INDIA bloc adopts ‘motion to impeach’ CEC
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 1 November 2026
Summary
- On Saturday the INDIA bloc held a symbolic "public impeachment" of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar in the garden of Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge's residence in New Delhi. Kharge moved the "motion". The setting was modelled on the Lok Sabha, with former Speaker Meira Kumar presiding. The "motion" was adopted unanimously by a show of hands.
- It has no constitutional force. The Opposition said it held the event because every institutional route was closed to it. Its charges centre on the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, alleged voter deletions and alleged collusion with the Government.
- The BJP called it a mockery of democratic institutions. Congress called the BJP's "Loktantra Bachao, Arajakta Hatao" campaign hypocrisy. Related developments the same day: Bengal's Opposition questioned 16.10 lakh appeals against voter inclusion, and the Uttar Pradesh CEO deactivated ECINET logins of ERO computer assistants after the Pilibhit complaint.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324(5): CEC removable only like a Supreme Court judge (Art. 124(4) route); grounds are proved misbehaviour or incapacity.
- Removal needs a motion by both Houses with a majority of total membership and two-thirds of those present and voting. Initiation needs 100 LS or 50 RS members, followed by a three-member inquiry under the Judges (Inquiry) Act framework.
- Other ECs: removal only on the CEC's recommendation.
- CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023: replaced the 1991 Act; selection committee of PM, LoP (LS) and a Union Cabinet Minister; six years or age 65; protection from legal proceedings under Section 16.
- Representation of the People Act, 1950, Section 21(3): special revision of rolls. Art. 326: adult suffrage and elector eligibility.
- Form 6 is for inclusion of new electors; Form 8 is for correction of entries. Each Assembly constituency has an Electoral Registration Officer (ERO). Section 24 of the RP Act, 1950 provides a two-tier appeal: first to the DM, second to the CEO.
- Supreme Court, 27 May 2026: ECI has power to conduct SIR under Art. 324 read with RP Act 1950; it cannot finally decide citizenship.
- N. Seshan (1995): upheld the multi-member Election Commission.
- No CEC has ever been removed by the constitutional procedure.
Data and details
- The "motion": six charges. These include conspiring with the BJP to steal elections, disenfranchising 13.2 crore voters through SIR exercises, and acting at the behest of PM Modi and HM Amit Shah. Kharge listed these specifics: deleting names, changing Form 6 without parliamentary oversight, centralising rolls through ERONET/ECINET, excluding the other two Election Commissioners from decisions, and acting at the PM's and HM's behest.
- Rahul Gandhi said 13.3 crore votes were deleted (figure as reported; the charge sheet figure is 13.2 crore), about 15% of the electorate. He said the 2024 Lok Sabha margin between the Opposition and the winning side was only three percentage points. He said Kumar should be removed and tried for treason. He warned officials working under the CEC that legal protection would not last and called them "first target".
- Kharge said 193 Opposition MPs gave notices in both Houses seeking removal seven months ago, and the proposals were rejected. He said the aim was to restore trust in the ECI, that there is "no personal enmity", and that the lifelong-immunity law should be repealed.
- TMC's Mahua Moitra claimed 71% of those deleted in Bengal were Muslims and 51% were women. Sagarika Ghose alleged the 2026 West Bengal election was "stolen".
- CPI(M)'s John Brittas attended two hearings personally to prove his eligibility. He said SIR hollows out universal adult franchise. CPI's P. Sandosh Kumar said "the government is selecting the voters". Kapil Sibal called Kumar a "pawn on a chess board" and argued that manipulating rolls electronically amounts to treason under criminal laws.
- Voter testimonies: Anita Jaiswal (Kolkata to Delhi) voted in every election 2012–2025 but was asked to prove citizenship and told to get an Aadhaar card as proof. Iftikar Ahmed (Chowrangee) voted 20 years and got a notice over a "mapping discrepancy". Kanta Prasad was declared dead in the exercise. Shashi Tharoor called the deprivation of the vote "a crime against the Constitution".
- Notable absence: RTI activist Anjali Bharadwaj said the ECI replied that no file recording the decision-making process behind SIR exists. She claimed a Principal Secretary (T. C. Kom) said the ECI had not taken any decision to conduct SIR. AISA's Neha Bora said software was overriding statutory authority.
- BJP rebuttal (Sambit Patra): if the Opposition's 38 lakh BLAs worked properly there would be no need for a "mock Parliament". He said not one vote was stolen and that SIR was conducted 10 times during Congress rule. His account of the 13 crore: about 12 crore permanently shifted, about 6 crore of them already filled Form 6, notices went to the rest, about 2.8 crore deaths, and nearly 1 crore duplicates. He said only a declaration was added to Form 6 and the 27 May 2026 Supreme Court judgment settled it. He said the ECI clarified SIR decisions were unanimous. He said the 2023 law only laid down procedure for existing constitutional protection. He cited a Telangana lower-court order of July 2023 to register a case against the CEC, set aside by the High Court.
- Sudhanshu Trivedi cited the World Bank's 2025 report: extreme poverty fell from 27.6% to 2.6% between 2011 and 2023 (tangential to the debate).
- Bengal: 16.10 lakh appeals were filed against voter inclusion after SIR. CPI(M)'s Mohammad Salim called it a "ghostly affair". Former special observer Subrata Gupta reportedly said he had "no information" about the CEO's office filing lakhs of appeals against voters cleared by judicial officers; AITC says he is now advisor to CM Suvendu Adhikari.
- Uttar Pradesh: The CEO (Navdeep Rinwa) ordered immediate deactivation of ECINET logins of all computer assistants in ERO offices. This followed the Pilibhit complaint, where the Opposition alleged details of 13,150 voters in Pilibhit Sadar were altered although EPIC and serial numbers stayed the same. In 347-Azamgarh, 13 entries named "Vikas Yadav" appeared. On 25 October the CEO had ordered re-verification of all entries made by computer assistants since the final roll was published on 10 April after SIR. The outsourced operator in 127-Pilibhit is to be terminated. There are about 806 operators, two per Assembly constituency. KND Engineers and Consultants (India) Pvt Ltd (Gorakhpur) holds the outsourcing; operators are drawn from the same government-portal list, most for 8–10 years.
- Counter-campaign: BJP president Nitin Nabin leads a padyatra in Rohtak on 1 November under "Loktantra Bachao, Arajakta Hatao". Haryana Congress in-charge Sanjay Dutt called it hypocrisy.
- Wider mobilisation: CPI(ML) Liberation's Dipankar Bhattacharya said the protests would be integrated with farmers' and workers' issues. He cited the proposed India–US trade deal and the Labour Codes. All INDIA constituents will join a rally at Ram Lila grounds on Sunday.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Art. 324 gives the Election Commission of India (ECI) superintendence, direction and control of elections. Art. 326 sets the eligibility for being an elector: citizen, 18 years of age, ordinarily resident, not disqualified.
- The CEC has security of tenure under Art. 324(5). The CEC can be removed only "in like manner and on like grounds" as a Supreme Court judge, i.e. via Art. 124(4). The grounds are proved misbehaviour or incapacity, and Parliament must adopt a motion by a special majority. A rally-based "impeachment" is therefore only political symbolism. The only legal route is a parliamentary motion.
- The Opposition's grievance is also a rolls-integrity question. SIR shifts the burden of proof onto the elector, and the ECI's own decision-making is contested.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission, Art. 324); Representation of the People Acts; electoral reforms | GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability of institutions
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI) and the CEC
- What it is:
- a permanent, independent constitutional body, established on 25 January 1950 under Art. 324, with superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Why it matters:
- The Constituent Assembly intended an independent Election Commission whose appointment is regulated by law and not decided by the Executive.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- a large-scale, labour-intensive revision in which Booth Level Officers visit each household to verify identity and eligibility of every registered voter. BLOs flag Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate (ASDD) entries.
Additional context
- On 27 May 2026 a bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi upheld the legality of the ECI's SIR in Bihar. The Court said the ECI may examine citizenship for electoral purposes but cannot make final determinations of citizenship, which lie with competent authorities under the Citizenship Act. It directed referral of non-citizenship deletions from the 2003 rolls to a competent authority within four weeks, and restoration of the name if the person is found to be a citizen.
- In its affidavit before the Supreme Court, the ECI said all three SIR orders issued across 2025 and 2026 were unanimous decisions of the full Commission. It said no change was made to the statutory Form 6. The SIR declaration is a separate document and not part of Form 6. Citing Art. 324(5), it said any prayer to restrain the CEC from functioning was not maintainable. A bench headed by CJI Surya Kant was scheduled to hear petitions against CEC Gyanesh Kumar and the Commission's SIR decisions.
- A Delhi High Court judgment of 14 October 2026 (Nilotpal Datta v. ECI) held that previously enrolled electors' apprehension of making a false declaration while submitting Form 6 was misplaced.
Mains dimensions
- Institutional independence: Security of tenure for the CEC alone, removal of ECs only via the CEC, and an appointment panel with a ruling-party majority give rise to autonomy concerns. Autonomy concerns arise because two of the three members of the 2023 Act's selection committee come from the executive (the PM and a Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM). In Anoop Baranwal (2023) the Supreme Court had set an interim panel of the PM, the LoP and the CJI, and the 2023 Act replaced the CJI with a Union Cabinet Minister. Reform pointers include a collegium including the CJI and an independent ECI secretariat. In Anoop Baranwal the Supreme Court declined, by judicial fiat, to extend to the ECs the CEC's protection against removal.
- Process transparency: the RTI reply that no decision file exists, and the allegation that the two other Commissioners were excluded, sit against the ECI's affidavit claim of unanimity. This tests the Commission's accountability to citizens.
- SIR: inclusion vs integrity: The burden shifts to the elector (notices, document hearings, "mapping discrepancy"). The Supreme Court limited the ECI's citizenship role. Bengal's 16.10 lakh appeals, and the dispute over who authorised them, show how the appellate stage can itself become contested.
- Technology and data integrity: Pilibhit and Azamgarh show insider-misuse risk on a centralised platform (ECINET) with outsourced operators. The UP CEO's re-verification and login deactivation is a corrective, but it also underlines the Opposition's centralisation charge.
- Democratic discourse: a mock parliament outside Parliament, and a rival BJP campaign, signal the migration of institutional disputes to the street. The Opposition argues Parliament's removal route was shut (rejected notices). The BJP argues Parliament is disrupted by the Opposition.
- Rule of law and immunity: Clause 16 immunity vs accountability, and the BJP's point that constitutional protection already existed.
- Way forward: transparent decision records, independent audit of deletions, outsourcing safeguards, equal removal protection for ECs, and a quick judicial resolution of the pending petitions.
Possible Mains question
**GS Paper II, 15 marks:** "The independence and credibility of the Election Commission are central to free and fair elections. In the light of the recent controversy over the Special Intensive Revision and the demand for the CEC's removal, examine the adequacy of constitutional safeguards for the Commission and suggest reforms."
Related topics
- Art. 324 and plenary powers of the ECI (Mohinder Singh Gill, 1978); Art. 124(4) and the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968
- Representation of the People Acts, 1950 and 1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960; Citizenship Act and the limits of the ECI on citizenship
- Electoral reforms: ECI secretariat, selection committee, Model Code of Conduct
- ECINET (see the UP CEO action above) and digital governance in elections; RTI Act
- Cross-reference: takedowns during the anti-CEC protests (see the note on social media takedowns, 071)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 1 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs