Metrics to minds — restoring purpose to universities
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 17 October 2026
Summary
- This is an opinion piece. It argues that India has stretched the logic of single national examinations beyond the narrow purpose they once served, which was fair selection of a few thousand officers, soldiers and engineers.
- It says that standardised multiple-choice tests (NEET, JEE, UGC NET) and numerical research-score metrics now decide admissions and academic appointments across all disciplines.
- It claims this undermines academic judgement, intellectual diversity and institutional autonomy.
- Its remedy is to let university departments set their own admission tests and make appointments through peer judgement. Faculty would then be held accountable for the quality of those decisions.
Key facts for Prelims
- The NTA was approved by the Union Cabinet in November 2017 as an autonomous, self-sustained society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, under the Ministry of Education.
- It conducts JEE Main, NEET-UG, CUET-UG/PG and UGC-NET. NEET-UG has been under the NTA since 2019.
- UGC-NET is a test of eligibility for Junior Research Fellowship, Assistant Professor and Ph.D. admission.
- The UGC Regulations on Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers were notified on 18 July 2018 and superseded the 2010 Regulations.
- NEP 2020 was approved on 29 July 2020. It proposes a single regulator (HECI) for higher education excluding medical and legal education, and common NTA entrance exams at least twice a year.
- NEP 2020 also targets graded autonomy for colleges and phasing out of the affiliation system in 15 years, along with a 50% Gross Enrolment Ratio in higher education.
- For UGC-NET categories 2 and 3, the NET score carries 70% weightage and the university interview 30% in Ph.D. admission.
Data and details
- The original purpose of national exams, per the article: to find "a few thousand" officers, soldiers and engineers, fairly across the country.
- NEET, JEE and UGC NET now test lakhs of candidates across disciplines from oncology to organic chemistry and history to Punjabi literature, all in the same multiple-choice format.
- In the Ph.D. selection matrix for teaching posts, 30 marks are commonly set aside for the doctorate.
- So-called authenticated journals publish across 7 or 8 disciplines under one title. The article's example is a "Journal of International Studies" printing history, management, literature and law in one issue with no serious referee process.
- UGC 2018 Regulations (per the article): they discontinued the earlier API-based Performance Based Appraisal System (PBAS) and introduced a revised framework with research scores. The author says the underlying problem persists.
- Absences the article points out:
- Nobody who taught the author's generation had sat the NET.
- No education body appears to have done a historical comparison of teaching quality before and after standardised testing.
- Journals do not send papers to qualified referees.
- Vice-chancellor search committees ask about patents, which have no relevance outside a narrow band of applied science.
- The viva voce is treated as a formality.
- The author's own interview for associate professor: a committee of four eminent professors, headed by a vice-chancellor, interviewed for over 40 minutes.
- Mechanism of STEM bias: a scientist running a large laboratory can add his name to every research candidate's paper, inflating his publication count beyond what a lone humanities scholar could match.
- The ISBN or ISSN is described as no evidence of scholarly merit.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Static concept: Higher education governance in India is split between regulators (UGC), autonomous testing agencies (NTA) and universities. The tension is between standardisation, which gives fairness, scale and uniformity, and autonomy, which gives academic judgement and diversity.
- Why it matters: UPSC regularly tests the trade-off between merit measured by common exams and merit judged contextually, as well as the role of regulators such as the UGC. The editorial is a case study for both.
- Policy link: NEP 2020 favours faculty and institutional autonomy, and also proposes common entrance exams run by the NTA. The piece highlights the tension between these two ideas.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity/Governance: Education, regulators, institutional autonomy | GS2 – Social sector: Human-resource development | GS3 – Science and Technology: Research output and incentives
Background primer
National Testing Agency (NTA)
- What it is:
- An autonomous, self-sustained testing organisation set up by the Government of India to conduct standardised examinations for admission to higher education institutions.
- Founded:
- Approved by the Union Cabinet in November 2017 as a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. It gives effect to the Programme of Action 1992, which envisaged an all-India common entrance exam for professional programmes.
- Mandate:
- It conducts JEE Main, NEET-UG, CUET-UG/PG and UGC-NET.
- Why it matters:
- Earlier the CBSE ran JEE Main and NEET, but its expertise was in schooling. The NTA was created as a specialist body for entrance testing using modern assessment techniques.
UGC-NET
- What it is:
- A test of eligibility of Indian nationals for Junior Research Fellowship and Assistant Professor appointment, Assistant Professor and Ph.D. admission, or Ph.D. admission only, in Indian universities and colleges.
- Why it matters:
- A common eligibility screen for teaching and research careers across disciplines.
UGC Regulations, 2018 (minimum qualifications and standards for teachers)
- What it is:
- UGC regulations on minimum qualifications for appointment of teachers and measures for the maintenance of standards in higher education. They were notified on 18 July 2018, in supersession of the 2010 Regulations.
- Mandate:
- Fixes minimum qualifications and service conditions for university and college teachers, including research-score thresholds for appointment and career advancement.
- Why it matters:
- To maintain standards by setting objective minimum criteria. The editorial argues these criteria have turned into counting exercises.
NEP 2020 (higher education)
- What it is:
- Approved on 29 July 2020, it was the first education policy in 34 years.
Additional context
- NTA under scrutiny in 2026: The NTA cancelled the NEET-UG 2026 exam held on 3 May, announcing the cancellation on 12 May. A pre-circulated "guess paper" was found to overlap with the actual paper, over 22 lakh candidates were affected, and the government referred the matter to the CBI. The exam was re-conducted on 21 June 2026. This supports the editorial's wider theme of strain in the standardised testing system, though the author's own argument concerns the narrow reach of MCQ tests, not paper leaks.
- UGC-NET and Ph.D. admission: For categories 2 and 3, the NET score carries 70% weightage in Ph.D. admission and the university interview carries 30%. This is a case of departments having some say within a national exam framework.
- Research-score thresholds in the 2018 Regulations: The Regulations specify minimum publications and research scores, such as 75 for one associate-professor route and at least 120 for the professor route. A minimum of 110 research score is needed for promotion to Professor under the Career Advancement Scheme. This bears directly on the editorial's critique of counting publications.
Mains dimensions
- Standardisation versus judgement: The article argues that MCQ tests built for uniformity cannot measure reasoning or critical thinking. They reward test technique and memorisation, and so change what a classroom is. The author calls this a loss of reading depth and questioning, based on his own long observation rather than data.
- Departmental autonomy: The article proposes that departments set their own admission tests, as in Western systems, so that faculty judgement and student choice return. This is consistent with the NEP 2020 aim of faculty and institutional autonomy. It sits uneasily with the NEP 2020 push for common NTA entrance exams.
- Metric fixation in recruitment: Publication counts, minimum publication requirements and research scores have created a "market for papers". Low-quality journals accept whatever applicants must publish to meet deadlines, and the 30-mark Ph.D. weight does not reflect the quality of the work. Supervision and viva voce checks are thin.
- Leadership selection: Patent counts in VC searches favour STEM candidates, and lab heads can inflate publication numbers. A VC who has only worked in a laboratory may not be suited to lead an institution meant to cultivate minds beyond it.
- Networking over merit: Many appointments are settled by networking, not metrics, so fixing metrics alone will not help. The author's contrasting example is a rigorous 40-minute interview by an eminent panel.
- Reform direction: Harsher laws and penalties for examiners and testing agencies punish lapses but do not prevent them. The article calls for peer-made appointments and accountability for judgement, and admits this costs more time and requires institutions to defend choices without hiding behind a number.
- Counter-arguments:
- Standardised national exams serve equity, scale and transparency. Many universities lack good internal processes, and decentralisation can bring nepotism or arbitrary admissions.
- The author's evidence is largely anecdotal, as he concedes, and the NEET-UG 2026 paper leak shows the testing system's own problems. The challenge is to improve testing integrity while limiting its reach, not necessarily to drop it.
- Way forward:
- Use multi-factor selection with common eligibility screens plus departmental interviews.
- Weight research on quality rather than counts, for example by blacklisting predatory journals.
- Require external referees and a serious viva for the Ph.D.
- Set transparent VC search criteria, with graded autonomy tied to accountability.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Standardised national examinations and metric-based recruitment have been criticised for undermining academic judgement and institutional autonomy in Indian higher education. Critically examine, and suggest reforms in the light of NEP 2020."
Related topics
- NEP 2020 higher education reforms: HECI, graded autonomy, Academic Bank of Credits, MERUs
- UGC Act, 1956 and the role of regulators (UGC, AICTE, NAAC)
- NTA functioning, paper leaks and exam-integrity reforms
- Research ecosystem: National Research Foundation, predatory journals, quality of Ph.D.s
- Equity in admissions: CUET and common entrance tests
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 17 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs