Fouled waters
Source: The Hindu, 28 October 2026
Summary
- The Supreme Court has again pulled up Rajasthan over industrial effluents flowing into the Jojari river. The editorial describes the problem as decades old and treats the State's lapse as bordering on systematic.
- The Court has acted through a suo motu writ petition, an oversight committee, and bans on construction and hazardous industry near the river. It has also flagged possible collusion between officials and industrial interests, and hinted at State liability under the "polluter pays" principle.
- The editorial endorses the Court's stance but warns against a recent tendency of the Court to substitute itself for regulators instead of disciplining them.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 21: right to life includes the right to a healthy environment. Related: Article 48A (DPSP: protect environment) and Article 51A(g) (fundamental duty).
- Polluter pays and precautionary principle: recognised in Vellore Citizens Welfare Forum (1996); both are part of Indian environmental law.
- Public trust doctrine: M.C. Mehta v. Kamal Nath (1997). Absolute liability: M.C. Mehta (Oleum Gas Leak, 1987).
- National Green Tribunal: established under the NGT Act, 2010; Principal Bench in New Delhi; handles environmental disputes.
- CETP: Common Effluent Treatment Plant, which treats effluent from clusters of small units. STP: Sewage Treatment Plant. ZLD: Zero Liquid Discharge.
- Jojari: seasonal tributary of the Luni, flowing through Jodhpur. Luni rises in the Aravallis near Ajmer and ends in the Rann of Kutch.
- Suo motu cognisance: the Supreme Court acting on its own on a matter of public importance.
- RIICO: Rajasthan State Industrial Development and Investment Corporation.
Data and details
- PIL in the Rajasthan High Court in 2011 first alerted State machinery. The editorial calls the problem decades old.
- The three seasonal rivers (Jojari, Luni, Bandi) flow through Jodhpur, Balotra and Pali districts. The region is a textile-dyeing and steelworking hub, and illegal sand mining in riverbeds is rampant.
- About 20 lakh residents' health is at risk from untreated or insufficiently treated industrial effluents.
- State submissions to the Court in 2025: STPs in the three urban centres accommodate only about half the sewage generated. The Court also recorded substantial underutilisation at CETPs. The editorial reads this as pointing to industrial sources bypassing treatment facilities, poor connections between sources and plants, and/or insufficient capacity at particular sites or times.
- Suo motu writ petition initiated in 2025. The High-level Ecosystem Oversight Committee is chaired by Justice Sangeet Lodha.
- Bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta: construction banned within 100 m of river edges; hazardous industries banned within 500 m of the present path, or of flood lines where available.
- The Court cited its own stay of a 2022 NGT order (compensation on RIICO and the local administration in Jodhpur and Barmer) to show local authorities' enforcement failure.
- Officials knew of illegal mining in some areas yet regularised leases there. The Court treats possible collusion between State officials and "industrial mafias" seriously.
- Justice Mehta observed the State could be liable under the polluter pays principle, a significant indictment of failure through negligence.
Static–dynamic linkage
The constitutional hook is Article 21. The Supreme Court has read the right to life as including a right to a healthy environment. Two doctrines apply:
- Polluter pays: the polluter bears the cost of remedying environmental harm.
- Precautionary principle: act to prevent harm before scientific certainty is complete.
Statutory regulators (State Pollution Control Boards, industrial development bodies) are meant to enforce effluent norms. When they fail, courts and the National Green Tribunal step in. The editorial's concern is the balance between judicial correction of failed regulation and judicial takeover of regulatory functions.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: conservation, pollution and degradation; environmental governance. GS2 – Polity: judiciary (suo motu jurisdiction, judicial review), accountability of regulatory institutions.
Background primer
Polluter pays principle
- What it is:
- Those who cause environmental damage must bear the cost of restoring it.
- Why it matters:
- Pollution is an externality, and costs should not be passed to the public or the State.
Jojari–Bandi–Luni river system (Rajasthan)
- What it is:
- Three seasonal rivers in arid western Rajasthan.
Suo motu jurisdiction and the High-level Ecosystem Oversight Committee
Additional context
- Committee's tasks: Oversee implementation of the National Green Tribunal's final order of 25 February 2022 and the Justice P.C. Tatia Committee recommendations. It must also prepare a scientifically grounded, time-bound River Restoration and Rejuvenation Blueprint for the Jojari, Luni and Bandi system.
- NGT history: The Jojari pollution had been the subject of numerous High Court writ petitions and an application before the NGT's Principal Bench in New Delhi (Application No. 329 of 2015). The Supreme Court's order of 21 November 2025 modified its interim stay on the NGT's final order of 25 February 2022, so the stay no longer restrains the NGT's substantive remedial and regulatory directions. The stay continues only for the remarks against RIICO and other authorities and the ₹2 crore environmental compensation imposed on them.
- Infrastructure findings: Jodhpur's estimated sewage generation was about 230 MLD. The Court's 2025 order recorded existing treatment capacity of 120 MLD, and its later 2026 order recorded about 175 MLD, leaving a gap of about 55 MLD. 312 textile units and 81 steel units are connected to CETPs, largely within RIICO industrial areas. The absence of Zero Liquid Discharge systems and continued discharge of treated effluent into the RIICO drain, which joins the Jojari, were flagged as serious concerns.
- Later orders: On 7 August 2026 the Court directed Rajasthan to constitute an Integrated Coordination Group led by the Chief Secretary within seven days, and to set up an independent River Commission or River Rejuvenation Authority. The ICG is an internal government arrangement and does not override the Oversight Committee. The interim 100-metre construction ban and the 500-metre ban on hazardous industry stay in force while the High Flood Line and ecological buffer zones are scientifically demarcated.
- Relocation of industry: In its August 2026 order, the Court stated that authorities should consider relocating industries away from the river in the long term.
Mains dimensions
- Regulatory failure and collusion: Treatment plants are under-used while effluent goes untreated, and leases were regularised despite known illegal mining. This points to institutional capture and weak enforcement by regulators and industrial development bodies.
- Judicial role: The Court's interventions (suo motu cognisance, committee, buffer-zone bans) fill a governance vacuum. The editorial warns against courts substituting for regulators. The better course is to make regulators perform: clear accountability, timelines and monitoring, as the Court's Integrated Coordination Group and River Authority directions try to do.
- State liability under polluter pays: Extending liability to the State recognises that regulatory negligence is a form of environmental failure.
- Livelihood vs environment: The textile and steel clusters support jobs and exports. Remedies such as ZLD, CETP upgrades, relocation and buffer zones must balance livelihoods with the health of about 20 lakh residents.
- Ecological and technical gaps: Seasonal rivers in arid regions have little dilution capacity, so even treated effluent is harmful. Illegal sand mining adds to ecological stress.
- Way forward: Mandatory ZLD in dyeing clusters, real-time monitoring, strict action on bypassing, independent river authority, transparent leasing for mining and community participation.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "The Supreme Court's intervention in the Jojari river pollution case highlights both the importance and the limits of judicial activism in environmental governance. Discuss, with reference to the 'polluter pays' principle and regulatory accountability."
Related topics
- National Green Tribunal (NGT Act, 2010) and its powers
- Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974; Environment (Protection) Act, 1986
- Public interest litigation and judicial overreach debate
- Namami Gange and river rejuvenation models
- Illegal sand mining and the mining lease framework
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 28 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs