levels, soil density and water absorption at marked points, vegetation and water-body map, dated photographs), signed by both officer and occupier;
- where the baseline cannot be recovered, prefer approximate compensation to acquittal, as the ICJ did.
Possible Mains question
**GS Paper III, 15 marks:** "The 'polluter pays' principle requires attribution of harm to a polluter. In the context of the Yamuna floodplain (World Culture Festival) litigation, examine the difficulties in applying this principle where baseline environmental conditions are unrecorded, and suggest institutional reforms."
Related topics
- Polluter pays, precautionary principle and public trust doctrine (Article 21; Article 48A; Article 51A(g))
- Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA); NGT's jurisdiction and powers
- Floodplain and wetland regulation (Wetlands Rules)
- Yamuna rejuvenation and NMCG
- Evidentiary burden and expert committees in environmental adjudication
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 16 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs