Fourth ‘encounter’ in just 4 months as rape-murder accused killed in Bengal
Source: The Hindu, 10 November 2026
Summary
- West Bengal police shot dead Dilip Roy, a prime accused in the rape and murder of a 13-year-old girl in Raiganj, Uttar Dinajpur. Police say he fired at them while trying to cross into Bihar.
- This is the fourth such "encounter" in four months since the BJP came to power in the state. CM Suvendu Adhikari, who also holds the police portfolio, has defended the practice and said police have a "free hand" in certain cases.
Key facts for Prelims
- PUCL v. State of Maharashtra (2014): 16-point guidelines on police encounters; law declared under Article 141. It arose under Article 32 (PIL).
- Article 21 (life and personal liberty) and Article 14 (equality) underpin protection against extra-judicial killing.
- "Police" and "public order" are State List subjects (Seventh Schedule, Entries 2 and 1).
- NHRC/SHRCs under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 must be informed of encounter deaths.
- Magisterial inquiry into police-encounter deaths is mandatory under PUCL (earlier CrPC provisions, now carried into the BNSS, 2023).
- Right of private defence (earlier IPC ss. 96–106, now BNS) is the legal basis police cite for "retaliatory" firing (stable background).
- Kulik Wildlife Sanctuary, where the body was found, lies in Raiganj, Uttar Dinajpur district (North Bengal), which borders Bihar.
Data and details
- Latest incident: the accused Dilip Roy was shot dead around 3.30 a.m. on Monday, in the Gauri village area, while allegedly trying to cross into Bihar. The 13-year-old victim went missing on Tuesday, and her mutilated body was recovered from the Kulik Wildlife Sanctuary on Thursday.
- Police say he shot at the personnel and was killed in retaliatory firing. He was rushed to hospital, declared dead and the body sent for autopsy.
- A case of rape and murder was registered at Raiganj police station after her parents' complaint.
- Pattern: this is the fourth encounter in four months, 13 days after two more on 27 October, 12 hours apart.
- Samaul Sheikh, a key accused in the 28 August murder of BJP worker Sujit Mondal, was shot dead in a gunfight in Murshidabad around 3 p.m.
- About 12 hours earlier, Prahlad Das, accused of raping and murdering a minor in Gaighata (North 24 Parganas), was shot dead around 3.30 a.m.
- On 8 July, in Baruipur (South 24 Parganas), Prabhas Mondal, prime accused in the rape-murder of a 12-year-old girl, was shot during a crime-scene reconstruction. The area had been tense since 5 July when her body was recovered from a pond.
- Official statements: Panchayat Minister Dilip Ghosh said police must act if accused persons try to evade the law or escape.
- On 3 November, CM Adhikari said criminals would not be spared if they harm women. Addressing reporters in Digha, he asked whether police should "keep gun in pocket" and said they act in self-defence.
- He said the government has given the police a free hand: they need not wait for permission from superiors in cases of rape and murder, drug trafficking and infiltration from Bangladesh, which the government treats with "zero tolerance".
- Notably absent in the report: it does not say whether an FIR on the encounter, an independent investigation, a magisterial inquiry or NHRC/SHRC intimation, the steps required by PUCL, was carried out in any of the four cases.
Static–dynamic linkage
Police and public order are State subjects. Every killing by police must satisfy Article 21 (no deprivation of life except by procedure established by law) and Article 14. The Supreme Court has laid down binding procedure for investigating encounter deaths. The key question is whether lethal force was used under the right of private defence and with independent scrutiny, or as extra-judicial punishment. A political announcement of "free hand" and zero tolerance clashes with the principle of rule of law.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental Rights (Article 21), judiciary, police accountability, statutory bodies (NHRC/SHRC); GS4 – Ethics: ends vs means, accountability in public service.
Background primer
PUCL v. State of Maharashtra (2014): guidelines on police encounters
- What it is:
- a Public Interest Litigation under Articles 32 and 21 in which the Supreme Court issued 16-point standard procedure for investigating police encounter deaths. The judgment is dated 23 September 2014 (2014) 10 SCC 635.
Human rights oversight
Additional context
- Courts continue to enforce PUCL: a 2026 High Court order in a bail matter held that, if the guidelines are not followed in an encounter with death or grievous injury, the team leader and the district police chief could be liable for contempt in addition to departmental proceedings.
- Under PUCL, a person aggrieved by inaction over an encounter death or grievous injury can apply to the Sessions Judge.
- The MHA told the Rajya Sabha (23 March 2022) that between 1 April 2016 and 10 March 2022, in 107 reported encounter-death cases the NHRC recommended compensation of ₹7,16,50,000.
- Local political reaction: Congress's Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury said the incidents deprived investigators of crucial information, and CPI(M)'s Mohammed Salim described the encounters as staged. BJP state president Samik Bhattacharya rejected the allegations, saying the term "encounter" was being misinterpreted.
- AIR reports Adhikari said police can take independent decisions in cases involving drug abuse and crimes against women.
Mains dimensions
- Pattern vs. isolated incident: four encounters in four months, three involving accused in rape-murder of minors, all with the same narrative of the accused firing first (fleeing, scene reconstruction), invites scrutiny of whether they are genuine.
- Rule of law and fair trial: a death at the hands of police ends investigation and trial. Opposition leaders call the cases staged and say investigators lost chances to obtain information, while the government says police acted in self-defence.
- Policy signalling: the CM's statement that police need not await permission from superiors in specified cases risks creating an incentive for lethal force. PUCL specifically discourages rewards that incentivise encounters.
- Public support vs. due process: public anger over crimes against children can make encounters popular. Constitutional morality requires punishment through courts, and the state's duty is to improve investigation, prosecution and speed, for example fast-track and POCSO courts.
- Federalism and oversight: as police is a State subject, the oversight is from courts, NHRC/SHRC, magistrates and legislatures.
- Ethics (GS4): ends vs means, accountability of public servants, and the moral hazard of political endorsement of extra-legal action.
- Way forward: strict PUCL compliance with independent investigation, publication of data on encounter deaths, training and non-lethal options, police reforms (Prakash Singh directions) and speedy trials.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Police 'encounters' have been defended as a response to heinous crimes, yet they raise serious questions about the rule of law. Discuss in the light of the Supreme Court's guidelines in PUCL v. State of Maharashtra."
Related topics
- Article 21, Article 14 and Article 141; Article 32 and PIL
- NHRC/SHRC: composition and powers; custodial violence and extra-judicial killings
- Police reforms: Prakash Singh case; POCSO Act and fast-track courts
- Right of private defence in criminal law (BNS) and magisterial inquiry (BNSS)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 10 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs