BrainParrot

At COP31, ‘overshoot’ narrative cannot replace climate action

GS3Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 10 November 2026

Summary

  • The 31st Conference of the Parties (COP31) to the UNFCCC started in Antalya, Türkiye on Monday. The year has seen extreme weather and an energy crisis, and the world is preparing to accept that warming will exceed 1.5°C.
  • The authors argue that "overshoot" (passing 1.5°C in the near term and returning by the end of the century) has become a buzzword. They say it risks letting developed countries avoid real emission cuts and finance delivery, and shifts the burden of carbon removal to the Global South.
  • They call for a return to basics: deep mitigation by developed countries, grant-based finance, technology transfer, and honest accounting of what overshoot pathways imply.

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Environment: climate change, international environmental agreements; GS2 — International Relations: climate negotiations, North–South equity

Key facts for Prelims

  • COP31: Antalya, Türkiye (9–20 November 2026); the 31st Conference of the Parties to the UNFCCC.
  • Paris Agreement: adopted at COP21 (2015); 1.5°C goal; NDCs every five years; Article 9.1 is the developed-country finance obligation.
  • COP29 NCQG: at least $300 billion a year for developing countries by 2035.
  • COP26 (Glasgow) is linked to "net-zero" as the buzzword (per the article). COP30 was held in Belém, Brazil, which agreed a Climate Finance Work Programme, per the authors.
  • EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM): a unilateral trade measure covering iron, steel, cement and aluminium.
  • Green Climate Fund (GCF): the fund from which the US rescinded $4 billion in pledges (per the article).
  • Direct air capture: a technology to remove CO2 from the atmosphere. Forests and soils do almost all current CO2 removal.
  • UNEP report: Limiting Overshoot: Navigating Exceedance of 1.5 degrees Celsius and Pathways towards Return.
  • Wadden Sea: a UNESCO World Heritage Site (mentioned as the site of gas drilling cleared by Germany and the Netherlands).

Data and details

  • Fossil fuel share of primary energy in 2025: about 83% (US) and 73% (EU).
  • US has exited the Paris Agreement twice and has proposed opening nearly 1.3 billion acres of its waters to offshore drilling.
  • Norway offered 70 new oil and gas exploration blocks, including in the Arctic. The UK approved the Jackdaw gas field. Germany and the Netherlands cleared gas drilling near the Wadden Sea.
  • Australia (which will preside over COP31 negotiations) has approved 37 fossil fuel projects since 2022.
  • Climate finance: developed countries reported about $137 billion mobilised in 2024. The authors cite an estimate of the true value at only $33–45 billion, with 65% of public finance as loans.
  • The US rescinded $4 billion in pledges to the Green Climate Fund. The UK almost halved its contribution.
  • Adaptation finance fell to $26 billion in 2023, against a need of at least $310–365 billion every year by 2035.
  • UNEP report: reversing just 0.1°C of warming would need permanent removal of 220 billion tonnes of CO2. The authors say this is a quantity the world currently emits, in five years.
  • The world removes about 2.2 billion tonnes of CO2 annually, almost entirely through forests and soils. Direct air capture removes barely 2 million tonnes, and scaling it could cost $600 per tonne.
  • National pledges already rely on nearly 1.2 billion hectares of land for CO2 removal, mostly in the Global South.
  • Switzerland plans to meet up to one-third of its 2030 target via credits from projects abroad, including cookstoves in rural Ghana. Its emissions were only 22% below 1990 levels in 2024 against a 50% target by 2030.
  • A US oil company chosen for federal direct-air-capture hub funding described the technology as a "license to operate" for 60–80 more years.
  • Notably absent: the UNEP report is silent on who should undertake and pay for removals and on whose land they will happen. The authors say no COP decision has referred to the quantitative value of the total or remaining carbon budget, nor discussed which countries spent it the most.
  • Demands: developed countries reach net-zero well before 2050 and net-negative emissions within their own borders. Developing countries get predictable, grant-based public finance (no loans or private investment). The Climate Finance Work Programme agreed at Belém must take shape in Antalya, with guidance on Article 9.1. Technology transfer barriers (IPR, premium pricing) must be discussed. Any overshoot pathway discussion must explain the term and acknowledge carbon budget, historical emissions, uncertainties, feasibility and consequences for livelihoods, food security, biodiversity and indigenous communities.
  • Authors: Ankita Ranjan (National Institute of Advanced Studies, Bengaluru) and Tejal Kanitkar (Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research, Mumbai).

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The Paris Agreement's core logic is nationally determined action with differentiated responsibilities. Developed countries are expected to lead on mitigation and provide finance. The authors argue that "overshoot" language blurs this.
  • Carbon budget logic: the remaining budget for 1.5°C is finite and historical emissions are unequal. Without allocating responsibility, "net-negative" promises can shift obligations onto countries with land but little historical emissions.
  • Climate finance is a legal obligation under Article 9.1, not charity. Loan-based and private flows do not meet its intent in this view.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: climate change, UNFCCC/Paris Agreement, mitigation and adaptation finance | GS2 – International Relations: global groupings, North–South equity, trade-climate linkages (CBAM) | GS3 – S&T: carbon dioxide removal

Background primer

UNFCCC and COP

What it is:
The UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (adopted 1992, entered into force 1994) is the parent climate treaty. The Conference of the Parties (COP) reviews implementation of the Convention and negotiates climate-related decisions.
Members:
All Parties to the Convention (decisions by consensus).
Mandate:
Review implementation and negotiate decisions on mitigation, adaptation, finance, loss and damage and technology.
Why it matters:
Collective action on a global commons problem with common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities.

Paris Agreement and Article 9.1

What it is:
Adopted at COP21 in 2015, committing nations to limit global warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels (the temperature goal, alongside well below 2°C).
Members:
Parties must submit revised nationally determined contributions (NDCs) to the UNFCCC secretariat every five years.
Mandate:
Article 9.1 provides that developed countries shall provide financial resources to assist developing countries with mitigation and adaptation.
Why it matters:
Finance by those who emitted most is the basis of the Agreement's equity.

Overshoot

What it is:
Scientists warn that the world will temporarily exceed the 1.5°C threshold, a situation known as overshoot. The authors define it as passing 1.5°C in the near term and returning to it by the end of this century.

CBAM (EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism)

Additional context

  • The UN's counter-framing. A UN News explainer quotes an expert saying "Overshoot is not surrender." It calls for faster emissions cuts and greater investment in protecting vulnerable communities. So overshoot can be used either as a call for urgency or, as the authors fear, as a licence for delay.

  • Second Global Stocktake. The second GST begins at COP31 and can reaffirm priority mitigation areas, extend quantified goals to 2035 and 2040, and make existing action areas more tangible.

  • Finance goal. At COP29, countries agreed on a climate finance goal of at least $300 billion annually for developing countries by 2035.

  • Outcome of COP30 (Belém). More than 80 countries backed Brazil's proposal for a formal fossil fuel transition roadmap, but earlier drafts containing it were removed in the final hours and the text only referred to the COP28 UAE Consensus. The final agreement included a call to triple adaptation finance by 2035.

  • Article 9.1 work programme. The Belém package proposed a two-year work programme on climate finance issues, including Article 9.1. This is the work programme the article wants to take shape in Antalya.

Mains dimensions

  • Equity and historical responsibility. Developed countries have used most of the carbon budget but continue to expand fossil fuel supply (US offshore, Norway Arctic blocks, UK Jackdaw, Australia's 37 projects). The authors say "overshoot" lets them postpone cuts.
  • Land and sink inequity. Large-scale removal depends on forests, soils and land, with 1.2 billion hectares already counted in pledges, mostly in the Global South. This raises food security, livelihood and indigenous rights concerns. Examples such as Switzerland's overseas credits show externalisation of obligations.
  • Technology reality check. Current removal is about 2.2 billion tonnes a year, almost all in forests and soils, against the scale needed. Direct air capture is tiny (2 million tonnes) and costly ($600 per tonne). Fossil interests see it as extending the life of oil and gas.
  • Finance gap. Reported finance ($137 billion) versus estimated real value ($33–45 billion), loan-heavy delivery, rescinded or halved pledges, and the adaptation shortfall ($26 billion versus $310–365 billion needed) weaken trust. The authors say Article 9.1 requires predictable grants.
  • Trade measures. CBAM on steel, cement, aluminium and iron penalises industrialisation in the Global South. This links climate to trade and the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities.
  • Counter-view. UN voices present overshoot as a call for more urgency, not surrender. The practical danger lies in how the term is used, not in the science itself. The authors do not say overshoot is false; they say it needs full context.
  • Implications for India. At COP30, India, with BASIC and LMDC, pressed for full implementation of Article 9.1 and for grant-based, scaled-up finance. Overshoot-based framing that dilutes developed-country finance and mitigation duties therefore cuts against India's climate-justice and CBDR-RC position.
  • Way forward. Insist on carbon-budget accounting in COP decisions. Operationalise the Article 9.1 work programme. Increase grant-based finance. Ensure technology transfer. Treat overshoot pathways with transparent safeguards.

Possible Mains question

**GS3 (Environment) / GS2, 15 marks:** "'Overshoot' risks becoming a narrative that shifts the burden of climate action from the Global North to the Global South. Critically examine, with reference to the Paris Agreement's provisions on finance and equity."

Related topics

  • UNFCCC principles: CBDR-RC, equity, historical responsibility; carbon budget
  • Paris Agreement architecture: NDCs, Global Stocktake, Article 6 (carbon markets), Article 9 (finance)
  • NCQG, Green Climate Fund, adaptation fund, loss and damage fund
  • CBAM and India's trade concerns; India's NDCs and net-zero 2070 target
  • Carbon dioxide removal: afforestation, BECCS, direct air capture

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 10 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs