ECI’s appeals against 16.10 lakh cleared voters raise legal questions
Source: The Hindu, 31 October 2026
Summary
- In West Bengal's SIR, roughly 16.10 lakh electors had been cleared by judicial officers after being flagged for "logical discrepancies". They were back under challenge because appeals against their inclusion were filed before the Appellate Tribunals.
- The question is whether the officers who filed these appeals had any authority under the Representation of the People (RP) Act, 1950. The Act names only the CEO/DEO/ERO/AERO as authorities for electoral rolls.
- The ECI's 26 October affidavit in the Supreme Court did not clearly say that the appeals were filed by those authorised officials. Opposition parties want the appeals scrapped and a judicial probe.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of electoral rolls and elections in the ECI. Art. 326 is the basis of adult suffrage (citizen, 18+, not disqualified).
- RP Act, 1950 deals with electoral rolls. Section 21 covers preparation and revision, including special revision. Section 24 covers appeals.
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: the second appeal under S.24(b) lies to the CEO in the manner prescribed under Rule 27.
- Authorities "with respect to electoral rolls" named in the Act (per the article): CEO, DEO, ERO, AERO.
- SIR phases: Phase I Bihar; Phase II 9 States + 3 UTs (incl. UP and West Bengal).
- The Supreme Court upheld the ECI's power to conduct SIR within its statutory mandate.
Data and details
- Appeals filed against inclusion: 16.10 lakh electors ("a little over 16 lakh"), all previously cleared by judicial officers after being flagged for logical discrepancies.
- These electors would have voted in the April Assembly polls because they were on the supplementary lists published before the elections.
- Supreme Court affidavit: filed 26 October 2026. It said the appeals were not brought to the ECI's notice earlier. It also said a communication dated 22 October 2026 from the CEO West Bengal's office stated that its officials filed the appeals as authorities under the Act. It further said the officers "had the authority" under the Supreme Court's orders.
- Notably absent: the affidavit acknowledged only CEO/DEOs/EROs/AEROs as authorities under the Act, but did not say categorically that the appeals were filed by them. It described them only as "officers of the office of CEO West Bengal".
- Two Election Commissioners, S. S. Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, raised the question of appeals against inclusions in their file notings.
- Congress leader Prasenjit Bose (a petitioner in the West Bengal SIR case) argues that these officers have no authority under the Act. His reasoning is that the Tribunals were created by the Supreme Court in April 2026 and the Act says nothing about any tribunal.
- On Thursday, Congress submitted a memorandum to the CEO West Bengal. It demanded cancellation of the appeals as violating the Act, and an IT audit to disclose the date, time and process of filing them.
- Scale: about 60 lakh "doubtful and pending" cases went to roughly 700 judicial officers (drawn from a Calcutta High Court list sent at the Supreme Court's direction). They cleared and restored 32,77,360 voters and rejected 27.23 lakh. Of the rejected, 22 lakh appealed to the Tribunals.
- Timeline: Supreme Court directed a separate appellate body on 10 March; ECI constituted the Tribunals on 21 March; they began functioning around 13 April. On 16 April the Supreme Court ordered successful appellants to be added through a supplementary list. Assembly elections began 23 April, and reportedly only 136 names had been cleared by then.
Static–dynamic linkage
The Constitution gives the ECI "superintendence, direction and control" of electoral rolls (Art. 324). The detailed machinery for preparing rolls, claims, objections and appeals is statutory. It sits in the RP Act, 1950 and the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. Only authorities the statute recognises can act in each role. A body created by court directions, such as the Appellate Tribunals, sits awkwardly with a statute that provides a different appeal ladder. This is a classic "authority vs. competence" question: can an executive body act through persons or fora the statute doesn't name, even if a court order contemplated those fora?
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional/statutory bodies (ECI); Representation of the People Act, 1950 (electoral rolls); separation of powers and judicial supervision of electoral processes; dispute redressal mechanisms.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- the constitutional body that superintends, directs and controls the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections to Parliament, State legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President (Art. 324).
- Founded:
- 25 January 1950, along with the Republic (stable textbook fact).
- Members:
- Chief Election Commissioner plus Election Commissioners, appointed by the President. Appointment and service conditions are now governed by the 2023 Act. In the article, ECs S. S. Sandhu and Vivek Joshi are the two Commissioners who raised the questions in file notings.
- Mandate:
- preparing and revising electoral rolls, conducting free and fair elections, and registering/regulating political parties (RP Act, 1951).
- Why it matters:
- an independent, insulated electoral umpire.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) and the roll-machinery hierarchy
- What it is:
- an intensified revision to include all eligible citizens, exclude ineligible voters and make additions and deletions transparent.
West Bengal Appellate Tribunals (SIR)
- What it is:
- bodies set up during the Supreme Court's supervision of the West Bengal SIR so that people could challenge decisions of judicial officers. The article says the Supreme Court directed a separate appellate body on 10 March and the ECI constituted the Tribunals on 21 March.
Additional context
- In the final West Bengal roll published on 28 February, about 60 lakh names were marked "under adjudication".
- The Supreme Court ordered deployment of judicial officers to adjudicate claims and objections of people in the "logical discrepancy" list. It also allowed the ECI to publish a draft list by 28 February and issue supplementary lists later.
- The Tribunals were spread across 23 districts.
Mains dimensions
- Statutory competence vs. court-created machinery: the RP Act names CEO/DEO/ERO/AERO. The Tribunals arose from the Supreme Court's supervision of the SIR, and the Act is silent on tribunals. Officers appealing before them therefore raise a question about the source of their authority. The ECI's affidavit leans on "orders of this Hon'ble Court" rather than on the Act.
- Transparency and accountability of the ECI: the appeals surfaced only after a CEO-office communication on 22 October. The ECI said it was unaware earlier, and its own two Election Commissioners had flagged the issue in file notings. This points to weak internal control and to a possible lack of collegial decision-making.
- Electoral integrity vs. voter enfranchisement: the voters were cleared by judicial officers and appeared on supplementary lists before the polls. Appealing against the inclusion of voters already cleared by judicial officers and placed on supplementary lists raises questions of finality, legitimate expectation and the risk of disenfranchisement.
- Judiciary–executive interface: courts supervising a constitutional body's statutory function (judicial officers whose orders are "deemed orders of court", tribunals headed by retired judges). This helps in a hard situation but leaves hybrid legal status.
- Opposition demands: scrapping of appeals, a judicial probe and an IT audit of filing time and process. These point to a trust deficit in the SIR process.
- Way forward: clarify through a court order or statutory amendment who may appeal before the SIR Tribunals; publish a time-stamped appeal register; ensure appeals are filed only by notified authorities; keep a due-process safeguard for those already on supplementary lists.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has put the Election Commission's statutory powers, and the role of courts in supervising it, under scrutiny. Examine with reference to the recent controversy over appeals against voters cleared in West Bengal."
Related topics
- Art. 324–329 (election machinery; bar on court interference in electoral matters)
- RP Act, 1950 vs RP Act, 1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
- Appointment of CEC/ECs and the 2023 Act; independence of the ECI
- Tribunals in India (Arts. 323A/B) and judicial review
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 31 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs