BrainParrot

Tied by geography, divided by politics

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 23 October 2026

Summary

  • The author traces the roots of India–Bangladesh friction to the 1971 Liberation War itself. Bangladesh's elites swing between gratitude and resentment, and fear Indian domination because of geography and shared Bengali culture.
  • He argues that India's close identification with Sheikh Hasina and the Awami League, her August 2024 fall and flight to India, and the continuing refusal to extradite her turned the relationship into a crisis.
  • With Tarique Rahman (BNP) in power since February 2026, "functional engagement" has resumed but suspicion persists. The piece ends with advice for both sides: India should show restraint, and Dhaka should not define autonomy through opposition to India.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — India & neighbourhood; bilateral relations (India–Bangladesh)

Key facts for Prelims

  • Mukti Bahini: Bangladesh's liberation force in the 1971 war. India's decisive military role led to the Pakistani surrender (as the author puts it).
  • Maitri Diwas: 6 December, marking India's 1971 recognition of Bangladesh.
  • Ganga Water Treaty, 1996: signed 12 Dec 1996; 30-year term; dry-season (1 Jan–31 May) sharing at Farakka Barrage (West Bengal, operational 1975); expires December 2026; Joint Committee; 50,000-cusec consultation trigger.
  • Joint Rivers Commission (India–Bangladesh) is the main mechanism for cooperation on rivers, flood control, irrigation and cyclone forecasting. India and Bangladesh share 54 transboundary rivers. The Teesta remains unresolved.
  • Longest land boundary of India: with Bangladesh (4,096 km); the editorial says "more than 4,000 km".
  • Neighbourhood First policy and Act East are the policy frames. BIMSTEC is cited by the Standing Committee as an alternative to SAARC.
  • The Standing Committee on External Affairs (Chair: Shashi Tharoor) submitted its report "Future of India–Bangladesh Relationship" in December 2025.

Data and details

  • Shared border: more than 4,000 km. Bangladesh is "virtually surrounded" by India (on three sides).
  • Timeline in the article:
  • 1971: Liberation War.
  • Post-Mujib period: Ziaur Rahman redefines nationalism in Islamic terms, away from linguistic nationalism.
  • August 2024: Hasina's overthrow and flight to India.
  • February 2026: BNP returns to power under Tarique Rahman (also BNP Chairman).
  • Nov/Dec 2026: speculated visit of Rahman to New Delhi.
  • Key actors: Sheikh Mujib and Indira Gandhi (shared goodwill; the "honeymoon" was short). Ziaur Rahman (distancing from India, tilt towards Pakistan, China, US). Sheikh Hasina (Awami League; India identified its interests with her).
  • Dhaka's fears: a Hindu-majority West Bengal shaping India's Bangladesh policy, threatening Bangladesh's independent identity. Open borders after 1971 revived memories of the Hindu bhadralok's socio-economic dominance in pre-Partition Bengal.
  • Rivers: Bangladesh's principal rivers flow through or originate in India.
  • The author says India is "indispensable" to Bangladesh's regional connectivity. No relationship with Beijing, Islamabad or Washington can substitute for a workable one with the country that surrounds it on three sides and shares its major river systems.
  • Author: Mohammed Ayoob, University Distinguished Professor Emeritus of International Relations, Michigan State University, and co-author with K. Subrahmanyam of The Liberation War (1972).
  • The author says India's continued refusal to extradite Hasina keeps the "Hasina question" a major bilateral irritant.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Asymmetry between a large state and its smaller neighbours drives the "big-brother" perception problem in South Asia. India's Neighbourhood First policy tries to counter it with connectivity, credit lines and equitable cooperation.
  • The editorial's point on "identity politics" is that in Bangladesh, attitudes to India are tied to a domestic contest between Bengali-linguistic secular nationalism (Awami League) and a religion-inflected nationalism (BNP and allies). Foreign policy is therefore not just an interstate matter.
  • Transboundary rivers are the area where geographic interdependence is greatest and where "reciprocity" demands are most sensitive (Ganga, Teesta).

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – International Relations: India & its neighbourhood; effect of policies of neighbouring countries on India. GS1 – Modern history: Liberation of Bangladesh, 1971 and post-independence South Asia. GS1/GS3 – Transboundary rivers (water sharing).

Background primer

India–Bangladesh Relationship (core concept)

What it is:
The bilateral relationship with a country India borders on three sides. The 4,096-km India–Bangladesh border is India's longest land boundary.
Founded:
India was among the first countries to recognise Bangladesh (6 December 1971), celebrated as Maitri Diwas.
Mandate:
Bangladesh is India's largest trading partner in South Asia. India has extended nearly USD 8 billion in Lines of Credit.
Why it matters:
Shared history and geography make stability next door a core Indian interest. The Neighbourhood First and Act East policies depend on it. Bangladesh is central for connectivity to the North-East.

Ganga Water Treaty, 1996 (the "river waters" flashpoint the author flags)

What it is:
A bilateral treaty governing the sharing of Ganga waters at Farakka between India and Bangladesh during the dry season.
Founded:
12 December 1996, for 30 years, renewable by mutual consent. It followed prolonged disputes since the 1950s and interim arrangements in 1977, 1982 and 1985, giving a long-term, formula-based framework. The Farakka Barrage has operated since 1975.
Mandate:
Regulate dry-season flows at Farakka between India and Bangladesh.
Why it matters:
Equity, fairness and no harm between upper and lower riparian states. The treaty is reviewed every five years and is renewable by consent.

Awami League and BNP (the two poles of Bangladeshi politics)

Additional context

  • The BNP won the 12 February 2026 general election, and PM Modi was among the first leaders to congratulate Tarique Rahman. Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla attended the 17 February 2026 swearing-in in Dhaka and handed over a personal letter from PM Modi inviting Rahman to visit India at the earliest convenience.

  • The Ganga Water Treaty is due to expire on 12 December 2026, ahead of renewal talks. Bihar has raised concerns on flooding, siltation and dry-season availability in any renewal.

  • The Parliamentary Standing Committee on External Affairs (December 2025 report) noted 54 shared rivers, with agreements only on the Ganga and two other rivers and none on the Teesta. The Teesta issue has been unresolved since 2011 due to state-level irrigation and water-scarcity concerns.

  • Bilateral trade was USD 13.46 billion in 2024-25, heavily skewed towards India. Parliament's committee flagged 864 km of unfenced border.

Mains dimensions

  • Historical roots: Gratitude turned to discomfort because the "liberator" role was played by India, not Bangladesh itself. India's contribution became a source of resentment, since nations prefer narratives of self-liberation (the Mukti Bahini's contribution notwithstanding).
  • Identity politics: The Awami League's Bengali-secular nationalism favoured India. Under Ziaur Rahman, nationalism was redefined in Islamic terms. India became a variable in Bangladesh's domestic identity contest, not just a foreign policy issue.
  • Strategic autonomy of a smaller state: What India reads as "gratuitous anti-Indianism" was, from Dhaka's side, hedging through Pakistan, China and the US. The author argues India must read it as an assertion of autonomy.
  • India's own missteps: India tied its interests to one leader and party (Hasina/AL). It was seen as placing security interests above Bangladesh's democratic evolution. Her fall, her flight to India and India's refusal to extradite her compound the damage.
  • Geography as a binding constraint: India surrounds Bangladesh on three sides, shares major rivers and is vital for connectivity. Dhaka cannot substitute Beijing, Islamabad or Washington. Equally, India's security and stability are "inextricably intertwined" with Bangladesh's.
  • Policy prescriptions (the author's way forward): India should exercise preponderant power with restraint and sensitivity. It should not demand reciprocity for magnanimity, especially on river waters. Bangladesh should not define autonomy through knee-jerk opposition. Neither side should rely on 1971 gratitude, since repeated invocation "reinforces the psychological trauma."
  • Critical note: The piece is largely a historical-psychological argument. Contemporary levers (Ganga treaty renewal, Teesta, border management, trade, minorities, Hasina's extradition) are mentioned only in passing and need to be supplemented in an answer.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Gratitude for 1971 cannot be the foundation of India–Bangladesh relations; national interest, linked to identity, is enduring. Examine this statement and suggest how India can build a more resilient relationship with Bangladesh after the change of government in Dhaka."

Related topics

  • Liberation War 1971: Mukti Bahini, Instrument of Surrender, 1972 Treaty of Friendship (textbook)
  • Ganga Water Treaty (1996) renewal; Teesta dispute and the role of West Bengal; Joint Rivers Commission; Farakka
  • Land Boundary Agreement 2015 and border management (fencing, BSF)
  • Neighbourhood First, Act East, BIMSTEC vs SAARC
  • Role of states in foreign policy (federalism and treaty-making, Article 253)
  • China's and Pakistan's role in South Asia

Topics: GS2History

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 23 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs