BJP leaders meet President over ‘irregularities’ in KPSC
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 6 November 2026
Summary
- A BJP delegation met President Droupadi Murmu on Thursday. It asked her to act on the recommendation of former Keralam Governor Rajendra Vishwanath Arlekar to remove the State Public Service Commission (KPSC) Chairman M.R. Baiju and its members over alleged irregularities. The former Governor had flagged these irregularities before demitting office.
- In a separate development, the Crime Branch of the Keralam Police registered FIRs against the PSC Chairman, members and officials over alleged exam irregularities. One FIR concerns the Fisheries Extension Officer exam; another concerns the Assistant Motor Vehicle Inspector exam.
- BJP State president Rajeev Chandrasekhar framed it as a youth-jobs issue. He also made partisan attacks on the Congress and the CPI(M)-linked SFI.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 315: Constitution of Public Service Commissions for the Union and the States. Article 316: appointment and term. Article 317: removal and suspension.
- State PSC members are appointed by the Governor but removed only by the President. A State Commission member may resign by writing to the Governor.
- Removal for misbehaviour needs a Supreme Court inquiry on presidential reference (Art. 145 procedure). The Court's report is the basis for the President's order.
- Governor's power: suspend a State PSC Chairman or member after a Supreme Court reference (Art. 317(2)).
- Direct removal by the President (no SC inquiry): insolvency, outside paid employment, or unfitness due to infirmity of mind or body (Art. 317(3)).
- Art. 317(4): interest in a government contract or its profits is deemed misbehaviour.
- Term: six years or age 62 (State PSC), whichever is earlier. UPSC members hold office for six years or till age 65. Members are ineligible for reappointment to the same office.
- Governor's regulations under Art. 318 (conditions of service and staff) and Art. 320(3) proviso (consultation regulations) govern State PSC working.
- The Kerala PSC has a Chairman and 20 members.
Data and details
- Delegation leaders: Rajya Sabha MP (nominated) C. Sadanandan (leader); Rajeev Chandrasekhar (State BJP president); P.T. Usha (RS member).
- Target of the memorandum: removal of KPSC Chairman M.R. Baiju and its members, in line with the recommendation of former Governor Arlekar, who flagged irregularities before demitting office.
- Allegations by the BJP:
- Youth have been protesting and on strike "for the last several months", having secured ranks but been denied jobs.
- Rank holders have protested outside the Secretariat for months, "with the full knowledge of the Congress Chief Minister".
- The PSC is allegedly in "complete capture" by vested interests such as the SFI, part of the CPI(M) ecosystem.
- The Congress and Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi raise "manufactured issues" about youth while ignoring Keralam's youth. It alleged hypocrisy on SIR (against it in Delhi, in favour in Keralam).
- Police action:
- The Crime Branch of the Keralam Police registered an FIR against the KPSC Chairman and members over the Fisheries Extension Officer exam at the Kerala University of Fisheries and Ocean Studies.
- The latest FIR explicitly names three accused categories: Chairman, members and officials.
- A further FIR names PSC members over the Assistant Motor Vehicle Inspector recruitment exam.
- The articles do not say that any reference has been made to the Supreme Court. They also do not say that the Governor has suspended anyone.
Static–dynamic linkage
- State PSCs are constitutional bodies whose members have special protection from removal, so that they stay free from political pressure.
- Appointment: The Governor appoints the Chairman and members (Art. 316).
- Removal: Only the President can remove them, and only on proven "misbehaviour" after a Supreme Court inquiry on a presidential reference (Art. 317(1)). A Governor's recommendation or a political memorandum cannot by itself remove a State PSC member.
- Suspension: The Governor may suspend a member only after a Supreme Court reference has been made (Art. 317(2)).
- Other grounds: Insolvency, outside paid employment or unfitness due to infirmity of mind or body allow the President to remove a member directly (Art. 317(3)).
- Why it matters here: The BJP's request tests this procedure. It also shows the politicisation of recruitment bodies and Governor–State friction.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Public Service Commissions, Arts. 315–323); Governor's and President's powers; Governance: transparency and accountability in recruitment
Background primer
State Public Service Commission (Kerala PSC) and Article 317
- What it is:
- a body created by the Constitution of India. Its provisions are in Chapter II of Part XIV. The Kerala PSC is vested with recruitment to State Government posts, PSUs and all Universities.
- Founded:
- constitutional PSCs come from Art. 315. The Kerala PSC's own founding date is not confirmed from a trusted source.
- Members:
- 1650 employees and a Commission comprising the Chairman and 20 Members. The Governor appoints the Chairman and members, and about half the members must have at least ten years' government service. Term is six years or till age 62, whichever is earlier, and re-appointment to the same body is barred.
- Mandate:
- conduct recruitment examinations and selections, and advise the Government on disciplinary matters of civil servants and on promotions through DPCs.
Additional context
- A gubernatorial reshuffle appointed Keralam Governor Rajendra Vishwanath Arlekar as Governor of Tamil Nadu, with Om Prakash Mathur moving from Sikkim to Keralam. This explains why Mr. Arlekar is described as the "former" Governor.
- Precedent on Art. 317: a 2025 Supreme Court advisory-jurisdiction judgment (Ref. u/A 317(1) No. 1 of 2023) concerned a member of the Arunachal Pradesh PSC. The reference came from the President under Art. 317(1) over allegations of misbehaviour. One question was whether a failure to ensure integrity in the AE mains examination could count as misbehaviour. The route there was: the State sought the reference, the Governor requested it, and the President made it (the Governor was asked to place the matter before the President).
- Outcome of that reference: the Supreme Court, on 28 August 2025, exonerated the Arunachal Pradesh PSC member of "misbehaviour" over the 2022 AE (Civil) Mains paper leak. It found nothing on record to show her individual involvement.
- "Misbehaviour" is not defined in the Constitution.
Mains dimensions
- Constitutional route is narrow and judicial: The BJP asks the President to act on a former Governor's recommendation. Art. 317 allows removal for misbehaviour only after a Supreme Court inquiry, so the real constitutional step is a presidential reference, not direct removal. In the 2025 Arunachal reference the Supreme Court held that removal is in personam: it must rest on a specific member's own conduct, not on the failings of the Commission as a whole. This matters for a demand to remove the Chairman "and its members" together.
- Role of the Governor: The Governor appoints members and can suspend only after a reference. A Governor's report or recommendation can start the process. It cannot end it. This points to the wider Governor–State government friction in opposition-ruled States.
- Criminal law versus constitutional process: Police FIRs naming the Chairman, members and officials run in parallel with, but do not replace, the Art. 317 route. Whether an FIR alone amounts to "misbehaviour" is for the Supreme Court to judge. The independence of the Commission also constrains State police action against it.
- Credibility of recruitment: Alleged irregularities in specific exams (Fisheries Extension Officer, Assistant Motor Vehicle Inspector) and months-long protests by rank holders erode faith in the merit principle. The Kerala PSC is a very large recruiter. It conducts recruitment for State posts, PSUs and universities.
- Politicisation: The BJP, Congress and CPI(M) trade accusations over youth jobs, SFI influence and SIR. The competing narratives show how a technical recruitment problem becomes a partisan issue. The allegations are partisan claims and have not been tested.
- Way forward: Transparent and timely results and appointments, an independent probe, a public statement of any Art. 317 reference, clear rules for what counts as "misbehaviour", technology-based safeguards in exams (the Kerala PSC has itself held a summit on blockchain and AI in recruitment), and protection of the Commission from both capture and arbitrary removal.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Constitution gives State Public Service Commissions a protected tenure and a judicial removal process. Discuss how these safeguards balance independence and accountability, with reference to recent controversies over recruitment irregularities."
Related topics
- Articles 315–323 (PSC provisions: appointment, term, functions under Art. 320, bar on further employment)
- Removal procedures compared: Art. 124(4) for Supreme Court judges (and, by extension, the CEC and CAG), and Art. 317 for PSC members
- Governor's discretionary powers and Governor–State government relations (Art. 163, 200)
- Reforms for transparency and merit in recruitment, and paper-leak/exam fraud laws
- Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls (ongoing issue mentioned in the BJP's remarks)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 6 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs