On Abdullah’s promise of Statehood
Source: The Hindu, 19 October 2026
Summary
- Two years into Omar Abdullah's government in the Union Territory of J&K, the author argues his working-relationship approach with the Centre has yielded little on Statehood. The Lieutenant-Governor controls police, bureaucracy and universities.
- The National Conference has hardened its stance through a 28 September Assembly resolution, a Jantar Mantar protest and closer ties with the INDIA bloc.
- Two senior officials opposed the Statehood resolution as "sub judice." Transaction of Business Rules remain undecided.
Key facts for Prelims
- J&K was split into two UTs: J&K (with Legislature) and Ladakh (without), under the J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019.
- The Lieutenant Governor is an Administrator appointed under Article 239.
- Section 53: Council of Ministers capped at 10% of Assembly strength. Section 55: LG makes business rules on the Council's advice.
- LG's discretion covers All India Services, the Anti-Corruption Bureau and matters outside the Assembly's powers. Public order and police are with the LG, per AIR.
- Article 3: Parliament can form new States (including by upgrading a UT) by simple majority. The President must refer Bills that affect a State's boundaries to the State legislature, whose views are not binding.
- Article 370: special status abrogated in 2019; its abrogation was upheld by the Supreme Court in Dec 2023, which also directed statehood restoration "as soon as possible."
- The J&K Assembly is a 90-member House. Article 371 contains special provisions for certain States, and the Centre has agreed to discuss it for Ladakh.
- Transaction of Business Rules determine the powers and limits of the CM, the Council and the LG.
Data and details
- 2024 election: NC won 42 of 90 seats. BJP won 29 and PDP 3. Turnout was 63.8%, in a region marked by violence and election boycotts since the 1990s. NC has ruled the region for more than four decades.
- Omar Abdullah was 54 at the time of the victory and completes two years in office.
- October 2024: the first Cabinet meeting passed a resolution calling for "restoration of Statehood in its original form." He presented it to PM Modi, and it also stressed safeguarding the identity and constitutional rights of residents.
- 2025: NC lost the Budgam bye-election, a seat Abdullah had won in 2024.
- 28 September 2026: Assembly resolution on Statehood, referencing the 1953 special position and the 2000 resolution for greater autonomy.
- 20 July 2026: protest at Jantar Mantar. NC also has a growing presence in the INDIA bloc.
- LG Manoj Sinha has complete grip over police, bureaucracy and universities, per the author.
- Abdullah named the top officials who went against him in the Assembly. The author reads this as hard posturing after his balancing act yielded no results. His earlier public and social-media praise of PM Modi also "yielded little."
- Chief Secretary Atal Dulloo and Law Secretary Achal Sethi wrote to the Assembly Speaker, without taking the CM into confidence, opposing the resolution as "sub judice."
- Transaction of Business Rules remain undecided after two years, shuttling between Lok Bhavan and the Chief Minister's office.
- In Ladakh, amid agitation, the Centre has agreed to discuss Article 371 provisions to grant special status. Statehood for J&K "remains a distant dream."
Static–dynamic linkage
A Union Territory with a legislature (J&K, Delhi, Puducherry) has an elected government that shares power with a centrally appointed Lieutenant Governor, unlike a full State where the Governor is largely a nominal head. In J&K the 2019 Reorganisation Act specifies the LG's discretionary subjects and the procedure for making business rules. Restoring Statehood requires Parliament to act under Article 3. The author's central question is whether an elected government with limited powers can deliver on its promise.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Union Territories and their administration; Centre–State relations; functions and responsibilities of Union and States; role of Lieutenant Governor (Article 239, J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019).
Background primer
Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019 (Act 34 of 2019)
- What it is:
- the law that restructured the former State into two Union Territories. It provided for the Union Territory of Ladakh without a legislature and the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir with a legislature.
- Founded:
- after the 5 August 2019 announcement. The Centre announced revocation of J&K's special status under Article 370 and bifurcation into two Union Territories.
- Mandate:
- the LG acts in his discretion on matters outside the Assembly's powers and on matters related to All India Services and the Anti-Corruption Bureau. His decision on whether a matter is discretionary is final.
Statehood restoration and Article 3
Supreme Court on Article 370 (Dec 2023)
Additional context
- A newsonair report says the Assembly passed a resolution seeking immediate restoration of full statehood, moved by Chief Minister Omar Abdullah and passed by voice vote, with BJP legislators staging a walkout.
- Omar Abdullah took oath on 16 October 2024. AIR reported that about four and a half months after government formation, the Cabinet approved Business Rules and sent them to the LG. AIR notes the LG's powers are already defined, as he holds law and order, public order and All India Services.
- AIR also reported that the Union Home Ministry amended the Transaction of Business Rules under the Reorganisation Act, significantly strengthening the LG's authority. This was in July 2024, before the elected government took office. Proposals on police, public order, All India Services and the ACB now reach the LG directly through the Chief Secretary, not via the J&K Finance Department.
- Drishti IAS reported in October 2024 that the Supreme Court agreed to hear a petition on restoring J&K's statehood. It later reported that the Court sought a detailed Centre response in Zahoor Ahmed Bhat vs UT of J&K, where delay in restoration is argued to undermine federalism. This litigation is the context for the "sub judice" objection the article reports.
Mains dimensions
- Responsible government under dual authority: the elected government has the mandate and the LG holds police, bureaucracy and universities. The author says this has marginalised the government. Section 53(2) and the final-say clause favour the LG.
- Cooperative vs. confrontational strategy: the working-relationship approach (including praise for PM Modi) produced little. The hardened stance (resolution, Jantar Mantar, INDIA bloc) comes with political risk. The author says choices are limited: "batting for Delhi" loses the voter base, and doing what voters want antagonises the Centre.
- Administrative friction: the Chief Secretary and Law Secretary opposed the Assembly's resolution without the CM's knowledge. This raises the issue of civil service accountability to the elected executive.
- Legal and political commitments: the Supreme Court recorded the Centre's assurance and asked for statehood "as soon as possible" (see 2a). The Centre's response has been described as a cold shoulder.
- Political cost to the NC: Budgam bye-election loss, waning popularity, and the 2024 mandate of 63.8% turnout, which created high expectations in a region where Kashmir wanted an end to the sense of siege.
- Asymmetric federalism: the Centre is willing to discuss Article 371-type provisions for Ladakh, while J&K's Statehood remains pending. The comparison raises questions about uniformity in treating regions.
- Way forward: finalise Business Rules, define the LG's and government's spheres clearly, set a time-bound roadmap for Statehood, and use dialogue rather than litigation.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Examine the dual-power structure in Union Territories with legislatures, with reference to Jammu and Kashmir. How does it affect responsible government and the demand for restoration of Statehood?"
Related topics
- Article 239, 239A, 239AA and the Delhi–LG dispute; Puducherry
- Articles 3 and 4; creation of new States; Articles 370/35A and the 2023 Supreme Court verdict
- Article 371 series; Sixth Schedule (Ladakh demands)
- Governor vs. Lieutenant Governor; Sarkaria and Punchhi Commissions on Centre–State relations
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 19 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs