The debate over immunity to CEC, ECs
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 16 October 2026
Summary
- The Supreme Court has recently issued notice to the Centre on a petition by the Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) challenging the lifelong immunity for the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners for actions in discharge of official duties.
- The explainer argues the provision should be removed. Section 16 of the 2023 Act was added late as an amendment, has no stated rationale, and no comparable authority enjoys such blanket protection.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 14: equality before law and equal protection of the laws. It is part of the basic structure.
- Equality before law: British (A.V. Dicey, Rule of Law). Equal protection of the laws: American concept.
- Article 361: no criminal proceedings or process for arrest/imprisonment of the President or Governor during their term. Civil proceedings need two months' prior notice.
- Articles 105 and 194: parliamentary and State legislature privileges (freedom of speech and vote). They continue to be those of the British House of Commons until Parliament codifies them. Parliament has not enacted such a law.
- Diplomatic immunity: from civil and criminal jurisdiction under the Vienna Convention, applicable on a reciprocal basis in more than 190 countries.
- CEC & EC Act, 2023 (Dec 2023), Section 16: immunity for current and former CEC/ECs. The earlier 1991 Act had no such provision.
- Authorities without such lifelong immunity (per the explainer): judges, CAG, PSC Chairpersons and members, Lokpal and Lokayuktas, Information Commissioners.
- Anoop Baranwal (2023): interim selection panel of PM, LoP and CJI.
Data and details
- Section 16 was not in the original Bill and was added by amendment on the day the Bill passed in the Rajya Sabha. Lok Sabha then cleared it and the President assented. The Statement of Objects and Reasons gave no rationale.
- Article 361: civil proceedings need a two-month notice. The explainer says these immunities were inherited from British-era offices (Governor General and Governors).
- Parliamentary privileges are mainly for actions inside the House and while the House is in session. President/Governor immunity is only during the term of office.
- The Petitioner: ADR (the explainer notes the SC has issued notice to the Centre).
Static–dynamic linkage
- Equality before law is part of the basic structure. It is a Diceyan idea: no special privileges and no one above the law. Equal protection of laws is an American concept of equal treatment in equal circumstances.
- Classification is allowed under Art. 14 only if it is not arbitrary. It needs an intelligible differentia and a rational relation to the object of the law.
- Constitutional immunities are narrow and each has a rationale. The President and Governors get immunity during their term; legislators get privileges mainly inside the House; diplomats get immunity based on functional necessity and reciprocity.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Art. 14 (equality before law/equal protection), Rule of Law, constitutional immunities (Arts. 361, 105, 194), independence of constitutional bodies
Background primer
Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023
- What it is:
- The law governing appointment, service conditions and term of the CEC and ECs. It replaced the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of Election Commissioners and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991.
- Founded:
- Passed in December 2023. It followed Supreme Court intervention in Anoop Baranwal (2023), where the Court ruled that a panel of the PM, the Leader of Opposition and the CJI would select the CEC and ECs until Parliament passed a law.
Article 324 – the Election Commission
Additional context
- Earlier, an NGO, Lok Prahari, challenged Section 16 of the 2023 Act. A Bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi issued notice to the Centre and the ECI but declined to stay the provision.
- That plea argued the section gives permanent, blanket immunity from civil and criminal proceedings, even for alleged misuse of office.
- The Supreme Court in 2023 said it could not mandate parity in removal between the CEC and ECs, as the Constitution provides different processes, and that extending protection to ECs for their independence is for Parliament to consider.
Mains dimensions
- Art. 14 test: The classification must be non-arbitrary, with an intelligible differentia and a rational nexus to the objective. The explainer argues the blanket, unconditional and lifelong nature of Section 16 fails the test.
- Comparative immunities: Each existing immunity is time-bound or functional (President/Governor during term; legislators within the House; diplomats by reciprocity). Section 16 is lifelong and covers former office-holders.
- Process legitimacy: A late amendment, with no Statement of Objects reasoning, which weakens deliberation.
- Independence vs accountability: The Law Minister's rationale is unhindered functioning. Counter: other independent authorities (judges, CAG, Information Commissioners) function without such immunity. Immunity for "purported" acts could shield even acts beyond duty.
- Electoral integrity: Lifelong immunity for "purported" official acts could restrict legal remedies against the very authority that supervises elections under Art. 324, which links this debate to the credibility of the electoral process.
- Way forward: Narrow it to acts in good faith within official duty, retain removal safeguards, and ensure judicial review is available.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Independence of constitutional bodies must not come at the cost of accountability. Critically examine the blanket immunity granted to the CEC and Election Commissioners under the 2023 Act in light of Article 14."
Related topics
- Articles 14, 324, 361, 105, 194; Anoop Baranwal (2023); Selection Committee for CEC/ECs
- Removal of the CEC (Art. 324(5)); independence of CAG, UPSC, Information Commissions, Lokpal
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 16 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs