BrainParrot

Cess levied on sales tax falls within State’s ambit, says SC

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 5 November 2026

Summary

  • A seven-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court held that an additional tax a State legislature levies on the sale or purchase of goods does not fall outside the State's legislative competence.
  • It confirmed the 1975 ruling in S. Kodar v. State of Kerala. That ruling said a cess levied as an increment to an existing sales tax is judged in the same way as the principal tax.
  • The lead opinion is by CJI Surya Kant. Justice K.V. Viswanathan wrote a concurring but separate opinion. The petitions date back to 1994.

UPSC relevance: GS2 Polity (federalism, Seventh Schedule) / GS3 Economy (fiscal federalism)

Key facts for Prelims

  • Entry 54, List II (State List): taxes on sale or purchase of goods. Before GST this excluded newspapers (per the article).
  • Seventh Schedule: Article 246 (Union List, State List, Concurrent List).
  • Precedent confirmed: S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1975). A surcharge or additional tax computed as a percentage of sales tax is an enhancement of the sales tax rate and falls within Entry 54, List II.
  • Bench strength: seven judges (a Constitution Bench). Lead opinion by CJI Surya Kant, with Justice K.V. Viswanathan concurring separately.
  • Post-2016, Article 246A (GST) and the narrowed Entry 54 (101st Amendment) apply.

Data and details

  • The petitions date from 1994, so the dispute took over 30 years to resolve.
  • The 1975 precedent S. Kodar "continues to hold the field" and "squarely holds" that an additional tax or surcharge computed as a percentage of sales tax payable is an enhancement of the sales tax rate.
  • Assessees' argument: a levy measured by the quantum of tax already payable is a "tax on tax". It does not fall on the "sale" or "purchase of goods", which alone is the subject of Entry 54.
  • States' argument: the surcharge is merely an enhancement of the rate for a class of dealers. The mode of computation does not alter its character as a tax on sale of goods.
  • The question referred was a State Legislature's competence to levy tax on sale or purchase of goods under Entry 54 of List II, on sales tax payable by a dealer rather than directly on turnover.

Static–dynamic linkage

The Seventh Schedule distributes legislative subjects among the Union, State and Concurrent Lists. Entry 54 of the State List (List II) is the State's power to tax sale or purchase of goods. The legal question was whether an extra levy computed as a percentage of sales tax payable is a "tax on tax", which would fall outside Entry 54. Or is it simply a higher rate of the same sales tax, which would be within Entry 54? The Court preferred the second view. The legal character of a levy is decided by what it substantively is (a tax on sale or purchase), not by how it is computed. The reasoning is consistent with the substance-over-form approach used to test legislative competence.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Union–State legislative relations, Seventh Schedule, Article 246; GS3 – Economy: fiscal federalism and State taxation powers.

Background primer

Legislative competence over taxation: Seventh Schedule, Article 246 and Entry 54, List II

What it is:
Under Article 246(3), the Legislature of any State has exclusive power to make laws for the State on matters in List II (the State List).
Why it matters:
A clear division of fiscal powers. The Centre taxed manufacture of goods while the States taxed sale of goods.

Additional context

  • Entry 54 has since been narrowed. The article says Entry 54 "as it then stood" governed the 1975 case. After the 101st Amendment, Entry 54 now covers only taxes on the sale of petroleum crude, high speed diesel, petrol, natural gas, aviation turbine fuel and alcoholic liquor for human consumption, excluding inter-State and international trade sales.
  • The same amendment inserted Article 246A, giving Parliament and State Legislatures power to make laws on GST.
  • Related federal-tax ruling: In India Cement, a seven-judge Bench held royalty to be a tax, so States had no competence to impose a cess on royalty under Entries 23 and 50 of List II. The later MADA decision laid down principles for interpreting Entry 54 of List I and Entries 23 and 50 of List II, and overruled India Cement. That decision is dated 25 July 2024.

Mains dimensions

  • Fiscal federalism: The ruling protects State revenue-raising flexibility. States can top up an existing sales tax with a percentage-based levy without needing a separate legislative entry.
  • Judicial stability vs. change: The Court reaffirmed a 1975 precedent through a seven-judge Bench. It prefers certainty in the law over re-opening settled doctrine. Disputes lasting since 1994 show the cost of delay for assessees and States.
  • Substance over form: Competence is tested by the nature of the levy (a tax on sale) and not by the formula used to compute it.
  • Revenue implications: The 1994-era petitions show that surcharge-type levies by States were contested for decades. The ruling settles the competence question in the States' favour, with the exact fiscal impact depending on the pending cases.
  • Link to GST era: Entry 54 is now narrow after the 101st Amendment. Under the current Entry 54, the practical relevance is likely to be mainly for legacy (pre-GST) disputes and for the goods the entry still covers, such as petroleum and alcohol.
  • Way forward: Clear demarcation of taxing entries, quicker resolution of constitutional tax disputes and a cooperative approach via the GST Council.

Possible Mains question

**GS2/GS3, 15 marks:** "Judicial interpretation of the Seventh Schedule has shaped fiscal federalism in India. Discuss with reference to recent Supreme Court rulings on States' power to levy taxes."

Related topics

  • Article 246, 246A, 265 and the Seventh Schedule
  • Doctrine of pith and substance; doctrine of precedent and Constitution Benches
  • GST, the 101st Amendment and the GST Council
  • Mineral area taxation (MADA, 2024) and royalty vs. tax

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 5 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs