How the algorithm is being targeted
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 12 November 2026
Summary
- The piece argues that India's digital public square is being squeezed from two sides. The first is mass blocking orders issued through the Sahyog portal. The second is pressure on platform algorithms, i.e. how content is recommended and ranked.
- Its running example is journalist Ila Kazmi. Her reel on police use of facial recognition at a Jantar Mantar protest became unavailable in India, and her Instagram account was later withheld. The Delhi High Court has asked the government, Delhi Police and Meta to produce the orders.
- The author concludes that citizens should push back and demand published, reasoned takedown orders.
Key facts for Prelims
- Section 69A, IT Act 2000: power to block public access to information, on Article 19(2)-linked grounds, with the 2009 Blocking Rules procedure.
- Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015): Section 66A struck down; Section 69A upheld because of safeguards (written reasons, hearing/committee review).
- Section 79 IT Act: safe-harbour for intermediaries. Section 79(3)(b) is the clause used for the Sahyog takedown notices.
- Article 19(1)(a) (speech), Article 19(2) (reasonable restrictions).
- Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) issues blocking directions and platform advisories.
- Karnataka High Court (September 24, 2025): dismissed X Corp's challenge and called Sahyog "far from being constitutional anathema."
- X is the notable platform that has not joined Sahyog; it has challenged the portal's legality.
Data and details
- July 23: journalist Ila Kazmi's reel showing a Delhi Police van at Jantar Mantar using facial recognition to match protesters' faces in real time. It became unavailable in India the next day. Her Instagram account was withheld on September 9, and Instagram cited "a legal request".
- October 9: in Ila Kazmi vs Union of India, the Delhi High Court asked the Centre, Delhi Police and Meta to produce the orders behind both blocks. Her notice named no agency, order or reference number.
- The Indian Express reported that at least 25 people the police had placed at the protest were in jail at that time. The editorial calls this a tool proven to err used in a sensitive situation.
- March–July: nearly 1.95 lakh blocking orders to Instagram, Facebook and YouTube, i.e. one every 68 seconds. Instagram alone received close to one lakh.
- Since February, platforms have had three hours to comply with any takedown via Sahyog.
- Cockroach Janta Party (CJP): began May 16. It crossed nine million Instagram followers in four days, overtaking the BJP's official handle (about 8.7 million), and now has over 23 million. Its X handle was withheld on May 21, "in response to a legal demand", two months before the July 20 Jantar Mantar protest.
- July 24: four days after the protest, the Prime Minister reportedly told his Cabinet to be more active on Instagram.
- October 10: MeitY wrote to Meta asking it to review its "recommendation and content ranking mechanisms" so they do not cause "disproportionate exposure of users to a single or limited set of narratives."
- Shrey Gupta (28, Ahmedabad engineer) built a website to collect videos of police action. He says four plain-clothes men took him to a police station and to the Crime Branch on July 22 at 10.30 pm, where he was questioned for four hours. He says an officer told him protesting was not the problem, posting about it was.
- In July, Meta pulled down the Prime Minister's video, then restored it, called it an error and apologised. A citizen blocked the same way gets neither reason nor apology.
- October 15: the Internet Freedom Foundation helped four reporters send legal notices to Meta. Their accounts were restored on October 19 and 20.
- The Karnataka HC ruling runs counter to the Shreya Singhal safeguards (written reasons, hearing, review), the editorial argues.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Article 19(1)(a) guarantees free speech, and Article 19(2) allows only "reasonable restrictions" on specified grounds. Online blocking must meet that test through Section 69A of the IT Act and the Blocking Rules, which require written reasons and review.
- The editorial's argument is that "fast, quasi-informal" takedown channels such as Sahyog, plus pressure on recommendation systems, bypass these safeguards. Blocking leaves a notice that can be challenged. Algorithmic down-ranking leaves nothing to challenge.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity & Governance: Article 19(1)(a) and 19(2), transparency and accountability; GS3 – Security/Cyber: IT Act, regulation of social media and emerging technology.
Background primer
Section 69A, IT Act, 2000 and the Blocking Rules, 2009
- What it is:
- a provision inserted by the IT (Amendment) Act 2008 that empowers the Central Government to block public access to information online in the interest of sovereignty, integrity, security, friendly relations with foreign states, public order or prevention of incitement to cognisable offences.
- Founded:
- inserted in 2008. Procedure is governed by the 2009 Blocking Rules, which require examination by a designated committee and approval by MeitY, except in emergencies.
- Members:
- the Central Government acts through MeitY and a designated committee. Intermediaries must comply with directions.
- Mandate:
- block content on the specified Article 19(2) grounds. Non-compliance can attract imprisonment up to seven years and a fine.
- Why it matters:
- in Shreya Singhal (2015) the Supreme Court upheld Section 69A as having adequate procedural safeguards and narrow parameters. It struck down Section 66A as violating Article 19(1)(a).
Sahyog portal
- What it is:
- a portal launched by the Ministry of Home Affairs in October 2024 and run through its Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre (I4C). Ministries, state governments and police use it to send takedown notices to intermediaries.
- Mandate:
- quicker coordination between law enforcement and platforms for takedown of unlawful content.
Additional context
- Rule 16 of the Blocking Rules requires strict confidentiality. Critics argue this prevents users from knowing why their content was blocked, which hinders recourse to the courts.
- Sahyog's origin: it grew out of a MeitY office memorandum of October 2023 that leveraged Section 79 of the IT Act. Platforms such as X argued that it bypasses the Section 69A safeguards.
Mains dimensions
- Free speech vs. regulation: the government can rightly point to harmful uses of Instagram. The Karnataka High Court ruling accepted Sahyog as lawful. The editorial argues that Shreya Singhal's safeguards still apply and were not followed (no agency, order or reference given).
- Process deficit: the three-hour deadline means "nobody weighs a post". Orders go out from ministries, state governments and the police, not through a single reviewed channel.
- Algorithmic governance: pressuring platforms to alter ranking is a less visible form of control than blocking. A blocked user at least gets a notice, whereas a down-ranked one has nothing to challenge.
- Surveillance and rights: real-time facial recognition at a protest, shown to be error-prone, raises privacy and proportionality concerns (Puttaswamy test: legality, necessity, proportionality).
- Accountability: the platform (Meta) too is accountable. It restored a PM video and apologised for an "error" but gave users no reasons.
- Way forward (from the editorial): citizens should refuse silence, as the restoration of four reporters' accounts after legal notices shows. MeitY and Meta should publish each order, or at least its issuer, date and grounds.
Possible Mains question
**GS Paper II, 15 marks:** "Online content takedowns by executive agencies, and executive pressure on platform algorithms, raise questions of free speech and procedural fairness. Discuss with reference to Section 69A of the IT Act, the Shreya Singhal judgment and the Sahyog portal."
Related topics
- Article 19(1)(a), 19(2); Puttaswamy (privacy) and proportionality
- IT Act 2000 (Sections 66A, 69A, 79); IT Rules 2021; intermediary liability and safe harbour
- Facial recognition technology and data protection law
- Press freedom and digital rights
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 12 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs