Jailhouse rock, the ‘others’ in the dock
Source: The Hindu, 31 October 2026
Summary
- Dr. Randall Sequeira and Dalit activist Laxman Naik were arrested on 16 October in Odisha's Kalahandi district. The arrests were linked to an April clash in Rayagada. Neither was among the 26 villagers named in the FIR. They were picked from a category of 100 unnamed "others" in the FIR.
- Activists say this is a pattern: criminal cases and the unnamed "others" category are used against villagers and activists resisting bauxite mining in the Niyamgiri/Eastern Ghats region. The police say adding "others" is common procedure in rioting cases and relies on later identification.
- The region is seeing a rush of bauxite projects (NALCO, Aditya Birla, OMC, Vedanta, Adani), and villagers, including Dongria Kondh women, marched on 26 October against the arrests and mining plans.
Key facts for Prelims
- Dongria Kondh: PVTG of Niyamgiri hills, Odisha; deity Niyam Raja. India has 75 PVTGs, 13 in Odisha.
- Niyamgiri judgment: 18 April 2013 (Supreme Court); Gram Sabha consent; FRA, 2006.
- FRA, 2006 recognises forest rights of STs and other traditional forest dwellers. PESA, 1996 extends Panchayat provisions to Scheduled Areas (Fifth Schedule).
- BNSS, 2023: S.173 (FIR), S.175 (investigation); BNS Section 109(1) (attempt to murder), 191(2) (rioting).
- NALCO: Navratna CPSE under the Ministry of Mines. OMC: Odisha Mining Corporation, State-owned.
- Bauxite = raw material for aluminium. Eastern Ghats districts Kalahandi, Rayagada, Koraput hold much of India's bauxite (per Indian Minerals Yearbook 2023).
- Goldman Environmental Prize: awarded to Prafulla Samantara in 2017 (per article).
- PUDR = People's Union for Democratic Rights (New Delhi civil liberties group).
- The District Collector's 2025 order barring 25 people from entering Rayagada for two months was struck down by the High Court.
Data and details
- Arrest: Dr. Randall Sequeira (39) and Laxman Naik (31, Dalit activist) arrested around 11 p.m. on 16 October at a rented house in Hilltown, Bhawanipatna (Kalahandi HQ). The police linked the arrests to a clash 192 days earlier (the early hours of 7 April, when Kantamal villagers near the Sijimali bauxite deposit resisted police entry).
- FIR No. 85/2026 (Kashipur police station, Rayagada): 26 villagers named; 100 unnamed "others" from Kantamal town. Five complaints were registered on the day of the clash (three by police personnel, two by magistrates).
- Sequeira: booked under BNS 109(1) and 191(2); learnt of the charges only after a medical examination, when handed the arrest memo. Orissa High Court had already granted him anticipatory bail for the same incident under FIR No. 87/2026. Police say he is named in eight cases. He was also among 25 people barred in 2025 from entering Rayagada for two months; the High Court struck the order down.
- Naik: his name appears in two other FIRs he knows of; police say 16 cases are against him.
- Sequeira's background: MBBS (St. John's Medical College, Bengaluru), postgraduate in internal medicine (Sawai Man Singh Medical College, Jaipur). He worked with the Tribal Health Initiative in rural Tamil Nadu, then in Jharkhand and Odisha. His observations suggested that residents near operational mines had more skin ailments than those in non-mining areas. He was visited by his parents in Rayagada jail on 26 October.
- Police version (Rayagada SP Raj Prasad): "others" is a common procedure in rioting cases because the complainant cannot identify all accused at once. Faces are recognised later from CCTV or eyewitness statements. FIRs are based on villagers' complaints, and police "go by the rule book".
- Activist version: Biswapriya Kanungo describes a "climate of intimidation" and the legal system as a tool to intimidate, prolong ordeal and silence dissent. Sharanya Nayak says police have "weaponised" authority. Prafulla Samantara asks whether this is not a "police state".
- PUDR figures: 43 cases in three years on resistance to bauxite mining in Kalahandi and Rayagada, with over 100 Adivasis and Dalits sent to jail. Between 8 March and 8 April, up to 24 were arrested and jailed, 217 named as accused and 1,140 listed as "others". Few cases have ended in conviction, and most trials have not begun.
- Lingaraj Azad (62, adviser, Niyamgiri Suraksha Samiti): jailed since 25 March; eight cases registered; his name is absent in five of the eight FIRs (arrested as one of the "others"). He has secured bail in seven of the eight. Accusations include attempted murder, rioting and robbery. His son, Allaram Christ Kumar, says police book him in another case each time bail is granted.
- Ladda Sikaka (president, Niyamgiri Suraksha Samiti): 11 cases; bail applications filed in seven; his lawyer Narendra Mohanty says records could not be found in the record room. On 11 September, after getting bail in two old cases, he was intercepted and dragged out of a vehicle with no arrest memo shown. Lawyers have asked police and court for a list of all cases against him.
- Naring Dei Majhi (35, Sagabari, near the proposed Sijimali mine): taken from the Rayagada District Headquarters Hospital on 2 August 2025 as her daughter-in-law was about to give birth; six FIRs; released after six months. Nayak notes that of 40+ cases against resisters in three years, only one complaint by Naring (an anti-mining voice) was registered, and the police had not begun an investigation 18 months later.
- Bauxite geography: per the Indian Minerals Yearbook 2023, Kalahandi, Rayagada and Koraput hold 51% of India's bauxite reserves and produce 74.64% of India's bauxite. More than 95% of Odisha's bauxite resources are in the East Coast region. There are 44 deposits, with a majority within a 100-km stretch across Kalahandi, Rayagada, Koraput and Malkangiri.
- Projects (reserves in million tonnes): NALCO — Panchpatmali 310 (Koraput, mining for decades), Pottangi 111 (preparing). Aditya Birla Group — Baphlimali 196.98 (Rayagada; alumina refinery), Maliparbat 15.06 (Koraput; not yet started). OMC — Kodingamali 77.5 (Rayagada/Koraput). Vedanta — Sijimali 311 (environmental clearance received; Rayagada/Kalahandi), Karlapat 248 (preferred bidder). Adani Group — Kutrumali 127.737 (public hearing for environmental clearance not yet held), Balada 22.13 (Koraput).
- Background to the protests: resistance dates to 2003, when OMC signed an agreement with UK-based Vedanta Resources. The Niyamgiri Suraksha Samiti has worked for two decades.
- August 2026: a delegation of retired civil servants and police officers met CM Mohan Charan Majhi to ask him to hold back mining, citing cumulative ecological and social impacts.
- 26 October: hundreds of villagers, including Dongria Kondh women, marched from Munikhol panchayat to the Muniguda tehsil office. Kartik Majhi (Khandualmali Surakshya Samiti) said gram sabhas of 112 villages under Supreme Court supervision had rejected mining 13 years ago, and that fresh attempts were now being made.
- Samantara said that he and Medha Patkar were forcibly sent back from Rayagada because the administration did not want villagers made aware of what was at stake.
Static–dynamic linkage
Two static strands meet here. First, personal liberty and criminal process: how an FIR is registered (Section 173, BNSS), who can be added as an accused later, and what safeguards apply at arrest (grounds of arrest, arrest memo, bail). Second, tribal rights over land and forests: the Niyamgiri precedent made Gram Sabha consent central to diverting forest land for mining. The article alleges that criminal procedure is being used to weaken the second through the first.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental rights (Art. 21, 22), criminal procedure and police accountability; Fifth Schedule, PESA 1996, FRA 2006 (tribal rights); GS3 – Environment/Economy: mining vs. conservation, EIA, public hearing; GS2 – Social Justice: vulnerable sections (PVTGs).
Background primer
FIR and the "unnamed accused" practice (BNSS, 2023)
- What it is:
- the First Information Report records information about a cognizable offence. Registration of FIR is dealt with in Section 173 BNSS and investigation in Section 175 BNSS.
Niyamgiri, Dongria Kondh, Forest Rights Act and PESA
Additional context
- The Xaxa Committee stressed that the State must monitor so that Gram Sabha consent is obtained freely. It also said cases of forged Gram Sabha consent must face penalties.
- It further noted that officials meant to prevent tribal land loss were increasingly seen as negotiators for project authorities, and that this must stop.
Mains dimensions
- Misuse of criminal process: the "others" category lets police add accused later. Between 8 March and 8 April, 1,140 people were listed as "others" against 217 named, according to the PUDR. Azad's name does not appear in five of his eight FIRs; the repeated booking after bail (seven of eight bails secured) suggests the process itself is the punishment. This engages Art. 21 and 22 and the need for judicial oversight at remand.
- Selective registration: only one complaint by a mining opponent was registered out of 40+ cases and none was investigated in 18 months, which Nayak says shows bias by complainant's position. Missing case records (Sikaka) and an arrest without an arrest memo (D.K. Basu safeguards) add to this concern.
- Police version: the SP says the practice is standard in riot cases and based on CCTV and eyewitnesses, and the clash itself involved allegations of attempt to murder. The balance is between maintaining order and protecting dissent.
- Tribal rights and consent: Niyamgiri made Gram Sabha consent central (FRA, PESA, Fifth Schedule). Fresh mining plans in the same Eastern Ghats region raise the question of whether consent is being sought or bypassed. The Xaxa Committee's warnings about consent and official neutrality are relevant.
- Development vs. ecology: the region has 51% of India's bauxite reserves and produces 74.64% of its bauxite. The pace of projects (NALCO, OMC, Vedanta, Adani, Aditya Birla) raises concerns of cumulative impacts raised by retired civil servants and police officers. Sequeira's observation of skin ailments near mines links to health impacts.
- Chilling effect and rule of law: the 2025 externment-style order against 25 people (struck down by the High Court) and the denial of entry to activists suggest a pattern of administrative restriction of speech and movement (Art. 19).
- Way forward: guidelines on adding "others" (specific evidence at the time of arrest, time-limited identification), mandatory arrest memos and case lists, independent inquiry into the cases, strict compliance with Gram Sabha consent, cumulative impact assessment before new mines, and fair hearing for both sides.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Examine how the use of an unnamed 'others' category in FIRs can affect personal liberty, with reference to the recent arrests of anti-mining activists in Odisha. How can the Niyamgiri principle of Gram Sabha consent be protected in such contexts?"
Related topics
- BNSS Section 173, Lalita Kumari (2013), bail and anticipatory bail; D.K. Basu (1997)
- Art. 19, 21, 22; chilling effect and the rights of protesters
- Fifth Schedule, PESA 1996, FRA 2006; PVTGs; Xaxa Committee
- EIA Notification, 2006 and public hearings; mining regulation
- FPIC and indigenous rights in international law
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 31 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs