Land shortage cripples Agriculture Ministry’s weather network rollout
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 16 October 2026
Summary
- The WINDS project is meant to build a nationwide network of automatic rain gauges (ARGs) and automatic weather stations (AWSs). It is a PPP run by an Agriculture Ministry body, and it is moving at a crawl.
- Completion is in single digits and the project is at least a year behind deadline. Over 96% of planned sensors are not yet installed.
- Implementing companies blame two things:
- a shortage of suitable land;
- an alleged "retrospective" tightening by the India Meteorological Department (IMD) of the rule that sensors go on the ground, not on rooftops.
- IMD says ground siting is essential for accurate data.
Key facts for Prelims
- WINDS = Weather Information Network and Data System, run by the Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare and executed through the Mahalanobis National Crop Forecast Centre (MNCFC).
- Purpose: hyper-local weather data, mainly to compute insurance estimates and payouts under the Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY).
- ARG: measures rainfall only. About 10% of ARGs at gram panchayat level also carry a temperature sensor.
- AWS: measures rainfall, air temperature, relative humidity, wind speed and wind direction.
- Data from the sensors flows to data centres run by government agencies. These prepare hourly, daily and fortnightly forecasts.
- Implementation is through States and their private implementing partners (PPP model).
- Guideline instruments: the 2023 WINDS manual (published 1 September 2023) and its amendment of 3 December 2025. A WINDS Committee exists, and prior State recommendation and approval for rooftop units in flood- or landslide-prone areas goes to it.
- World Meteorological Organization (WMO) guidelines require ground-based sensors, with rooftop placement only in exceptional situations, according to IMD officials and a former IMD meteorologist.
- MNCFC's schemes: FASAL, CHAMAN, NADAMS.
- MNCFC was inaugurated on 23 April 2012 and is named after P.C. Mahalanobis.
- PMFBY was launched on 18 February 2016. It replaced NAIS and MNAIS.
Data and details
- Targets: three companies (Skymet Weather Services, Ingen Technologies Private Limited, Azista Industries) were collectively asked to install 1,197 AWSs and 49,313 ARGs, about 50,500 sensors.
- Progress (status update of 9 September, the latest The Hindu could confirm):
- 113 AWSs installed (9.4% of target).
- 1,730 ARGs installed (about 4%).
- A shortfall of about 48,700 sensors, over 96%.
- The project is at least a year behind deadline.
- State ARG targets:
- Uttar Pradesh: 27,487, which is over half the ARG target.
- Uttarakhand: 7,983.
- Odisha: 7,286.
- Himachal Pradesh: about 3,550.
- Assam: 2,140.
- State AWS targets:
- Odisha: 434, the largest.
- Assam: 196.
- Uttar Pradesh: 157.
- Kerala: 148.
- Site rejections:
- Uttar Pradesh: 16,478 of 27,644 sites rejected (about 60%).
- Odisha: 5,666 of 7,720 rejected (about 73%).
- Kerala: 524 of 946 rejected (about 55%).
- Documents also flag hundreds of "duplicate sites" approved at panchayat and block level that need re-checking, sites pending clearances, and sites States have yet to share with implementing partners.
- Rules timeline:
- The 2023 manual (1 Sept 2023) allowed an ARG on the roof of a single-storey building where siting norms could not be met or in flood-prone areas. It set no numerical cap on rooftop units.
- Amended on 3 Dec 2025, about 2.5 years later and after six States had already issued tenders or work orders. The amendment was made on IMD's advice. Rooftop ARGs are now capped at 10% of the total.
- Rooftop installation needs a State justification note saying no suitable ground space exists.
- In flood- or landslide-prone regions the ceiling is 15%, with prior State recommendation and approval sent to the WINDS Committee.
- The article reports the "retrospective" charge as the companies' claim. The 10% to 15% figure was reported by one company representative who asked not to be named.
- Official positions:
- S. Hosalikar, former senior IMD meteorologist and a member of the 2023 committee, says sensors must be on the ground and rooftops only in exceptional cases, because height significantly affects weather data.
- IMD Director-General M. Mohapatra says a consistent ground-based network is needed for standardised data, and that getting small plots of land in villages should not be that hard.
- He stressed that IMD is only a technical partner and does not administer the project.
- MNCFC Director Soumya Bandopadhyay did not respond to The Hindu before going to press.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Crop insurance runs on objective loss measurement. Under an area approach, payouts depend on yield estimates at a defined insurance unit, or on weather variables recorded at notified local weather stations.
- Hyper-local, standardised weather data is therefore a public good that keeps insurance payouts fair and fast.
- Building that data layer is partly a metrological problem, since sensor siting affects readings, and partly a land-governance and federal-coordination problem. The news shows that implementation failures (sites, land, rule changes) can stall a scientifically sound scheme.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Economy: Agriculture (crop insurance, e-technology aids to farmers); GS2 – Governance: Centre–State implementation, PPP models, data-driven governance; Prelims – Economy/Geography (meteorological instruments)
Background primer
WINDS (Weather Information Network and Data System)
- What it is:
- A nationwide network of AWSs and ARGs that generates long-term hyper-local weather data. It was initiated by the Department of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare (Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare) for hyper-local weather data and wider use in agriculture and other sectors.
- Founded:
- The WINDS Manual dates from 2023. The WINDS portal was launched along with the AIDE mobile app and the YES-TECH manual under PMFBY initiatives. The reason for building it: WINDS has so far focused on PMFBY requirements, though other uses such as disaster management and agro-forestry can be integrated.
Mahalanobis National Crop Forecast Centre (MNCFC)
- What it is:
- A body under the Department of Agriculture (and Farmers' Welfare), Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers' Welfare, for applying space and geospatial technology across agriculture.
- Founded:
- It is named after the statistician Dr. Prasanta Chandra Mahalanobis and was inaugurated on 23 April 2012. It was set up to give in-season crop forecasts and drought assessment using methods developed by ISRO.
- Members:
- Headed by a Director. It works with state agriculture and horticulture departments, three ISRO centres (SAC, NRSC, NESAC), ICAR institutes, IMD and others.
Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY)
- What it is:
- A flagship crop insurance scheme. It covers risks from pre-sowing through to post-harvest losses.
- Founded:
- It was approved for all States/UTs from Kharif 2016, replacing NAIS and MNAIS. It was launched on 18 February 2016.
- Members:
- The Centre and States share the premium subsidy in a 50:50 ratio. Subsidy sharing is 90:10 for North-Eastern and Himalayan States/UTs. Insurance companies are allotted districts through bidding.
India Meteorological Department (IMD)
- What it is:
- India's national meteorological service, under the Ministry of Earth Sciences.
Additional context
- The 2023 WINDS Manual required ARGs at a minimum height of 30 cm from the ground. It allowed rooftop placement on a one-storey building where siting requirements were not met or in flood-prone areas. This matches the article's account of what the 2023 rules permitted.
- The manual estimated about 2,00,000 new ARGs and about 5,000 new AWSs nationwide. The three firms' 50,500-sensor mandate in the article is thus only part of the full national build-out.
- The manual says ARGs should sit on a level piece of ground with short grass or natural earth, ideally 4 m × 3 m. This helps explain why land availability is a bottleneck.
- Sensors must be certified or calibrated by IMD or NABL-accredited laboratories, or equivalent.
- Since Kharif 2016 until Rabi 2025-26, more than 92.46 crore farmer applications have been insured, with claims above ₹2.06 lakh crore paid. This shows the scale of the scheme that relies on weather data.
- Under weather-based insurance, payouts trigger when weather variables (rainfall, dry spells, temperature, humidity, wind speed) at notified local stations cross pre-defined thresholds. Station coverage therefore directly affects claims.
Mains dimensions
- Why the data matters:
- Fair and fast PMFBY claim settlement depends on dense, standardised local weather data.
- Without sensors, insurance units depend on sparse or inconsistent records, which raises basis risk and disputes.
- This weakens the scheme's credibility, but also its use in forecasting and disaster management.
- Implementation bottleneck is land, not hardware:
- Site rejection rates are about 55% to 73% in the States cited.
- Many sites are duplicate, awaiting clearance, or not yet shared with the companies.
- This points to weak land identification, coordination and clearance processes at panchayat, block and State level. Land is a State subject, so the Centre cannot fix it alone.
- Regulatory certainty and PPP risk:
- Rule changes made after six States had issued tenders or work orders, alleged to be retrospective, raise contractual and cost uncertainty for private partners.
- The episode shows why PPP projects need stable specifications, clear risk allocation and a consultation process with implementers.
- Scientific standards versus feasibility:
- IMD and the WMO stress ground siting for data quality, since sensor height changes readings. This is a legitimate technical concern.
- Rooftop placement helps with land shortage and flood-prone areas. The 10% to 15% cap tries to balance the two.
- A way forward could be using government land such as school, panchayat and revenue plots, plus a clear siting protocol.
- Institutional clarity: IMD is only a technical partner while MNCFC and the Agriculture Ministry run the project. Responsibility is thus spread across the Centre, States, a technical agency and private firms, and the MNCFC Director was unavailable for comment.
- Way forward: an inter-departmental land bank, faster site approval, a joint State–Centre review mechanism, third-party quality audits, and a clear transition rule for contracts signed before the amendment.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "Hyper-local weather data is central to an effective crop insurance system. Examine the challenges in building such infrastructure in India, with reference to the WINDS project, and suggest measures to overcome them."
Related topics
- Restructured Weather-Based Crop Insurance Scheme (RWBCIS) and the area approach versus individual farm-level assessment
- YES-TECH, CROPIC and the National Crop Insurance Portal; FASAL, NADAMS (drought monitoring)
- IMD and the WMO's role in setting standards for meteorological observations
- PPP models in infrastructure: risk allocation and the rental model
- Land as a State subject and Centre–State coordination in agriculture
Topics: GS3Economy
All current affairs of 16 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs