BrainParrot

The SIR exercise is also a technology failure

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 13 November 2026

Summary

  • The editorial argues that the 2025-26 Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls is the first revision of this scale run on a centralised digital platform. It says the technology has itself become a source of exclusion.
  • A Hindu analysis found 1,13,059 new enrolments in Bengaluru's final rolls could not be traced to any Form 6 or Form 8 record.
  • The People Against SIR platform has announced nationwide protests from November 26 to December 20.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Elections, ECI, e-Governance, Representation of the People Act

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 324: ECI's superintendence, direction and control of elections and electoral rolls. Article 326: universal adult suffrage (18 years). Article 327: Parliament's law-making power on elections.
  • RP Act, 1950, Section 21: preparation and revision of rolls. Section 21(3): special revision "in such manner as it may think fit". Section 16: disqualifies non-citizens from enrolment.
  • Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: procedure for enrolment and revision.
  • Form 6 is for new voters (first-time enrolment). Form 8 is for shifting or correction of entries.
  • Polling-station cap used in the SIR: 1,200 electors per station.
  • ASDDO: Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate, Others, the categories under which names were dropped from draft rolls.
  • Booth Level Officer (BLO) and Electoral Registration Officer (ERO) are the field and statutory custodians of the roll.
  • Lawrence Lessig's "code is law" is the idea that software architecture regulates behaviour as law does.

Data and details

  • In West Bengal, over 1.3 crore entries were flagged. Counsel told the Supreme Court that more than half of the "logical discrepancy" cases were name variations.
  • The final West Bengal roll was published with over half-a-crore names still marked "under adjudication".
  • Enumeration in Tamil Nadu and West Bengal ran about six weeks. Final rolls came in February and polls were scheduled for April.
  • The Hindu analysis of Delhi's draft roll found family-size checks flagged Muslim electors at a markedly higher rate.
  • Name-matching problems also surfaced in Telangana and Karnataka. The ECI's own search portal suggests trying different spellings.
  • West Bengal's 2002 rolls were in Bengali, digitised and rendered into English from old printed records, reportedly with machine tools.
  • The Supreme Court has not ruled on the legality of the "logical discrepancy" category. It allowed it in West Bengal only as an interim arrangement.
  • The de-duplication software was not used in Bihar. In late 2025 the ECI told the Supreme Court its results could not be relied on. It was switched back on in some States/UTs.
  • The "relative mapping" algorithm appeared on the app in some States, forcing BLOs to redo completed work.
  • In October, new ERONet options let EROs dispose of notice cases without hearings. They were explained through demonstration videos. Interim instructions came via video conferences and WhatsApp groups.
  • The online Form 6 carried an SIR declaration about parents and grandparents that applicants could not skip. It was not part of the statutory form, and the Supreme Court said it never approved the change.
  • In Delhi, voters whose enumeration forms were not received but who were earlier on the roll were told to submit Form 6, meant for first-time voters. The Court called this a "structural incongruity".
  • In Delhi, where no election is due, the Supreme Court questioned the tight deadline.
  • The author cites India's digital public infrastructure (IRCTC, e-filing, Aadhaar authentication, UPI, DigiLocker) as built over years of piloting and published specifications.
  • The hearing-trigger rule coded in software has never been published by the ECI, and it varies from State to State.
  • The user manuals and written SoPs lagged behind code changes. Citizens have nothing to cite on appeal.
  • No change freeze was applied during live operation. There were no pilots in a handful of constituencies across States before nationwide rollout.
  • Officials in some States asked for restoration of discretion to decide which flagged cases need hearings.
  • 1,13,059 new enrolments in the final roll across Bengaluru's 28 Assembly constituencies could not be traced. That is about 44% of 2,55,926 new enrolments, or nearly one in two.
  • In 25 of 28 constituencies, at least 35% of new enrolments were untraceable to Form 6 or Form 8 records.
  • Bangalore South had the most: 9,434 (45.1%) of 20,914 new enrolments. Others: Mahadevapura 9,279; K.R. Pura 8,013; Yeshwanthapura 7,373; Byatarayanapura 6,885. These five together account for 40,984 names, or 36.3% of the total.
  • The analysis compared final rolls with Form 9 reports and Form 11A/11B reports.
  • The PA-SIR plans peaceful protests nationwide from November 26 to December 20. They include a People's Parliament, a people's referendum, dharnas and voter-list audits. Constitution Day (November 26) is the launch, under the slogan "Right to Vote, Right to Livelihood".
  • PA-SIR notes "backtracking measures" by the ECI over the past 16 months, calling them belated half measures.
  • Its demands: scrap the SIR in toto, and remove and prosecute Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. Actor Prakash Raj and activist Anjali Bhardwaj are associated with the platform.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Article 324 gives the ECI superintendence, direction and control of electoral rolls and elections. Article 326 guarantees adult suffrage. Article 327 lets Parliament legislate on elections, subject to the Constitution.
  • The ECI's power is wide but must stay within statute and natural justice. Where law is silent, Article 324 fills the gap (Mohinder Singh Gill, 1977).
  • The editorial adds a governance lens. When rules are embedded in software and changed unannounced, the "code" replaces the legal procedure, which erodes rule-of-law and due-process safeguards in e-governance.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI), Representation of the People Acts, electoral reforms, Right to vote; GS2 – Governance: e-governance, transparency, accountability.

Background primer

Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls

What it is:
A focused, time-bound exercise by the ECI to update and verify electoral rolls. The latest SIR is a hybrid of intensive and summary revision, and adds documentary proof at the enumeration stage, a departure from past practice.

ERONet and the roll-management machinery

Additional context

  • Legal challenge and outcome: In the ADR vs. ECI case, the Supreme Court held that the ECI can conduct SIR under Article 324 read with the RP Act, 1950 and its Rules. The Court found SIR satisfied the three proportionality requirements, including a legitimate purpose.
  • The Court held the ECI may examine questions bearing on citizenship, but this does not divest an individual's citizenship claims. The competent authority under the Citizenship Act decides citizenship.
  • The Court said the ECI can scale a special revision statewide or nationwide where systemic inaccuracies require it.
  • Date of the judgment: The Supreme Court judgment (2026 INSC 564) is dated 27 May 2026.
  • Per a Drishti IAS explainer, UIDAI admitted in 2021 that Aadhaar data quality was insufficient to ensure voter uniqueness.

Mains dimensions

  • Technology governance: The core argument is that the SIR ignored basic discipline for digitising a manual process. That discipline means validating business rules on real data, multilingual name-matching tests, a change freeze, written SoPs before training, and forms aligned with statute.
  • Code as law / rule of law: Hidden rules decided who was heard. The unpublished hearing-trigger, the video-taught features and the non-statutory Form 6 declaration mean citizens cannot cite a rule on appeal. This hits procedural fairness and Article 14.
  • Algorithmic bias and exclusion: The "logical discrepancy" filters (parent-child age gaps, number of children per parent) mishandle approximate ages and flagged Muslim electors at a higher rate in Delhi. Name-matching across scripts misfired in West Bengal (more than half of discrepancy cases were name variations).
  • Federal and institutional coherence: The same tools behaved differently across States. The de-duplication software was switched on in some places after being judged unreliable earlier. BLOs bore stress and rework. Officials wanted discretion back.
  • Timing and electoral integrity: The electoral calendar, not system readiness, set deadlines. West Bengal went to polls with over half a crore names "under adjudication".
  • Trust and accountability (Bengaluru, protests): About 44% of new enrolments in Bengaluru were untraceable to source forms. Whether this is a record-keeping or substantive problem, it feeds the credibility debate that PA-SIR is mobilising around.
  • Way forward: Publish rules and SoPs; pilot before scaling; freeze changes during live operations; independent audit of the digital workflow; align the app with statutory forms; give human discretion to EROs for flagged cases.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has been defended on grounds of roll integrity but criticised for exclusion. Examine the role of technology design in the process, and suggest safeguards to protect voters' rights."

Related topics

  • Article 324 vs Articles 327/328; Mohinder Singh Gill case
  • Representation of the People Acts, 1950 and 1951
  • Aadhaar–EPIC linkage and electoral roll purification
  • Digital public infrastructure (DPI), e-governance principles, algorithmic accountability

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 13 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs