BrainParrot

Building over Srinagar’s future

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 10 November 2026

Summary

  • The author argues that recent building-bye-law changes and the J&K Ease of Doing Business Act, 2026 allow more and taller construction on more land, including farmland, in Srinagar. This is happening in a hill city already stressed by flood and seismic risk.
  • The Act lets a committee relax Master Plan conditions and bypasses the Master Plan-2035. Srinagar has had no elected municipal council since 2023.
  • He proposes a suspension of the exemptions, immediate civic elections and carrying-capacity assessments.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: local governance/74th Amendment; GS1 — Geography: urbanisation; GS3 — Environment: wetlands, disaster management

Key facts for Prelims

  • The Twelfth Schedule lists 18 functions; Part IXA covers Articles 243P–243ZG.
  • Article 243W empowers State Legislatures to devolve powers and responsibilities to municipalities.
  • Municipalities have a five-year term, and fresh elections must be held before expiry or within six months of dissolution (Article 243U). The State Election Commission conducts them (Article 243ZA).
  • Metropolitan Planning Committees and District Planning Committees prepare integrated plans.
  • FAR/FSI, ground coverage and setbacks are development-control tools in building by-laws and Master Plans.
  • Liquefaction: loss of soil strength in saturated soil during earthquakes. It is relevant to river-plain cities like Srinagar on the Jhelum.
  • Hokersar and Shallabugh are Ramsar wetlands near Srinagar, as the article notes.
  • J&K is a Union Territory with a Legislature and a Lieutenant Governor, whose assent made the Bill law.
  • CAG audits public spending and found problems in Srinagar's Smart City works, as the article notes.

Data and details

  • Timeline: building by-laws amended on 1 Dec 2025. On 24 Jul 2026 they were extended to Housing Board colonies with extra FAR and reduced setbacks. On 9 Sep 2026 fresh limits were proposed, including 300% FAR for commercial complexes. The Ease of Doing Business Bill, 2026 was tabled on 28 Sep and received the LG's assent in the first week of October.
  • FAR example: a 100 sq m plot at 200% FAR allows 200 sq m of floor space.
  • Act provisions: residential buildings up to 24 m (about 8 storeys) and 5,000 sq m floor area can be built outside FAR and ground-coverage limits on a third-party certificate. Malls of the same size need no government approval.
  • Agricultural and horticultural land is opened for construction, and only red- and orange-category industries are barred. Section 22 lets an executive committee relax Master Plan conditions for individual enterprises.
  • Master Plan-2035: approved February 2019, covers 766 sq km and a projected 3.5 million people. It identifies wetlands and flood basins as at risk.
  • Former Chief Town Planner Iftikhar Ahmad Hakim says the law was passed without public consultation. He warns eight-storey buildings will increase vulnerability.
  • Hazards: government housing projects were earlier halted over liquefaction risks. A 2026 study of 87 wards found high to severe susceptibility along the Jhelum.
  • Land loss: farmland shrank from 142 sq km (1992) to about 66 sq km (2024). Marshland shrank from over 1,100 ha to 283 ha, a decline of over 70%.
  • Smart Cities: the mission ended in March 2025. CAG found no separate networks for sewage and stormwater. 49 pumping stations costing ₹124 crore spend much of the year pumping sewage into water bodies.
  • A study in the journal Water estimates that of 201 million litres of sewage produced daily, about 147 million litres reach Dal Lake and the Jhelum untreated.
  • Local democracy: the Srinagar Municipal Corporation's term ended on 5 Nov 2023 and there is still no elected mayor or councillor. The Bill was moved by an elected Chief Minister. Planning responsibilities sit with officers, authorities and a Smart City company.
  • Way forward proposed: suspend FAR and land-use exemptions and Section 22 until they are brought within the Master Plan and open to public objections. Hold municipal elections now, make councillors the first readers of plan changes, and approve no large construction without a published carrying-capacity assessment covering water, slopes, drains and wetlands.

Static–dynamic linkage

Under the 74th Amendment, urban planning and the regulation of land use and buildings are municipal functions. A Master Plan is the statutory instrument of planning, and its zoning and density rules (such as FAR) implement carrying capacity. In this case the author argues that ease-of-doing-business reform, a deregulation agenda, is overriding both the plan and local democracy, with ecological costs for a city built on flood basins and wetlands.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: local governance, 74th Constitutional Amendment, Union Territories; GS1 – Geography: urbanisation and its problems; GS3 – Environment: conservation, disaster management (wetlands and floods).

Background primer

74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992

What it is:
added Part IXA (Articles 243P to 243ZG) and the Twelfth Schedule listing 18 functions for municipalities.
Founded:
in force from 1 June 1993. It was passed because many municipal bodies had become weak and dependent, without regular elections or powers.
Mandate:
Article 243W lets State Legislatures give municipalities powers to function as institutions of self-government. The Twelfth Schedule includes urban planning and regulation of land use and construction of buildings.
Why it matters:
democratic decentralisation of urban governance.

Master Plan, FAR and the Srinagar Development Authority

Smart Cities Mission

Additional context

  • The Act's own stated aim: to replace permission-based control with rule-based governance for ease of doing business in the UT of Jammu and Kashmir.
  • The Assembly's explanatory note says the Government of India identified 23 priority areas under De-regulation Phase-2 for Viksit Bharat, and that 12 of these will be implemented in J&K after enactment.
  • The Bill is meant to consolidate proposals so that a single Cabinet approval and a single Legislature approval suffice.
  • The Master Plan itself recognised soil limits: it said vertical development is limited by low soil bearing capacity and earmarked highlands for expansion.
  • It also planned density: it envisaged raising gross residential densities with a matching increase in FAR/FSI to preserve prime agricultural land and ecologically fragile areas.
  • Public participation in the plan: about 320 suggestions and objections were examined by a government committee before approval.
  • A review of the Master Plan also considered High Court directions on Dal and Nigeen buffer zones; SDA had received 140 objections in that exercise.
  • Comparable governance gap: a CAG audit in Karnataka found town planning and land-use regulation were still delivered by state-controlled parastatals with no elected ULB representatives, despite the 74th Amendment.

Mains dimensions

  • Planning vs. deregulation: repeated rule changes within nine months, ending in a statute that exempts large buildings from FAR on a third-party certificate, undermine statutory planning. The author's point is that the Master Plan is a city's "promise to itself" and waivers by a committee rewrite it.
  • Ecological carrying capacity: farmland fell from 142 to about 66 sq km, and marsh, the city's "sponge", fell over 70%. Opening farmland and wetlands to building cuts floodwater absorption in a city on flood basins, with liquefaction risk along the Jhelum.
  • Hazard exposure: high to severe liquefaction susceptibility across 87 wards and halted government housing projects show that tall construction raises seismic and flood risk.
  • Accountability deficit: the Smart City model, run by a company, left sewage and stormwater unplanned (CAG findings, 49 pumping stations costing ₹124 crore, 147 of 201 MLD untreated reaching water bodies). Management via an SPV weakens answerability.
  • Democratic deficit: the municipal council has been absent since November 2023, though the 74th Amendment lists planning and land-use regulation as municipal functions. The author stresses that no public consultation preceded the law.
  • Himalayan context: the author's opening point is that hill towns must measure carrying capacity before approving large construction, a theme shared with other stressed mountain towns.
  • Balanced view: single-window clearances and quicker permits are welcome, and the author accepts ease of doing business. The point is that speed should not override planning, public objections or ecological limits.

Possible Mains question

**GS2/GS1, 15 marks:** "Ease-of-doing-business reforms in hill cities often conflict with planning norms and ecological limits. Discuss with reference to the role of urban local bodies under the 74th Constitutional Amendment."

Related topics

  • 74th Amendment: Twelfth Schedule, State Finance Commission, ward committees, Metropolitan/District Planning Committees
  • Smart Cities Mission and AMRUT; SPV governance model
  • Wetland conservation: Ramsar Convention, Wetlands (Conservation and Management) Rules, urban flooding (Srinagar floods, 2014)
  • Disaster management: seismic zones, liquefaction, Himalayan carrying capacity (Joshimath/Shimla parallels)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 10 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs