BrainParrot

Between a rock and a hard place

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 17 October 2026

Summary

  • In Dhamtari and Kanker (Bastar), Christians report disrupted prayers, village signboards barring pastors and priests, and refusals of burial sites. All this follows the Chhattisgarh Dharma Swatantrya Adhiniyam, 2026 (Freedom of Religion Act, FORA), which replaced a 1968 law.
  • Gram sabhas cite the Fifth Schedule and PESA to bar entry of pastors/converts and deny community land for burials. Christian leaders call this a misuse of PESA, with "the law taking precedence over the Constitution".
  • A writ petition against the Act is pending in the Chhattisgarh High Court, which on 7 October gave the State three weeks to respond.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Fundamental rights (Articles 21, 25), Fifth Schedule and PESA, state legislation, judiciary; GS1 — Society: communalism, tribal society

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 25: freedom of conscience and free profession, practice and propagation of religion; Article 26: management of religious affairs; Article 27: no compulsory taxes for promoting a religion; Article 28: religious instruction in educational institutions. All are subject to public order, morality and health (Articles 25–26).
  • Rev. Stanislaus v. State of MP (1977): Constitution Bench upheld the MP and Odisha anti-conversion laws; no fundamental right to convert others.
  • Article 244(1): Fifth Schedule for Scheduled Areas and STs in States other than Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram. Article 243M(4)(b): Parliament may extend Part IX to Scheduled Areas with modifications.
  • PESA, 1996: enacted 24 December 1996; Gram Sabha as the key body; village defined by customary habitation.
  • Gram Sabha: all persons on the village-level Panchayat electoral roll (Section 4(c) PESA).
  • Article 21 includes the right to a decent burial/last rites (judicial interpretation).
  • FORA 2026 competent authority: District Magistrate or authorised officer not below ADM; the offence is cognisable and non-bailable.

Data and details

  • Locations: 116-year-old Sundarganj Mennonite Church (Dhamtari); 15-year-old Diocese of Church of God at Jamgaon village (Kanker), where the gram sabha has put up one of three signboards.
  • FORA: passed by the Assembly in March, notified in August. It prescribes life imprisonment and fines up to ₹25 lakh in specific cases of "illegal conversion". It requires prior intimation from converts and religious functionaries to the competent authority.
  • CM Vishnu Deo Sai's BJP government defends it as curbing conversions that exploit poverty and lack of education.
  • Christian groups in Dhamtari say 1,500 self-declaration forms (visitors attending of free will) have been submitted to the District Collector, as a pre-emptive step. They note the law places the burden of proof on those accused of alluring people.
  • Burial disputes:
  • Somlal Rathore's burial last July led to violence and the signboards. His son-in-law Sandeep Chauhan says the body was exhumed and taken elsewhere.
  • Ramesh Baghel's case: a split Supreme Court verdict ordered burial at a designated site in Karkapal village (Bastar), and directed the State to demarcate exclusive Christian burial sites across the State. Kanker Collector Kundan Kumar says no sites have been allotted in his district because of stiff village opposition.
  • Last December, in Bade Teoda (Kanker), the father of then sarpanch Rajman Salam was buried on family land. A mob vandalised a prayer hall, police were injured in clashes over three days, and Salam was removed through a no-confidence motion.
  • Aamabeda police station covers 72 villages, the farthest 50 km away. In Tumasnar, five of 16 families stopped attending church.
  • Punpalli panchayat (Sukma): the gram sabha banned allotment of community land to Christians/converts for burials, churches and prayer meetings, citing Article 244(1), the Fifth Schedule, PESA and the amended Chhattisgarh PESA Rules, 2022.
  • Alleged exclusion: Chauhan now travels 17 km daily for casual labour after losing butchery work. A lawyer alleges denial of rural employment scheme work and forest produce collection, and one family barred from harvesting its crops.
  • BJP leaders' view: the Punpalli decision protects tribal culture (Madkam Bhima, BJYM). Jamgaon sarpanch Bhagwati Uikey calls the bans "non-negotiable". Hunga Markam alleges missionaries use healthcare and money; Christian leaders deny this.
  • Challenge: a Chhattisgarh High Court writ petition alleges violence, social boycott, misuse of conversion charges, gram sabha overreach, denial of burial rights, and says the Act makes even voluntary conversion subject to disclosure and multiple clearances. It seeks interim relief on some provisions. On 7 October the HC asked the State to respond within three weeks.
  • Local police claims: disruptions are mostly not acted on (FIRs often against a group, not named individuals), per Christian representatives. A senior police officer calls finding an acceptable solution "impossible".

Static–dynamic linkage

Article 25 protects freedom of conscience and the right to profess, practise and propagate religion, subject to public order, morality and health. The High Court has said Article 25 is not absolute and is subject to public order, morality and health. In Rev. Stanislaus, the Supreme Court (cited by the High Court) held that Article 25 does not grant a fundamental right to convert others, and that freedom of religion covers all religions alike. The present conflict tests whether a State law that regulates "forced" conversion, and village bodies exercising PESA's cultural-protection powers, can coexist with individual rights and the dignity of a decent burial.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental rights (Article 25 freedom of religion; Article 21 dignity/burial); Fifth Schedule and PESA, 1996; Part IX; state anti-conversion laws; judiciary's role. GS1 – Society: communalism, tribal identity, social boycott.

Background primer

Chhattisgarh Dharma Swatantrya Adhiniyam, 2026 (FORA)

What it is:
legislation to prevent religious conversions through force, fraud, coercion or inducement, while regulating voluntary conversions.
Why it matters:
curbing alleged exploitative conversions. Critics say it burdens voluntary conversion with disclosure and clearances.

PESA Act, 1996 and the Fifth Schedule

What it is:
an Act "to provide for the extension of the provisions of Part IX of the Constitution relating to the Panchayats to the Scheduled Areas". Scheduled Areas are those under Article 244(1), where the Fifth Schedule applies to States other than Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram.
Founded:
enacted on 24 December 1996. The Bhuria Committee (1994–95) recommended that Gram Sabhas should control natural resources and development in tribal regions.
Mandate:
safeguards traditions and customs, cultural identity, community resources and customary dispute resolution. Gram sabhas manage water, forest, land and minor forest produce, prevent land alienation and regulate intoxicants.
Why it matters:
adivasi communities in Scheduled Areas are to have a governance regime that respects their right to autonomous self-governance. PESA does not itself authorise restrictions on individual constitutional rights, which is the heart of the "misuse" charge.

Additional context

  • FORA coverage: authorities must publish details of the person intending to convert within seven days, and any person can object within 30 days of notice. An advance declaration is required 60 days before an interfaith marriage.
  • During the Assembly debate, the opposition pointed out that similar matters from 11 States are pending before the Supreme Court. The Deputy CM replied that the apex court had not stayed such legislation.
  • Burial rights: in the Baghel case, the Supreme Court bench split. Justice Nagarathna would have allowed burial on private land, while Justice Sharma insisted on a designated burial ground.

Mains dimensions

  • Freedom of religion vs regulation: the law's mandatory declaration, public display and multiple clearances arguably burden private conscience (Articles 19, 21, 25 and privacy), while the State claims a public-order interest in curbing coercion. The test is proportionality. Courts have upheld anti-conversion laws on force/fraud/allurement but a prior-permission regime attracts closer scrutiny.
  • Vigilantism and enforcement asymmetry: groups carrying printed copies of the Act stopping worshippers, and low police action, show a gap between law and rule of law. Pre-emptive self-declaration forms show the chilling effect.
  • PESA as sword or shield: gram sabha powers protect customary culture from outside interference, but their use to exclude fellow villagers from land, burial and worship collides with Part III. The Constitution (not PESA) is the higher law, and a Gram Sabha is bound by fundamental rights.
  • Burial and dignity: the Supreme Court has ordered designated Christian burial sites, but administrations say villages block them. This is a failure of implementation of judicial directions, and a dignity-in-death issue under Article 21.
  • Tribal society and religion: debates around "Hindu and tribal culture", conversion and customary participation reveal tensions inside tribal communities. Social boycott and economic exclusion (jobs, forest produce, crops) are forms of discrimination that Article 15 and statute address.
  • Federal and judicial dimension: the Supreme Court has similar State laws pending; the High Court petition is pending. Cross-State patterns of anti-conversion laws raise questions of uniform constitutional standards.
  • Way forward: a clear judicial standard, SOPs for police on disruptions, enforcement of burial-site directions, PESA training clarifying limits, and inter-community dialogue.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Anti-conversion laws and the use of PESA by village assemblies to restrict religious practice raise questions about the balance between religious freedom, tribal self-rule and public order. Critically examine in the context of recent developments in Chhattisgarh."

Related topics

  • Articles 14, 15, 19, 21, 25–28; secularism as basic structure; Rev. Stanislaus (1977)
  • Fifth and Sixth Schedules; Forest Rights Act, 2006 and the Gram Sabha
  • Panchayati Raj (Part IX) and the 73rd Amendment; Gram Sabha powers
  • Freedom of religion laws in other States and pending Supreme Court cases

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 17 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs