BrainParrot

Pinarayi to seek Assembly discussion on Arlekar’s move to remove PSC members

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 October 2026

Summary

  • Pinarayi Vijayan, Leader of the Opposition in the Keralam Assembly, says the Opposition will demand an Assembly discussion on former Governor Rajendra Vishwanath Arlekar's "unilateral" recommendation to remove the chairperson and members of the Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC). The Front Page teaser (013) carries the same demand.
  • Separately, the State told the High Court that the probe into alleged irregularities in the Planning Board exam conducted by the KPSC is progressing "vigorously".

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Public Service Commissions (Arts. 315–323), Governor's role, Centre–State relations

Key facts for Prelims

  • Arts. 315–323 (Part XIV, Chapter II): Public Service Commissions.
  • Art. 315: PSCs for the Union and for the States. Art. 316: appointment and term of members. Art. 317: removal and suspension. Art. 320: functions. Art. 318: Governor/President regulate conditions of service.
  • State PSC chairman/members are appointed by the Governor but removed only by the President.
  • Misbehaviour removal requires a Supreme Court inquiry under the Art. 145 procedure.
  • The Governor can suspend a State PSC member only after a reference to the Supreme Court.
  • Grounds for removal without SC inquiry: insolvency, outside paid employment, infirmity of mind or body.
  • SPSC member's term: six years or age 62, whichever is earlier.
  • Comparison: Art. 324(5) (CEC), Art. 124(4) (SC judges) and Art. 148 (CAG) use the judge-removal model, while PSC members use the Supreme Court inquiry model.

Data and details

  • Pinarayi Vijayan (CPI(M), Leader of the Opposition in the Keralam Assembly) says:
  • The Opposition will demand an Assembly discussion on former Governor R.V. Arlekar's "unilateral" recommendation.
  • Reports claim the recommendation to the President was made for the first time in the State's history.
  • The Governor allegedly exercised excessive powers before the State's probe into the PSC's functioning was complete; the ongoing Crime Branch probe has so far found no lapses by the chairperson or members.
  • He urged the State government not to accept the action and cautioned against supporting "legal violations" allegedly being done by the BJP-led Centre through Governors.
  • High Court (Justice A. Badharudeen):
  • The State said the investigation into alleged irregularities in the KPSC's Planning Board exam is "vigorously" progressing.
  • The de facto complainant V.S. Jayalal was given time to file objections.
  • The court was told the commission had suspended two persons over the alleged irregularities.
  • The State asked how the commission could seek to quash the FIR if it was taking action on the allegations.
  • The KPSC had approached the court to quash the government's sanction to prosecute its employees and the FIR.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Static concept. A State PSC member is appointed by the Governor, but the Constitution gives the Governor no power to remove. Removal is strictly regulated by Art. 317 to protect the PSC's independence.
    • Although SPSC chairmen and members are appointed by the Governor, they can be removed only by the President.
    • For misbehaviour, removal is by order of the President after the Supreme Court, on a reference by the President, has inquired under Art. 145 procedure and reported that removal is warranted.
  • Bridge. In the news, the Governor made a recommendation to the President. The constitutional route for misbehaviour passes through a Presidential reference to the Supreme Court. The article does not describe the exact legal route used, and the Opposition says the recommendation pre-empted the State probe. Federal tension arises because the State's own Crime Branch inquiry has found no lapses so far (Vijayan's claim).

Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional bodies (UPSC/SPSCs), Governor's powers and discretion, Centre–State relations, accountability of constitutional office-holders.

Background primer

Public Service Commissions (Part XIV, Chapter II)

What it is:
constitutional bodies for merit-based recruitment: UPSC for the Union and an SPSC for each State.
Founded:
provisions on composition, appointment, removal and functions are in Part XIV, Articles 315 to 323.

Removal under Art. 317

Additional context

  • A recent Supreme Court Art. 317 reference (2025).
    • In Ref. u/A 317(1) No. 1 of 2023, in re Mepung Tadar Bage, Member, Arunachal Pradesh PSC (2025 INSC 1047), the Court dealt with a President's reference.
    • The reference arose from a 2022 question-paper leak in an Assistant Engineer (Civil) Mains exam; the Governor sought a reference to the Supreme Court on 2 December 2022, and the member was suspended by the Governor under Art. 317(2) after the reference was made.
    • Art. 317(1) references are heard under Order XLIII of the Supreme Court Rules.
    • On 28 August 2025 the Court found no evidence linking the member to the leak, held that misbehaviour was not proved, and recommended that her suspension be revoked.
    • The Court said PSC members can be removed only by complying with Art. 317, not through a regular departmental inquiry.
  • Constituent Assembly intent. The Court's reading of the Assembly debates is that the framers wanted PSC autonomy and so prescribed an elaborate removal procedure.
  • Earlier references. Special Reference No. 1 of 1983, reported at (1983) 4 SCC 258, was the first occasion the Court dealt with an Art. 317(1) reference. It concerned a Punjab PSC member alleged to have slapped the Chairperson.
  • Whether the recommendation in Kerala has been sent as a formal Art. 317 reference is not confirmed from the search results.

Mains dimensions

  • Independence of constitutional bodies. Art. 317 deliberately denies both the State government and the Governor the power to remove PSC members. The route is the President after a Supreme Court inquiry. A recommendation pre-empting an unfinished State probe, if it bypasses that path, raises questions of constitutional propriety.
  • Role of the Governor. Governors have appointing and (limited) suspension powers but act under the Constitution. Here Vijayan alleges that the BJP-led Centre is committing "legal violations" through Governors, and he urges the State government not to accept the action.
  • Two tracks. The Governor's recommendation (a constitutional-removal track), the Crime Branch probe and the High Court's examination of the FIR and prosecution sanction (a criminal-law track) run in parallel. Misbehaviour needs a finding by the Supreme Court. The criminal case alone does not remove members.
  • Recruitment integrity. Alleged irregularities in the Planning Board exam strike at merit-based recruitment, a core PSC mandate. The suspension of two persons indicates internal action.
  • Legislative accountability. The demand for an Assembly discussion shows the federal and legislative route to scrutinise Governor actions.
  • Way forward.
  • Follow the Art. 317 reference route (President → Supreme Court inquiry → President's order).
  • Complete the investigation first.
  • Codify what counts as "misbehaviour".
  • Strengthen internal vigilance in exam conduct.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Public Service Commissions are meant to be insulated from political and executive pressure. Examine the constitutional safeguards for the removal of their members and the role of the Governor in this regard."

Related topics

  • Arts. 315–323; UPSC vs SPSC composition; Art. 320 functions
  • Art. 124(4), Art. 148, Art. 324(5) removal models
  • Governor's powers (Arts. 153–167, 200–201) and Centre–State relations; Sarkaria and Punchhi Commissions
  • Recruitment reforms and exam-leak legislation (Public Examinations Act, 2024)
  • Related note: the removal-of-CEC primer in the SIR note (005)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs