Prasar Bharati is not a public service broadcaster
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 23 October 2026
Summary
- An editorial argues that, twelve years after the 2014 promise to give Prasar Bharati BBC-style autonomy, the corporation still functions as a mouthpiece of the government of the day. It uses the 138th episode of "Mann Ki Baat" (September 27, 2026) as the most visible reminder.
- It lists provisions of the Prasar Bharati Act, 1990 that remain unimplemented, and recounts the history from the 1948 Nehru statement to the 1995 Supreme Court direction.
- It urges constituting the parliamentary committee and the Broadcasting Council, rebuilding the Board, and funding free of government strings. It says either courts must enforce the Act or the Lok Sabha after the 2029 general election must act.
Key facts for Prelims
- Prasar Bharati (Broadcasting Corporation of India) Act, 1990: assent 1990, enforced 1997. Statutory autonomy for AIR and Doordarshan. The Bill is described as "a charter of freedom" under Article 19(1)(a).
- Section 12: functions and objectives. Section 13: Parliamentary Committee of 22 MPs. Sections 14–15: Broadcasting Council and complaints. Section 10: recruitment board. Section 23: Central government's power to issue directions. (Section references as given in the editorial and 2a.)
- Public Service Broadcasting Day: November 12 (declared in 2000), marking Gandhi's only AIR broadcast in 1947 at Kurukshetra to refugees.
- UNESCO (2001) definition: public broadcasting is neither commercial nor state-controlled and speaks to every citizen.
- Secretary, Ministry of I&B v. Cricket Association of Bengal (1995): airwaves are public property; Centre must set up an independent autonomous public authority to control them (Justice P.B. Sawant).
- Nehru's 1948 statement in the Constituent Assembly: a semi-autonomous corporation under the government, with policy controlled by the government, but not run as a government department.
- Chanda Committee (1966) and the B.G. Verghese committee (Janata government) are earlier landmarks on broadcasting autonomy; the Verghese-based 1979 Prasar Bharati Bill lapsed.
- The Ministry of Information and Broadcasting administers the Act. Prasar Bharati is not a regulator like TRAI.
Data and details
- Javadekar's May 2014 promise: end the "government fiefdom" and recast Prasar Bharati on the BBC model (autonomous, editorially free, accountable to Parliament). Twelve years later it remains unfulfilled.
- The 138th "Mann Ki Baat" was broadcast on September 27, 2026.
- The government accused the BBC of a "continuing colonial mindset" after its 2023 documentary "India: The Modi Question". From April 2024 the BBC had to split its Indian news operation to meet foreign-investment rules.
- Mark Tully (2017): public service broadcasting is not the same as government broadcast. It rests on non-interference in autonomy and on not judging programmes by commercial merit alone.
- The Janata government asked B.G. Verghese to recommend autonomy. The 1979 Bill lapsed. The 1989 version received assent in 1990 and was enforced in 1997.
- Sections 13, 14 and 15 remain unimplemented. The 22-member parliamentary committee has never been constituted, and the Broadcasting Council has never been set up, so there is no system of editorial redress. Jawhar Sircar's explanation: ministers insist they alone are answerable to Parliament and so keep the power to summon AIR and Doordarshan officials.
- The Board has been filled with bureaucrats. Ownership of assets and staff was never transferred, and there is no independent fund. Section 23 still lets the Centre issue binding directions on what may or may not be broadcast.
- Section 10's recruitment board saw no action until July 2020, when Jagadish Upasane, who headed Bharat Prakashan (publisher of Panchajanya and Organiser), was made chairman.
- A 2021 manpower audit compared Prasar Bharati's then 25,000-strong workforce with the BBC: almost half in engineering vs a little over 10% at the BBC; content staff under 20% vs about 70%.
- In 2022 a Christian hymn sung by school students was sought to be dropped from the commemorative national broadcast for Public Service Broadcasting Day.
- In August 2026 the government told the Lok Sabha that it had received no formal complaints from journalists or media bodies about its autonomy in the previous year. The editorial argues that the absence of complaints is not evidence of independence because there is no Council to receive them.
- The Chanda Committee (1966) concluded that a psychological transformation in the government's approach to broadcasting was needed. The editorial says sixty years on it has not come.
- The editorial's two options: approach the courts to enforce the Act and the Sawant direction, or wait for the 2029 general election.
- Suhas Borker (Citizens First TV, convener of Jan Prasar) conceptualised the National Public Service Broadcasting Day on November 12 in 2000.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Public service broadcasting differs from state broadcasting: it serves citizens, not governments. Its legitimacy rests on editorial independence from both the market and the ministry, and on accountability to the public and Parliament.
- Statutorily, the Prasar Bharati Act, 1990 created an autonomous corporation. Its independence depends on bodies the Act itself created: the Board, a Parliamentary Committee (Section 13), a Broadcasting Council (Sections 14–15) and a Recruitment Board (Section 10). The editorial's central claim is that several are missing or have been captured, while Section 23 lets the Centre issue binding directions.
- The Supreme Court's 1995 judgment in Secretary, Ministry of I&B vs Cricket Association of Bengal treats airwaves as public property that must be controlled by an independent autonomous public authority. This is the constitutional anchor for the argument.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Statutory bodies and regulatory institutions; accountability of the executive to Parliament; freedom of speech and press (Article 19(1)(a)). GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability. GS1/Essay: media's role in democracy.
Background primer
Prasar Bharati (Broadcasting Corporation of India)
- What it is:
- India's statutory public broadcaster, running All India Radio (AIR) and Doordarshan. The Act provides for a Broadcasting Corporation for India, to define its composition, functions and powers.
- Founded:
- The Act (No. 25 of 1990) was enacted on 12 September 1990 and administered by the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting; it came into force on 15 September 1997. A parliamentary standing committee records that the Corporation was established with effect from 23 November 1997. Before this, AIR and Doordarshan were attached offices of the Ministry and their staff were central government employees. Earlier attempts included the Verghese Committee and a 1979 Bill that lapsed (per the editorial).
- Members:
- a Board (Chairman, Executive Member, and others including employee representatives). The Executive Member functions as the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) responsible for day-to-day administration. Section 13 provides for a Committee of 22 MPs, 15 from the Lok Sabha and 7 from the Rajya Sabha elected by single transferable vote, to oversee the Corporation and report to Parliament. Section 14 provides a Broadcasting Council with a President and ten other members appointed by the President of India from among persons of eminence in public life, plus four MPs. The Council receives complaints under Section 15 and advises the Corporation on its objectives in Section 12.
- Mandate:
- Guided by specified objectives emphasising unity and integrity, democratic and social values in the Constitution, and the varied cultural traditions of the regions. Section 12(2)(b), as the editorial notes, requires the corporation to safeguard citizens' right to be informed "freely, truthfully and objectively".
- Why it matters:
- The Statement of Objects and Reasons declares a policy to confer autonomy so that AIR and Doordarshan function in a fair, objective and creative manner. The intention was a genuinely autonomous body, innovative, dynamic and flexible, with high credibility and responsible to the people and Parliament.
Additional context
- The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Information Technology has repeatedly expressed concern over the non-implementation of provisions such as constituting a Parliamentary Committee and the Broadcasting Council, even though the Act says "shall". It recorded that Sections 13, 14 and 33 (regulations) were never implemented.
- During a Lok Sabha debate on amending the Act, it was recalled that the Nitish Sengupta Committee had recommended abolishing the Committee of 22 MPs and replacing the Broadcasting Council with a single-member judicial ombudsman. The editorial instead holds that the bodies were never set up.
- An explainer notes that the Act permits binding government directions on sovereignty, security and public order, which enable content control during crises. Reform proposals include amending Section 23 to confine directions to narrowly defined emergencies, subject to written reasons, parliamentary scrutiny and judicial review.
- A 1997 Amendment Ordinance (promulgated 29 October 1997) amended the Act to augment Prasar Bharati's autonomy and remove overlap with a proposed Broadcasting Authority.
Mains dimensions
- Autonomy gap between law and practice: the Act's design (Board, Committee, Council, Recruitment Board) has not been implemented. Section 12 safeguards objectivity, but Section 23 keeps a government override. The "truncated corporation" cannot hold the government at arm's length.
- Accountability to Parliament: no parliamentary committee has been formed, because ministers claim sole answerability to Parliament. The editorial reads this as accountability being replaced by ministerial control.
- No grievance mechanism: the Broadcasting Council is the intended complaint forum. Its absence makes the government's "no formal complaints" statement to the Lok Sabha meaningless as evidence of autonomy.
- Organisational capture and capacity: bureaucrat-heavy Board; Indian Information Service officers in operational control; a workforce skewed to engineering (almost half vs about 10% at the BBC) and content staff under 20% (vs 70% at the BBC), pointing to a transmission machine, not a content organisation.
- Constitutional anchor: Article 19(1)(a) and the Cricket Association of Bengal ruling (airwaves as public property needing an independent authority). Courts could enforce the Act (a writ of mandamus is a possible route, as the editorial suggests approaching courts).
- Comparison and credibility: the BBC model was invoked in 2014 and by Nehru in 1948; the political class later attacked the BBC itself. This shows the pattern that autonomy is demanded in opposition and forgotten in power.
- Counter-view (for balance): the government may argue that a state-funded broadcaster has to carry national messages (e.g., Mann Ki Baat) and that commercial revenue is limited. Reform proposals in explainers include a Parliament-approved public-service grant and revenue diversification.
- Way forward: constitute the Section 13 committee and Section 14 Council; make the Board professional; transfer assets and staff; fund through a mechanism without government strings; remove IIS officers from operational control; amend Section 23 and update the 1990 Act.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Prasar Bharati was envisaged as an autonomous public service broadcaster but functions as a government mouthpiece. Analyse the institutional and legal reasons and suggest reforms."
Related topics
- Article 19(1)(a) and freedom of the press; Cricket Association of Bengal (1995); Indian Express/Romesh Thappar line of press-freedom cases
- Broadcasting regulation: TRAI, the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, and the proposed broadcasting bills
- Parliamentary committees (standing and consultative committees) and executive accountability
- Emergency (1975) and its impact on the media; B.G. Verghese, Chanda and Joshi Committees
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 23 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs