BrainParrot

Jantar Mantar is a road, not a protest site: Delhi Police to SC

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 4 November 2026

Summary

  • In an affidavit, Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar told the Supreme Court that Jantar Mantar is a public road, not a protest "site". He said no one can insist on a fundamental right to protest at a particular place, and the State can shift venues.
  • This responds to Swaty Singh's petition against the recent de-notification of Jantar Mantar as a protest site.
  • Separately, a Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant heard Delhi traders (Kirana Committee Delhi) who say protests are "bleeding" them during the festive season. The Court said both the livelihood of vendors and the right to protest must be balanced. It noted a "protest economy" benefits hawkers, issued notice, and refused interim relief without hearing the organisers.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Fundamental rights (Art. 19), right to protest vs public order

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 19(1)(a) (speech and expression), 19(1)(b) (assemble peaceably without arms), 19(1)(c) (associations/unions). Restrictions are under Art. 19(2) (speech) and 19(3) (assembly).
  • Right to protest is derived from Article 19, not a separately enumerated right.
  • Key cases: Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. UoI (2018), on Jantar Mantar and Boat Club; Himat Lal K. Shah (1973), on regulation vs prohibition; Amit Sahni (2020), the Shaheen Bagh case, on indefinite occupation of public roads.
  • Ramlila Grounds is the designated protest site after Jantar Mantar (per the article).
  • Section 163 BNSS is the order-making provision for restricting assemblies (the successor to Section 144 CrPC).

Data and details

  • Jantar Mantar sees nearly 1,300 protests a year.
  • The 20 July NEET-UG protest turnout far exceeded capacity, creating a constant fear of a stampede.
  • 1–17 August: 250 distress calls; 109 theft FIRs; 10 motor-vehicle-theft FIRs; over 250 property-loss claims; 23 FIRs for public-order violations, rioting and defacement.
  • The area hosts 78 foreign embassies/missions, 99 Central government offices, 1.46 lakh daily footfall and 7,017 private residences.
  • Police say identifying it as a protest site was "contrary to public interest since the inception". Emergency services are hampered and general security compromised. The proximity of the new Parliament premises adds to the need to regulate.
  • The Commissioner's argument is that dissent must be balanced against others' livelihood and free movement.
  • The Jantar Mantar protests were linked to the NEET-UG paper leak and the anti-Chief Election Commissioner protests.
  • The Bench was headed by CJI Surya Kant; Justice Bagchi also made observations.
  • Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi (for traders) said "thousands of crores" were lost, that nobody can do business in Connaught Place, and that thousands of auxiliary workers are without jobs in the festive season. He noted Ramlila Grounds is only about a mile from CP, and sought a two-month protest ban over the festive season.
  • Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said protesters linked to the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) over the NEET-UG leak had sought one day's permission on 20 June but refused to leave. He said organisers of protests/bandhs should bear responsibility for losses.
  • CJI: everyone has a right to protest but must follow permission conditions; a protest site cannot be occupied indefinitely, as other protesters also need space.
  • Justice Bagchi called it a "mela economy", noting vendors supply food and water to protesters. He asked whether organisers had been made parties; traders said they had not.
  • Senior advocate N. Hariharan (for CPI(M) State secretary M.A. Baby) asked whether authorities were having second thoughts about designating Ramlila Grounds.
  • The Court issued notice but passed no interim order without hearing the protest organisers.
  • (The two articles give different dates for the NEET-UG protest, 20 July in the police affidavit and 20 June in the SG's submission.)

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Peaceful assembly and speech are fundamental rights, but not absolute. Article 19(2) (speech) and Article 19(3) (assembly) allow reasonable restrictions, e.g. in the interest of public order and the sovereignty and integrity of India.
  • Courts have rejected both extremes. The State may regulate assemblies (time, place, manner) but cannot ban them everywhere.
  • The legal question in this case is whether there is a right to protest at a particular, State-designated place. Equally, can a long-used designated site be withdrawn by the executive without a reasoned, proportionate basis?

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental rights (Art. 19(1)(a), 19(1)(b), reasonable restrictions); judiciary; GS2 – Governance (police/public order); Prelims Polity.

Background primer

Right to protest (Article 19)

What it is:
not a standalone, separately enumerated fundamental right. It is derived from Article 19. The textual anchors are Article 19(1)(a) speech and expression, 19(1)(b) peaceful assembly without arms, and 19(1)(c) association/unions.
Why it matters:
protest works as a democratic feedback and watchdog mechanism, letting citizens express dissent between elections.

Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India (2018), the Jantar Mantar precedent

Additional context

  • Amit Sahni v. Commissioner of Police (2020), the Shaheen Bagh case, upheld the right to peaceful protest against a law. It also held that public ways and spaces cannot be occupied indefinitely.
  • Himat Lal K. Shah v. Commissioner of Police (1973) recognised the right to hold public meetings under Art. 19(1)(a) and (b). The State may regulate gatherings but cannot arbitrarily prohibit them everywhere.

Mains dimensions

  • Place as part of the right: The Commissioner argues no one can insist on a protest at a particular place. Counter: the 2018 MKSS ruling treated Jantar Mantar as a place long used and earmarked, and asked for regulation rather than exclusion. Police say designation "since the inception" was wrong. This effectively reopens the 2018 balance.
  • Public order evidence: The affidavit's data are mostly crime and crowd metrics (FIRs for theft, distress calls). Whether these show causation by protests or just a busy central-Delhi zone is open to challenge. A proportionality test requires a link between the restriction and the harm, and a less restrictive alternative (caps, time slots) before closure.
  • Competing rights: Article 19(1)(a)/(b) against Article 19(1)(g)/Article 21 (trade, livelihood, mobility). The Court's "protest economy" remark signals that protests also create livelihoods, a nuance against blanket festive-season bans. Interest-group framing matters (traders vs protesters vs residents).
  • Natural justice: The Court declined interim relief without hearing organisers, reflecting audi alteram partem.
  • Security and symbolic geography: Proximity to Parliament, 78 embassies and 99 central offices explains the State's interest, but cutting access to the seat of power for dissent raises democratic concerns. Ramlila Grounds is about a mile from Connaught Place, per the traders' counsel.
  • Way forward: Transparent, rule-based slot allocation; capacity limits; organiser accountability (SG's point); published guidelines of the kind the 2018 judgment mandated; an independent review of de-notification.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The right to protest is a fundamental right, yet the State may regulate its time, place and manner. In light of the recent de-notification of Jantar Mantar as a protest site, examine how courts have balanced the right to dissent with public order and the rights of others."

Related topics

  • Article 19 restrictions; Article 21 (livelihood, mobility); reasonable restriction and proportionality doctrine
  • Section 163 BNSS; unlawful assembly under BNS; Section 144 CrPC (legacy)
  • Judicial notice/interim orders and hearing affected parties (principles of natural justice)
  • Cross-reference: NEET-UG paper-leak and anti-CEC protests

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 4 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs