BrainParrot

Cracker conundrum

GS3Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 10 November 2026

Summary

  • Two Deepavali nights followed the Supreme Court's temporary relaxation of the cracker ban. The Air Quality Index (AQI) in several north Indian cities was "severe" on Diwali night. The editorial says the Court is waiting for quantitative evidence on health effects, which it argues is almost impossible to get. It calls on the Court to give a final view and lay down contours for a time-bound policy.
  • Reports from Delhi, Kolkata, Mumbai and Chennai show spikes in PM2.5, firecracker-related fires, arrests, burn injuries and tonnes of waste. In Delhi, key monitoring data went missing at the peak.
  • Political reactions split along party lines. The West Bengal CM defended celebrations, while Congress and AAP attacked the Centre and Delhi government.

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Environment: air pollution, regulation; GS2 — Polity: judiciary, rights vs. religion, federalism; GS3 — Disaster Management

Key facts for Prelims

  • Green crackers: developed by CSIR-NEERI; certified by NEERI/PESO; at least 30% lower particulate matter; no barium; QR-code verification.
  • Arjun Gopal vs Union of India (2018): the Supreme Court judgment that banned conventional crackers and introduced green crackers.
  • M.C. Mehta case: the long-running Supreme Court case on air quality in the NCR.
  • PM2.5: particulate matter of 2.5 micrometres or less, which can enter lungs and the bloodstream.
  • WHO 24-hour guideline for PM2.5 cited in the article: 15 µg/m³.
  • SAFAR: the Central government's System of Air Quality and Weather Forecasting Research.
  • NCAP (2019): MoEFCC programme; 131 cities; PM10-based target; CPCB implements.
  • Disaster Management Act, 2005: the basis for the Mumbai prohibitory orders on aerial crackers.
  • CPCB issues the daily AQI bulletin; DPCC is Delhi's pollution control committee.
  • CAQM: the Commission for Air Quality Management in NCR, which is involved in the cracker case.

Data and details

  • Delhi's five-day average AQI before and after Diwali: about 298 to 358 (2024), 259 to 315 (2025), 350 to 376 (2026).
  • PM2.5 above 1,000 in Delhi and its outskirts on Diwali night, per air sensors run by various organisations.
  • AQI had already been "poor" and "very poor" in the first week of November.
  • CSIR-NEERI says low-emission crackers cut emissions by only 30–45% under stringent lab conditions. The editorial notes these percentages say nothing about gross particulate emissions.
  • The cracker season begins about a fortnight before Diwali. An earlier decision would have let stockists dispense green crackers better.
  • The Court was told an absolute ban would invite "illegal crackers from across the border".
  • The editorial says the Court acknowledges the implementation challenges of policing cracker sales but does not address them. It also says the Court "hyphenates" crackers with religious observance.
  • PM2.5 was 2,597 µg/m³ at Patparganj at 1 am on Monday (about 173.13 times the WHO limit of 15 µg/m³). It was 3,008.4 µg/m³ at NSUT West Campus at 5 am (about 200.5 times).
  • Crackers were burst past the 10 pm deadline. Traditional crackers were available in Delhi markets even though only green ones were allowed on November 7 and 8.
  • Data from several government-run stations went missing at peak pollution. Experts say missing peak values make air quality look better than it was.
  • Delhi's 24-hour AQI: 344 ("very poor") at 4 pm Monday, 370 at 9 am Monday, 376 a day earlier. The article also says AQI was "severe" on Monday in Delhi-NCR.
  • Gufran Beig (NIAS chair professor, SAFAR founder-director) said winds shifted from north-westerly to easterly/south-easterly on Sunday afternoon and picked up speed, so the stubble-burning effect in Delhi was almost negligible.
  • Stubble burning in neighbouring States contributed 5.1% of Delhi's PM2.5 on Sunday (Ministry of Earth Sciences).
  • Punjab: 1,152 stubble burning incidents on Sunday (highest this season), 198 on Monday, 4,657 this season (second lowest since 2020, till November 9) per IARI.
  • AAP and Congress attacked the BJP government over the missing data. AAP called it "data fraud". Delhi Labour Minister Kapil Mishra alleged a "conspiracy" by AAP-governed Punjab to burn stubble on Sunday evening.
  • Burn injuries: 397 reported in major Delhi hospitals after Diwali (per The Hindu data team). Severity ranged from 1–2% to as high as 65% of body surface area, per Sameek Bhattacharya. Most patients were children and young adults.
  • Mumbai: 137 firecracker-related fires on November 8 alone, and two women injured. Aerial crackers and rockets are banned until November 25 under the Disaster Management Act, 2005 by the Urban Disaster Management Authority (announced by BMC).
  • Kolkata: AQI crossed 500 and noise crossed permitted limits in some areas. About 205 people were arrested for violating cracker rules. CM Suvendu Adhikari blamed "communists" and non-Sanatanis and said he felt the situation was "largely under control". BJP MLA Papia Adhikari claimed bursting crackers cures illnesses.
  • Chennai: the Greater Chennai Corporation cleared about 400 tonnes of cracker waste, with 200 more expected, and deployed 600 extra sanitation workers.
  • Congress's Jairam Ramesh said the Centre has rejected studies in Parliament and outside because they are not India-specific or not directly attributable.
  • FICCI-EY report Clean Air, Healthy India (October 2026): 2 million deaths in 2023 (about 22% of all deaths) attributed to air pollution. More than 660 million Indians live in areas where annual fine particulate pollution exceeds the national standard, with a 3.5-year average loss of life expectancy.
  • The report says pollution raises healthcare costs and absenteeism and lowers productivity. It calls for explicit PM2.5 targets, precursor gas controls and health-linked exposure indicators. It says AQI is a warning tool and not a pollution-control measure.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Air quality is a right-to-life issue (Article 21, which includes the right to a healthy environment). Article 25 protects religious freedom, but it is "subject to public order, morality and health". The editorial's point is that the Court recognises this tension but gives it only lip service.
  • Pollution spikes come from a mix of sources: meteorology (slack winds, dryness), vehicles, industry, construction dust, stubble burning, and crackers. This is why attribution to any one source is hard, and why courts struggle with the burden of proof.
  • The regulatory design depends on certification (NEERI/PESO), licensing, QR codes and policing. Enforcement is the weak link.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: air pollution, pollution control and regulation, environmental governance | GS2 – Polity: judiciary and policy-making, balancing Articles 21 and 25, federalism (Centre/State/local bodies) | GS3 – Disaster Management (Disaster Management Act, 2005)

Background primer

Green crackers (CSIR-NEERI) and the Supreme Court's regulation of crackers

What it is:
Green crackers were developed by CSIR-NEERI to reduce environmental impact. They are not pollution-free but cut particulate matter by at least 30% and exclude chemicals such as barium nitrate, arsenic, lithium and mercury.
Founded:
NEERI says the green cracker exercise in India began in 2018. They were introduced in the Arjun Gopal vs Union of India (2018) judgment, which banned conventional firecrackers.
Members:
NEERI developed a standard operating procedure to register green cracker manufacturers and transfer technology. A QR code was developed for registered manufacturers, though NEERI found instances of QR codes being sold to unregistered manufacturers. PESO licenses manufacturing and sale.
Mandate:
Certified low-emission crackers can be sold only through licensed traders. The Court's conditions have included no sale through e-commerce, no "laris" (series crackers), time windows and no crackers containing barium.
Why it matters:
The Court has spoken of a "balanced approach" between festivals and environmental protection. The idea is that a regulated, lower-emission product can replace a blanket ban that is hard to enforce.

Air Quality Index and NCAP

Disaster Management Act, 2005

Additional context

  • The latest order. The Supreme Court allowed green crackers in Delhi-NCR from 6–7 am and 8–10 pm on November 7 and 8. No fireworks within 300 metres of hospitals, nursing homes, primary and district health centres, old-age homes and silence zones. No manufacture or sale of crackers joined in series and garlands, and no barium or non-NEERI-approved crackers. The complete ban was to be restored from November 9.
  • Earlier orders. The matter is in the long-pending M.C. Mehta air-quality case. On April 3, 2025, a Bench rejected applications for relaxation and affirmed the ban on firecrackers in Delhi-NCR, saying it would reconsider only if pollution from "so-called green crackers" was shown to be bare minimum. In October 2025 the Court allowed sale and use of green crackers from October 18 to 21, only from 6–7 am and 8–10 pm on two days.
  • Court's view on blanket bans. In October 2025, the Court called the relaxation a "test case" and noted that blanket bans led to smuggling and use of harmful fireworks. This matches the argument in the editorial and the "illegal crackers across the border" submission.
  • Evidence gap. A Union of India report, noted by the Court in 2025, put green crackers at 30% less polluting than regular crackers.
  • NCAP progress. In 2025-26, 108 of the 130 NCAP cities recorded lower annual PM10 than in 2017-18, and 26 achieved reductions above 40%. Only 26 of 130 cities met the 40% reduction target, so the national target remains largely unachieved.

Mains dimensions

  • Burden of proof. The Court seeks direct causation, which is nearly impossible. The editorial argues that crackers add to an already vitiated atmosphere. A precautionary approach would act on the consistent timing of spikes (a rise of about 26 to 60 points in the five-day AQI average in the three years given) rather than wait for isolation of the cracker share.
  • Meteorology matters. On Monday, winds reduced the stubble-burning effect, yet PM2.5 still reached more than 2,500 µg/m³ locally. This shows that crackers alone can cause acute spikes, even if their share of seasonal pollution cannot be separated.
  • Limits of the "green" solution. NEERI's 30–45% reduction is under lab conditions only. There were still traditional crackers in markets, QR codes were misused and policing is weak.
  • Timing and predictability. A decision issued days before Diwali leaves stockists and enforcement agencies no time. The editorial urges a final, reasoned policy, not annual ad hoc relaxations.
  • Rights and religion. The Constitution does not allow religious custom to override health and life (Articles 21, 25 and 51A(g)). Leaders' remarks in Kolkata linking opposition to firecrackers with religion show how the debate becomes politicised.
  • Data credibility. Missing station data at peak and the blame game (AAP "data fraud", the "conspiracy" claim) undermine trust in monitoring. Reliable data is itself a governance issue.
  • Public health and economy. The FICCI-EY estimates and the burn-injury figures show costs beyond air quality, including healthcare burden, productivity, and injuries among children and young adults. Municipal costs include waste (Chennai) and fire response (Mumbai).
  • Federalism. Enforcement lies with States, police and municipal corporations. Local bodies used the Disaster Management Act in Mumbai as a tool. Policy is uneven across cities.
  • Way forward. Issue a time-bound national policy on manufacture, sale and use. Strengthen NEERI/PESO verification and supply-chain control. Publish source-apportionment data. Move NCAP towards PM2.5 targets. Offer livelihood support to cracker-industry workers. Run awareness campaigns.

Possible Mains question

**GS3 (Environment) / GS2, 15 marks:** "The Supreme Court has repeatedly oscillated between banning and conditionally permitting firecrackers. Critically examine the effectiveness of 'green crackers' and suggest a durable policy framework that balances public health, livelihoods and cultural practice."

Related topics

  • Article 21 (right to clean environment), Article 25, Article 51A(g); precautionary principle and polluter-pays
  • Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981; NAAQS; CPCB/SPCBs; CAQM
  • NCAP, GRAP, stubble-burning policy and Punjab/Haryana
  • Disaster Management Act, 2005
  • Health impacts of PM2.5 and WHO air quality guidelines

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 10 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs