BrainParrot

Karnataka files plea against quashing of SC/ST quota hike

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 12 November 2026

Summary

  • Karnataka has filed a Special Leave Petition (SLP) in the Supreme Court against the Karnataka High Court's October 12 decision. The High Court quashed the increase in SC reservation (15% to 17%) and ST reservation (3% to 7%). A Government Order dated October 27 approved filing the SLP.
  • The High Court held the enhancement "constitutionally impermissible", since it took total reservation to 56% and breached the 50% cap laid down by the Supreme Court in 1992.
  • Separately, the Chief Minister's Office said the Congress government will keep pursuing the Centre to place the legislation in the Ninth Schedule.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: reservation, 50% ceiling, Ninth Schedule, federalism and judicial review

Key facts for Prelims

  • Special Leave Petition (SLP): appeal to the Supreme Court under Article 136, against a High Court judgment (a textbook provision, not from the article).
  • 50% ceiling: Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992); a ceiling set by the Supreme Court, not written in the Constitution.
  • Ninth Schedule: inserted by the First Amendment Act, 1951 under Article 31B; subject to the basic structure test for post-24 April 1973 laws (I.R. Coelho, 2007).
  • Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Reservation of Seats in Educational Institutions and of Appointments or Posts in the Services under the State) Act, 2022: Sections 3 and 4 struck down by the High Court as ultra vires.
  • The H.N. Nagamohan Das Commission (headed by a retired judge) recommended the enhancement.

Data and details

  • SC quota: 15% → 17%. ST quota: 3% → 7% (together +6 percentage points).
  • Karnataka's matrix before the hike: SC 15% + ST 3% + OBC 32% = 50%. With the hike the total reached 56%, which the High Court held breached the 50% cap.
  • High Court order: October 12. State Government Order approving the SLP: October 27. A Chief Minister's Office note issued on Wednesday said the State would continue to press the Centre.
  • 56,432 posts: recruitment was allowed in February 2026. The State says it protected the 6% SC/ST reservation under the backlog.
  • December 18, 2025: a resolution was moved in the legislature urging the Centre to insert the law in the Ninth Schedule.
  • The Act followed a commission recommendation. The High Court held the Act ultra vires and struck down its Sections 3 and 4.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Articles 15(4) and 16(4) enable special provisions and reservation for backward classes and SC/ST. The Supreme Court limited their quantum through a judicially evolved 50% ceiling.
  • States try to exceed the ceiling in two ways. One is a legislative route, backed by commission data and "exceptional circumstances". The other is the Ninth Schedule route, placing the law beyond ordinary fundamental-rights challenge.
  • The second route is limited by the basic structure doctrine. Karnataka is pursuing both: an SLP in court and a political push for Ninth Schedule inclusion.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional provisions on reservation (Articles 15, 16), basic structure, Ninth Schedule (Article 31B), judicial review; Centre–State relations.

Background primer

50% ceiling on reservation (Indra Sawhney, 1992)

What it is:
a judicially laid down limit on total reservation. The Court ruled that reservations should not exceed 50% of total available posts, except in extraordinary circumstances.
Founded:
the 1992 *Indra Sawhney v. Union of India* (Mandal Commission case) decided by a nine-judge Bench. It set a 50% cap on total reservations in government jobs and educational institutions.
Members:
the cap covers combined SC, ST and OBC quotas. The EWS judgment later treated the 50% rule as not inflexible and as applying only to SC/ST/SEBC/OBC, not the general category.
Mandate:
it balances the equality guarantees in Articles 14 and 16(1) against group-specific reservation.
Why it matters:
reservation is an exception to equality of opportunity, so it must be bounded.

Ninth Schedule (Article 31B)

What it is:
a list of central and state laws that cannot be challenged in courts for violating Fundamental Rights.
Founded:
added by the Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951. Its original purpose was to protect land reform laws.
Mandate:
the Coelho (2007) verdict held that post-1973 laws in the Ninth Schedule must follow the basic structure doctrine. It allows scrutiny of laws added after April 24, 1973 if they violate fundamental rights.
Why it matters:
to shield social-justice and agrarian laws from prolonged litigation, an intent that Coelho then narrowed.

Additional context

  • Other states that have exceeded the cap: Tamil Nadu is the standing example. Maharashtra also legislated beyond the 50% limit (the Maratha quota).
  • The Tamil Nadu precedent: the Tamil Nadu reservation law was placed in the Ninth Schedule by the 76th Amendment (1994). The State gives 50% to OBCs, 18% to SCs and 1% to STs, a total of 69%.

Mains dimensions

  • Legal question: can a State breach the 50% ceiling? The Court allows it only in "extraordinary circumstances", which need quantifiable data. The State relied on the Nagamohan Das Commission, and the High Court still found the hike impermissible.
  • Political economy: the government is using litigation (SLP) and legislative/political routes (Ninth Schedule inclusion, the December 18, 2025 resolution urging the Centre) in parallel.
  • Federalism: inclusion in the Ninth Schedule requires a constitutional amendment, i.e. Parliament. The State depends on the Centre. Ninth Schedule inclusion would still face the basic structure test after Coelho.
  • Equity vs. merit/ceiling: the State's own matrix (SC 15% + ST 3% + OBC 32%) kept total reservation at 50% before the hike. After the hike it is 56%, which shrinks the unreserved share. Supporters of the cap defend open competition. Critics say the cap is arbitrary and does not reflect population shares.
  • Administrative impact: protecting the 6% backlog in the 56,432-post recruitment shows how court rulings disrupt ongoing recruitment. Courts, States and the Centre will need a clear and consistent policy.
  • Way forward: a fresh enumeration of backwardness and representation data (caste census), a judicial reconsideration of the cap, and a nationwide consensus rather than state-by-state litigation.

Possible Mains question

**GS Paper II, 15 marks:** "The 50% ceiling on reservation is a judicial creation, yet several States have breached it. Discuss the constitutional issues involved, including the role of the Ninth Schedule and the basic structure doctrine."

Related topics

  • Indra Sawhney (1992); Maratha reservation and the Supreme Court's treatment of the ceiling
  • 103rd Amendment (EWS quota) and Janhit Abhiyan (2022)
  • Article 31B, I.R. Coelho (2007), basic structure (Kesavananda Bharati)
  • OBC creamy layer (see the OBC creamy layer note of the same date)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 12 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs