BrainParrot

BJP has no bad option, Congress has no good option

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 24 October 2026

Summary

  • The editorial examines the options before the BJP and the Congress on delimitation, the redistribution of Lok Sabha seats among States. The Centre has not disclosed the precise proposals it plans to legislate.
  • On 16 Oct 2026, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge wrote to the PM, for the fourth time since April, seeking an all-party meeting before proposals are finalised. On 19 Oct, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju replied that the Government had sought the Congress's cooperation repeatedly and had consulted other Opposition parties. The author reads the reply as showing the Centre will bring legislation without disclosing details.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Parliament, constitutional amendments, federalism, delimitation, women's reservation

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art. 81: composition of Lok Sabha (max 550: 530 States + 20 UTs); Art. 82: readjustment after each Census; Art. 170: State Assemblies; Art. 80: Rajya Sabha max 250 members; Art. 368: amendment procedure.
  • 42nd Amendment (1976) froze seats on the 1971 Census; 84th (2001) extended the freeze until the first Census after 2026; 87th (2003) used 2001 Census for boundaries; 106th (2023) women's reservation.
  • Present Lok Sabha strength is 543, below the Art. 81 ceiling of 550. Delimitation Commission: statutory, chaired by a retired SC judge.
  • The third delimitation (1973) followed the 1971 Census. The fourth (2002) redrew boundaries but left inter-State seat shares unchanged.
  • Majority concepts: simple majority is 50% plus one of those present and voting. A special majority is a majority of total membership plus two-thirds of those present and voting.

Data and details

  • Kharge's 16 Oct 2026 letter to PM Modi was his fourth since April seeking an all-party meeting on delimitation proposals before they are finalised and introduced in Parliament.
  • Rijiju's 19 Oct reply: letters to Kharge in March and April, discussions with Kharge and LoP (Lok Sabha) Rahul Gandhi, and consultations with several other Opposition parties. It did not disclose precise proposals.
  • April 2026: the Government said it would keep each State's current proportion in an enlarged Lok Sabha of up to 850 seats, which raises the cap by more than 50%.
  • Subsequent Bills required allocation on the 2011 Census; the contradiction unravelled and the Bills failed.
  • Congress's counter-proposal: stay at 543 seats and the present distribution. This also needs a constitutional amendment, which the author calls "dead on arrival".
  • As it stands, the Constitution requires reallocation among States on the 2027 Census. Without an amendment, the 550 seats possible under present provisions can be reallocated, to the heartland States' advantage.
  • DMK would support delimitation that keeps current proportions regardless of total size, but wants clarity on how it will be legislated.
  • Possible BJP calculations the author lists: avoid marginalising peninsular India for national legitimacy; implement women's quota by adding 50% more seats without displacing sitting male members; alleged scope for gerrymandering before the next general election; and room for caste-based representation in its social engineering.
  • Author's conclusion: the BJP has two good options (an amendment gives it extra seats; failure shifts more seats to its strongholds), and the Congress two bad ones (larger House at unchanged shares through an amendment the BJP has not drafted; or same-size House reallocated on the latest Census, sharply cutting Keralam and Tamil Nadu).

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Art. 82 sets out readjustment of Lok Sabha seat allocation and the division of each State into territorial constituencies after every census, with Parliament deciding the procedure through Delimitation Acts that guide the Delimitation Commission. A readjustment takes effect only when the existing Lok Sabha is dissolved. Art. 170 provides the same for State Assemblies.
  • Art. 81(1) caps the Lok Sabha at 530 members from States plus 20 from UTs, and Art. 81(2) requires seats to be proportionate to each State's population "as far as practicable".
  • The editorial's "real debate" is this: how much should the House expand, and how should seats be shared among States? Any change to the cap or the allocation rule needs a constitutional amendment under Art. 368, which requires a special majority (majority of total membership and two-thirds of those present and voting). Changes to the representation of States in Parliament also need ratification by half the State legislatures (textbook provision).

Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Parliament (structure, constitutional amendment procedure); federal balance; Delimitation Commission; women's reservation (106th Amendment); Art. 81/82/170.

Background primer

Delimitation and the Delimitation Commission

What it is:
the process of redrawing electoral constituencies to ensure equal representation based on population.
Mandate:
allocate seats to States and carve constituencies of roughly equal population.
Why it matters:
"one person, one vote, one value" balanced against federal fairness for States that stabilised their population.

Women's reservation (106th Amendment, Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam)

What it is:
the 106th Amendment (2023) provides one-third reservation for women in the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies, linked to delimitation based on the census after 2026.
Mandate:
gender representation. The editorial argues the quota is settled and will apply whenever the next delimitation happens, irrespective of total seats.

Additional context

  • The Bills that failed (PRS, Drishti, Vision IAS): the Constitution (131st Amendment) Bill, 2026, introduced on 16 April 2026, proposed raising the Lok Sabha ceiling from 550 (530 States + 20 UTs) to 850 (815 + 35). It was negatived in the Lok Sabha on 17 April 2026, getting 298 votes against the 352 needed for a special majority. The companion Delimitation Bill, 2026 and the UT Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2026 then became infructuous. The Delimitation Bill required the latest published Census, which implied the 2011 Census. This matches the editorial's account of Bills requiring a 2011 Census-based allocation.
  • Why proportions matter (PRS): the Bill sought to revert to the principle of each State having seats in proportion to its population. PRS illustrates that, if the Lok Sabha kept its current strength and seats were allocated on the 2011 Census, Tamil Nadu would fall from 39 to 32 and Kerala from 20 to 15. Uttar Pradesh would rise from 80 to 89, Bihar from 40 to 46 and Rajasthan from 25 to 30. PRS adds that the change in relative shares would persist even if total seats increased. This is the contradiction the editorial highlights between the April promise of unchanged proportions and the Bills' 2011 Census basis.
  • Impact on Rajya Sabha ratio (PRS): if Lok Sabha seats rose by 50% (543 to 815), the Lok Sabha:Rajya Sabha ratio would move from 2.2:1 to 3.3:1. This would reduce Rajya Sabha's relative share in electing the President and Vice-President and increase Lok Sabha's power in a joint sitting.
  • Representation gap (Insights on India): an MP in Kerala represents about 14 lakh electors, against about 19 lakh in Uttar Pradesh or Bihar.
  • Tamil Nadu's position (ForumIAS): retain 543 seats, the existing State-wise distribution and the 2.2:1 ratio, and implement women's reservation from 2029 without linking it to future delimitation. This resembles the Congress position in the editorial.

Mains dimensions

  • Transparency and process: four letters from the Leader of the Opposition in Rajya Sabha since April, and a reply that names earlier outreach but discloses no content, show a legislative process that is not consultative. The author sees an intent to legislate "by stealth", which denies public debate on a federal question.
  • Federal balance: the North–South contest is the core. The freeze rewarded States that curbed population growth. The author argues proportions preserve each State's relative influence in majorities. Opponents argue absolute-number gaps widen as the House grows, since majorities are counted in absolute numbers.
  • Constitutional contradiction: the Government promised unchanged proportions but introduced Bills needing 2011 Census-based allocation, which the author says would have made its own promise unconstitutional. This undermines credibility, and the author cannot say whether it was incompetence or duplicity.
  • Women's reservation: the author calls it a distraction in the delimitation debate, but notes that a 50% expansion is the publicly stated way to implement the quota without displacing sitting male members.
  • Political economy: social engineering and caste representation create demand for more seats. The Congress's "defeat any BJP amendment" strategy has costs if the default outcome is census-based reallocation that cuts Keralam and Tamil Nadu and gives the BJP an opening to blame the Congress and the Left.
  • Larger House: logistical and deliberative strains; the Council of Ministers can be up to 15% of the Lok Sabha, so a bigger House could mean a bigger executive. The 15% limit (Art. 75(1A)) was introduced by the 91st Amendment (2003). PRS estimates that a 50% larger House (543 to 815) would lift the permissible Council of Ministers from 81 to 122. Alternatives suggested in coaching sources include a weighted-representation formula (which would need a major constitutional amendment) and applying a demographic-performance criterion only to seats beyond 543.
  • Way forward: disclose draft Bills; hold an all-party meeting; consider a formula that protects absolute seat counts of slower-growing States; and consider legislating the women's quota from 2029 independently of delimitation.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Delimitation after the 2027 Census threatens to alter the federal balance between populous and demographically stable States. Examine the constitutional options before Parliament and suggest a way forward that reconciles representational equality with federal fairness."

Related topics

  • Art. 368 (special majority and State ratification); 91st Amendment (size of Council of Ministers)
  • Finance Commission devolution criteria and the use of 1971 vs 2011 population (federal fiscal link)
  • Electoral systems: gerrymandering; SC/ST reserved constituencies; 106th Amendment
  • ECI's SIR and roll revision (see the SIR note)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 24 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs