BrainParrot

Will ‘examine everything’ in SIR case: SC

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 October 2026

Summary

  • The Supreme Court (Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant) said it will "examine everything" on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. Petitioners led by LoP Rahul Gandhi had asked that the ECI preserve, or file in court, the "complete records and decisions" on the revision. The case is listed for mid-November.
  • The ECI's affidavit calls the SIR lawful, says the orders were unanimous among all three Commissioners, and says a CEC can be removed only by the procedure used for a Supreme Court judge. Congress calls the affidavit "deceitful and duplicitous".
  • The Opposition has taken the issue to the streets: an INDIA bloc "public impeachment" of CEC Gyanesh Kumar, a CPI human chain, and a 1 November rally. State-level final rolls are also out, e.g. Karnataka.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Election Commission, electoral rolls, Article 324, federal/judicial oversight

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art. 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections vested in the ECI.
  • Art. 326: universal adult suffrage for citizens aged 18 and above, unless disqualified by law.
  • Art. 327: Parliament's power to legislate on elections (including rolls), subject to the Constitution.
  • Section 16 of the RP Act, 1950 excludes non-citizens; Section 19 covers citizens aged 18+ who are ordinarily resident in the constituency.
  • Section 21 of the RP Act, 1950 deals with preparation and revision of electoral rolls.
  • Under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, Form 6 is the claim for inclusion as a new elector; Form 7 is for objection to inclusion or deletion of a name.
  • A false statement or declaration in these forms is punishable under Section 31 of the RP Act, 1950.
  • Mohinder Singh Gill v. CEC (1977): ECI has broad Art. 324 powers; judicial review during elections is restricted by Art. 329(b).
  • Art. 324(5): CEC removed like a Supreme Court judge (grounds: proved misbehaviour or incapacity; Art. 124(4) mirror).
  • CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 now governs appointment, tenure and removal.

Data and details

  • Counsel and parties:
  • Senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi, with advocate S. Prasanna, appeared for Rahul Gandhi.
  • Senior advocate Vikas Singh appeared for lead petitioner Rakesh Kumar Singh, with Shailendra Mani Tripathi among others. He sought time to reply to the ECI affidavit filed Monday.
  • Senior advocate Menaka Guruswamy appeared for TMC leader Dola Sen. The Court issued notice on her petition against the ECI's functioning and "tampering" of Form 6.
  • Senior advocate Maninder Singh appeared for the ECI, and Solicitor-General Tushar Mehta for the Union.
  • Singhvi called the demand "innocuous, non-invasive" (file the records or direct their preservation). He said the affidavit itself speaks of decisions, consultations and whether decisions were unanimous.
  • Guruswamy said the ECI press note claimed the Bihar SIR judgment authorised "tampering" of Form 6. She also said the ECI affidavit "accepts many of the charges".
  • ECI affidavit:
  • CEC Gyanesh Kumar and ECs Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi spoke in one voice that SIR decisions were lawful and that any attempt to restrain the CEC's functioning was illegal.
  • It denied that Form 6 was changed. The additional declaration form is not "part" of the statutory form.
  • Deleted voters must file Form 6 and "map" their earlier roll entries to those of parents and grandparents in the additional declaration.
  • West Bengal CEO officials filed appeals against inclusion of deleted voters. Petitioners say these number over 16 lakh and are choking the Appellate Tribunals.
  • The ECI's counsel called the Sen petition's submissions "rhetoric meant for some other purpose". The SG said the Court should not become a political forum.
  • The court gave the ECI liberty to file a supplementary affidavit.
  • The legal challenge began with street protests for the CEC's removal and grew into multiple petitions, from ordinary citizens and activists to Opposition leaders.
  • Media reports before the protests alleged friction within the ECI: both ECs complained of procedural irregularities and the CEC's unilateral, authoritarian conduct.
  • SIR has excluded approximately 13 crore voters (005); the editorial says more than 13 crore names have been removed since June 2025.
  • Kharge listed alleged irregularities in 12 States and 1 UT and used the "vote chori" slogan.
  • Jairam Ramesh called the ECI's 248-page counter-affidavit "deceptive, deceitful and duplicitous". The ECI wants the petitions dismissed and says all three members approved the orders.
  • Form 6 allegation: the ECI earlier said the new declaration had been upheld by the Supreme Court but now says it is separate and Form 6 is unamended. Ramesh says the declaration was made mandatory for online submission, violating the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.
  • Ramesh also alleges that ECINET centralised control over rolls and overrode EROs, who are statutory authorities.
  • INDIA bloc "public impeachment" of the CEC planned for 30 October by 21 parties, as a curtain-raiser to the 1 November rally.
  • Congress says the govt-run Ashok Hotel withdrew permission after police intervention, and the Ramlila Maidan venue (booked 25 Oct–3 Nov) was also blocked.
  • Delhi Police (DCP Central Rohit Rajbir Singh) says no request was received for a mock impeachment.
  • Permission was sought and granted, with conditions, only for the 1 November rally at Ramlila Maidan, 10 a.m.–5 p.m. It is a no-objection on law and order, subject to the land-owning authority's permission. Conditions cover CCTV, security, water and toilets, traffic and crowd control, and it must end by 5 p.m.
  • K.C. Venugopal threatened a dharna at the PM's and Home Minister's residences.
  • CPI (D. Raja): human chain from Ajoy Bhavan to ITO demanding the CEC's resignation and rollback of SIR. It also criticised the denotification of Jantar Mantar as a protest site.
  • 99.32 lakh names struck off. The final roll has 4,55,00,011 electors (including 44,322 service electors), down from 5,54,32,314.
  • The draft roll was 4.46 crore, with more than 1.07 crore deleted. The final roll has a net addition of 8.19 lakh over the draft.
  • The CEO's figures do not show how many wrongly excluded voters returned, nor give a separate count of young or first-time voters.
  • Claims and objections closed on 23 September. Later Form 6 applicants go into quarterly supplementary lists.
  • Population-to-elector ratio is 66.11, against an ideal range of 60–70 (CEO V. Anbu Kumar). Projected population is 6.87 crore (NCP/MoHFW Projections 2011–2036) against 4.54 crore general electors. The roughly 2.33 crore gap was not explained.
  • Final roll breakdown: more than 2.25 crore men, 2.29 crore women, 2,841 third-gender voters, 6.83 lakh aged 18–19, 3.92 lakh aged above 85. The largest age group is 30–39 (1,02,57,680), then 40–49 (94,17,853).
  • Form 6 (16 June–23 September): over 7.87 lakh received, 76,231 rejected, 3,193 pending, 7.08 lakh accepted. More than 1 lakh post-deadline applications were also processed.
  • Till 26 October: 10.62 lakh Form 6 received, 83,806 rejected. DEOs are told to contact rejected applicants and include them if eligible.
  • 31.26 lakh of 33.14 lakh notices (94.34%) disposed, with names parked for inclusion in the final list due 4 December. Notices must be disposed by 30 November.
  • More than a quarter of removals were claimed dead or duplicate; most of the rest were absent or shifted.
  • Bela Estate booth, Delhi: 728 of 729 voters cut over address-proof discrepancies.
  • The SIR replaced the 1995 "presumption of legality" with data-matching. 2002-era rolls were hastily digitised from Bengali, Kannada and other languages, auto-transliterated into English, then matched to new forms. A second layer of "logical discrepancies" followed (e.g. parent–child age gap under 15 years).
  • Examples of false flags: twins (age gap under nine months); Oraon surname Xalxo rendered as Khalkho; "Md." versus "Mohammed".
  • According to the Internet Freedom Foundation, the rules flagged 17% of West Bengal's and 41% of Madhya Pradesh's electors.
  • West Bengal: 91% of exclusion appeals decided by tribunals were reversed, but the voters had already lost the 2026 Assembly election.
  • The ECI has never disclosed the acceptable error margin or the data. Two of the three Election Commissioners are on record objecting to centralisation of the database and curbs on local officers' authority.
  • Goa: officers heard 97 flagged voters and found all eligible, but could not restore them because the software had no reversal option.
  • Delhi: each booth-level officer received about 200 notices on a tight deadline.
  • West Bengal: a June State order marked ration cards of SIR-removed voters inactive; the SC has since restored access to food.
  • In January the CEC offered ECINet to other countries. In August US President Trump cited India's photo-ID rules to push stricter US voter laws.
  • Proposed reforms: disclose matching rules and error rates, an independent audit, and no striking-off until an officer with time and authority verifies the real person.
  • Core argument: a dead voter left on the roll is a clerical error; a living voter struck off loses a constitutional right.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Source of power. Article 324 vests the superintendence, direction and control of elections in the Election Commission. The Supreme Court read Section 21(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 together with Article 324 when upholding the Bihar SIR.
  • Limit on that power. Article 324 is plenary, but the Court has said this does not place the Commission above statutory law. Article 327 lets Parliament legislate on elections, subject to the Constitution.
  • Independence safeguard. The CEC's removal protection under Article 324(5) is why the ECI affidavit and the "impeach the CEC" campaign collide. See Primer 2a.
  • Bridge. The dispute tests three static ideas together:
    • Universal adult suffrage (Art. 326) versus roll "purification".
    • The burden of proof for citizenship and residence.
    • How far an independent constitutional body must disclose reasons and records to courts and citizens.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission); Representation of the People Act; electoral reforms; judiciary–executive/independent-body relations. Also GS2 — Governance: transparency and accountability; GS3 — S&T applications in governance (software-driven roll cleaning).

Background primer

Election Commission of India (ECI)

What it is:
the constitutional body that supervises, directs and controls the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President (Art. 324).
Founded:
established under Art. 324 (25 January 1950). It briefly became multi-member in 1989, reverted to a single-member body in 1990, and the multi-member structure was restored permanently in 1993.
Members:
CEC plus Election Commissioners. They are appointed on the recommendation of a three-member committee of the Prime Minister, the Lok Sabha Leader of the Opposition and a Union Cabinet Minister. Tenure is six years or until age 65, whichever is earlier.
Mandate:
preparing and revising rolls, conducting elections, and the Model Code of Conduct. Electoral Registration Officers (EROs) are the statutory authorities who decide individual roll entries.
Why it matters:
an impartial referee for democracy, insulated from the executive through secure tenure and judge-like removal protection for the CEC.

Special Intensive Revision (SIR)

What it is:
door-to-door verification of electoral rolls through house-to-house enumeration.

Removal of the CEC (Art. 324(5))

Additional context

  • Bihar judgment.
    • The Bihar exercise covered about 7.9 crore registered voters and ended with a final roll of 7.42 crore electors.
    • The Court held the ECI can check citizenship for the limited purpose of the roll, and a deletion does not amount to declaring someone a non-citizen.
    • It directed the ECI to refer those deleted on non-citizenship grounds to a competent authority under the Citizenship Act within four weeks, with restoration if found to be citizens.
    • It noted that safeguards added during hearings, notably accepting Aadhaar, helped make the process constitutionally compliant.
  • Form 6 declaration litigation. The ECI has cited a Delhi High Court judgment in Nilotpal Datta v. ECI (14 October 2026), which held that previously enrolled electors' fear of making a false declaration on Form 6 was misplaced. The ECI clarified that no action under Section 31 of the RP Act, 1950 will be initiated by an ERO merely because an elector was on a previous roll and filed Form 6 during or after the SIR.
  • 1995 ruling. In 1995 the Supreme Court ruled that proof of citizenship could be demanded only when credible evidence suggested someone was not a citizen. The editorial invokes the 1995 presumption in favour of names already on the roll.

Mains dimensions

  • Institutional independence vs accountability. The ECI's united affidavit and its stand that the CEC enjoys judge-like removal protection sit alongside media reports of dissent by both ECs. The Court's willingness to "examine everything", including the ask to preserve records, tests how far a constitutional body must disclose its decision-making. Art. 324(5) protects the CEC alone; other ECs depend on the CEC's recommendation, which is a structural asymmetry.
  • Type I vs Type II error. The editorial's framing is that wrongly retaining a dead voter costs little while wrongly deleting a living one costs a fundamental political right. Evidence: 91% reversal of West Bengal tribunal appeals, 97 of 97 Goa voters found eligible but not restorable, 17% and 41% flag rates, and 728 of 729 voters cut at one Delhi booth.
  • Automation and due process. The ECI says software only assists officers, but the Delhi case of about 200 notices per BLO shows the queue turns the machine's verdict into the State's. This links to algorithmic accountability, the right to a reasoned order, and the way an error in one register (ration card) cascades into another. The article's point is that India's "inclusion at scale" digital public infrastructure can exclude at scale.
  • Opaque numbers. Karnataka's CEO gives the net addition (8.19 lakh) but not the number of wrongly excluded voters restored or first-time voters added, and leaves the 2.33 crore population-electorate gap unexplained. This is a transparency deficit.
  • Federal and administrative layer. ECINET is alleged to centralise control and override EROs, who are statutory authorities. West Bengal CEO appeals (16 lakh+) are alleged to choke Appellate Tribunals. The 2026 West Bengal Assembly election has already passed.
  • Form 6 and the statutory framework. The row is whether an "additional declaration" attached to Form 6 is a rule change (the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 prescribe the form) or an administrative annexure. This ties into the Art. 324 limit: plenary but not above statute.
  • Right to protest and political process. Alleged denial of venues for the "public impeachment", police saying no request was made, Jantar Mantar's denotification, and the Solicitor-General's remark that the Court should not become a "political forum". Art. 19(1)(a)/(b) and reasonable restrictions.
  • Global spillover. ECINet offered abroad and India's ID rules cited in the US debate. The standard India accepts for electoral error becomes an international benchmark.
  • Way forward.
  • Publish matching rules and error rates, and commission an independent audit.
  • Build reversibility and human verification into the software.
  • Disclose restorations and net additions by category.
  • Keep removal and tenure protections intact.
  • Let the Court's record-preservation order settle the factual dispute.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has revived the debate on the powers of the Election Commission under Article 324 and the safeguards for citizens' right to vote. Critically examine, with reference to judicial pronouncements and recent controversies."

Related topics

  • Art. 324–329 and Part XV; RP Acts 1950 and 1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
  • Removal of constitutional functionaries (Art. 124(4), Art. 317, Art. 324(5)); Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968
  • Right to vote: constitutional vs fundamental vs statutory (PUCL 2003, Kuldip Nayar 2006)
  • Right to protest (Art. 19) and Jantar Mantar restrictions
  • Aadhaar–voter ID linkage and electoral roll purification (NERPAP, 2015); algorithmic governance and digital public infrastructure
  • Cross-reference: the Delhi High Court Form 6 declaration ruling in the 2b section

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs