BrainParrot

Enlighten us on the prohibitory orders, preserve all CCTV footage: SC to Centre

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 16 October 2026

Summary

  • A two-judge Bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi asked the Centre to "enlighten" it on the Section 163 BNSS prohibitory orders imposed on Delhi. These led to mass detentions of journalists, lawyers and protesters during the October 10 demonstrations demanding CEC Gyanesh Kumar's resignation. The Court also ordered all CCTV footage of the protest and detention centres to be preserved.
  • Linked proceedings: notice to the CEC and the two ECs on the Opposition petition for disclosure of SIR records; the Centre to explain the denotification of Jantar Mantar; and notice on a plea for criminal contempt against Rahul Gandhi and other Opposition leaders.
  • Parallel developments: protests entered a sixth day, with about 100 detained at a "Tiranga march". A Delhi HC refused to stop a protest. An actor was told to leave India. A Kerala protester alleged custodial assault. The Hindu's editorial attacks the Jantar Mantar denotification.

UPSC relevance: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental Rights (Arts. 19, 21, 22), police powers, judiciary, ECI

Key facts for Prelims

  • Section 163 BNSS (2023) replaces Section 144 CrPC (Section 144 CrPC corresponds to Section 163 BNSS). It is issued by a District Magistrate, Sub-Divisional Magistrate or other specially empowered Executive Magistrate. It ordinarily lasts two months, and the State Government may extend it for a further period of up to six months from the date it would have expired.
  • Other BNSS preventive-police provisions: Section 170 (preventive action against a planned cognizable offence) and Section 172 (detain or remove a person who disregards a lawful direction; to be produced before a magistrate or, in petty cases, released within 24 hours).
  • Section 189(1) BNS (formerly Section 141 IPC): defines unlawful assembly as five or more persons with an unlawful common object.
  • Art. 19(1)(a) (speech/expression) and 19(1)(b) (peaceful assembly without arms); reasonable restrictions under 19(2)/(3) (sovereignty, public order, contempt, etc.). Art. 19 rights belong to citizens. Art. 21 protection extends to foreigners as well.
  • Case law: MKSS v. UoI (2018, Jantar Mantar); Amit Sahni (2020, Shaheen Bagh); Anita Thakur (2016); Ramlila Maidan (2012).
  • Vishakha guidelines (1997) on workplace sexual harassment, later codified in the POSH Act, 2013 (stable background).
  • Delhi Police is under the Union Home Ministry. Foreigners Regional Registration Offices (FRRO) handle foreigner registration and enforcement. In Mumbai the DCP Special Branch 2 is the designated FRRO.
  • Criminal contempt can be initiated suo motu or on a petition. Foreigners have no fundamental right to political activity per the police reading of the Act.

Data and details

  • Protests of October 10 demanded CEC Gyanesh Kumar's resignation. Delhi protests entered their sixth consecutive day on Thursday.
  • Detentions: youth groups say about 100 detained at the AISF/AIYF Tiranga march at Connaught Place; Delhi Police gave no official count.
  • SIR: the Opposition petition says the exercise has left about 13 crore people without the power to vote. It seeks full disclosure of SIR records and an independent probe into alleged unilateral and arbitrary action by the CEC.
  • Respondents noticed: CEC Gyanesh Kumar and ECs Sukhbir Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. Counsel: Kapil Sibal, A.M. Singhvi, Prasanna S.
  • Court directions: preserve all CCTV footage, including detention centres and the Supreme Court premises (October 12 incident).
  • Jantar Mantar: Centre to explain the denotification. The authorities told the SC it was not based on the October 9 SC order but on expert opinion. The Delhi Police told the Delhi HC it followed the SC directive of October 9 (editorial). The Court refused interim orders without hearing the authorities.
  • Contempt plea (advocate Digant Mishra and others): seeks action against Rahul Gandhi and Opposition leaders for a "political procession" into the SC precincts on October 12. Notice to the Centre, the Delhi Police Commissioner and Mr. Gandhi.
  • Justice Bagchi's remark: the prohibitory orders are a "ghost" for now, to be brought under constitutional scrutiny after the Centre's affidavit. Petitioners say Section 163 orders cannot be made in contiguous areas and were not made public.
  • Journalists: the Delhi Union of Journalists (C.U. Singh) alleged devices were seized. Mr. Mehta denied it; the Court told the government to "make good the statement in an affidavit". Indira Jaising (Network of Women in Media, India) sought an independent committee headed by a woman, possibly a woman SC judge, on Vishakha lines. The Court prima facie agreed but the government sought time. Rajya Sabha MP John Brittas said security personnel "pounced upon" him; the CJI asked him to file a petition.
  • Counsel arguments: A.N.S. Nadkarni sought personal responsibility for protest organisers; Gopal Sankaranarayanan said police must also be accountable.
  • Jantar Mantar plea (Swaty Singh): protesters must be within earshot of power. Justice Bagchi referred to advances in technology; N. Hariharan retorted that, by that logic, courts could be addressed from Kerala.
  • Mumbai: actor Imran Khan (a foreign national) was served a notice by FRRO Mumbai under the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025. He was asked to leave by October 28 for joining the October 10 Mumbai protest. He is considering a writ. Kirit Somaiya alleged foreign funding; Supriya Sule and Sanjay Raut criticised the action.
  • Custodial injury: Fidal Royas (27, Kerala) was detained on October 2, October 10 and October 11. On October 11 he was allegedly beaten after recording a video. The medical report notes a perforated right ear and mild hearing loss, and surgery will be decided within two weeks.
  • Rally and closures: NDMC closed Central Park (Connaught Place) on Friday and Saturday for "administrative reasons" before the "Lehra Do Tiranga" rally. CJP's Abhijeet Dipke alleged rail and Metro suspensions after October 10. The Delhi HC (Acting CJ Nitin Wasudeo Sambre, Justice Sanjay Sharma) refused to restrain the CJP protest on October 16 and recorded the police assurance to regulate it. A Connaught Place vendor had sought regulation, citing festive-season losses.
  • Demands of youth groups: end police action; restore Jantar Mantar as a designated site. AISA president Neha Bora said the campaign is expanding to cities like Mumbai.
  • CJP leaders Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka faced police action for carrying the National Flag to Jantar Mantar on Tuesday.
  • Background to the denotification (editorial): on October 9 the CJI-led Bench urged the Union to identify an alternative, spacious and open protest site. Observations were exchanged that protests at Jantar Mantar inconvenience commuters. The editorial cites Washington DC and London as democracies where protest sites are centrally located. It argues that protesters are usually marginal groups who lack representation at the decision-making table.
  • Other hearing details: Senior advocate Mukta Gupta appeared for Swaty Singh (Jantar Mantar plea). Senior advocate Gaurav Bhatia argued for the contempt petition that the procession aimed to browbeat the judiciary; the CJI said "Nobody can browbeat the judiciary". Nadkarni's petitioner was Bhanu Sanoriya. Mr. Brittas said he had already written to the CJI.
  • Royas case details: he reached Delhi on the night of October 1 and returned home 11 days later. He alleged five or six policemen kicked him with boots after he stepped out of the bus, and that he was slapped again inside it. He reported delays in getting medical reports at Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital, and so continued treatment in Kerala.
  • CJP rhetoric: Abhijeet Dipke questioned the PM's support for the CEC. He said Delhi had been turned into an "India-Pakistan border" and challenged the government to declare an Emergency outright if it wanted mass detentions. He invoked Gandhi and Ambedkar and called a peaceful 5 p.m. flag gathering at Central Park.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Protest is a fundamental right derived from Art. 19(1)(a) (speech and expression) and 19(1)(b) (peaceful assembly), and is subject to reasonable restrictions on grounds such as public order.
  • The State may regulate but not extinguish it. A preventive power like Section 163 BNSS must be used on proportionality and imminence tests, not as blanket administrative convenience.
  • Preventive detention and custodial treatment engage Arts. 21 and 22. Press freedom (a facet of Art. 19(1)(a)) is engaged by device seizure and detention of journalists.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental Rights (Arts. 19(1)(a), 19(1)(b), 19(2)-(3), 21, 22); GS2 – Judiciary: PIL, Art. 32, contempt; GS2 – Governance: police accountability; GS3 – Internal Security: law and order, public order

Background primer

Section 163, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 (prohibitory orders)

What it is:
A preventive provision that replaces the colonial Section 144 CrPC. It empowers an Executive Magistrate to issue binding written directions to prohibit certain actions or regulate property use.
Founded:
BNSS, 2023 replaced the CrPC, 1973. Section 163 is the successor to Section 144 for urgent cases of nuisance or apprehended danger.
Mandate:
Invoked to prevent riots, violent protests, danger to life, or disturbance of public peace. It ordinarily expires after two months. The State Government may, by notification, extend it for a further period of up to six months from the date it would have expired, to prevent danger to life, health or safety or a riot or affray.

Right to protest and the Jantar Mantar line of cases

What it is:
A right read out of Art. 19(1)(a)/(b) and not an explicit fundamental right.
Why it matters:
Dissent is a democratic safety valve. The protester's right must be balanced with the commuter's right.

Additional context

  • Drishti IAS reports that the Delhi Police invoked Section 163 BNSS to ban unauthorised assemblies and used Sections 170 and 172 BNSS for pre-emptive detentions.

  • The same analysis says that in Delhi only about 1.5% of such orders were used to prevent unlawful assemblies, the rest for micro-management.

  • It also notes the UN expressed concern over the "mass detentions".

  • Foreigners' law: The Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025 replaced four older laws (Passport (Entry into India) Act 1920, Registration of Foreigners Act 1939, Foreigners Act 1946, Immigration (Carriers' Liability) Act 2000). It took effect from September 1, 2025. An Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025 was also notified to regulate visa compliance and foreigner registration. Whether protest participation breaches visa conditions under the Act is not confirmed from a trusted source beyond the police statement in the article.

Mains dimensions

  • Public order vs right to protest: The editorial argues that "inconvenience" arguments are no ground to push protests away from the seat of power. Proximity to Parliament and the President's Estate is the point of protest. It links this to the BJP's simultaneous-elections logic that democracy delays decisions. The 2018 MKSS ruling asked for regulation, not a ban.
  • Opacity of executive orders: Section 163 orders were allegedly not published and were imposed in contiguous areas. The Court's "ghost" remark points to the requirement that restrictive orders be on record and reasoned.
  • Inconsistent justifications: The government told the SC the denotification rested on expert opinion, while the Delhi Police told the HC it followed the SC's October 9 directive. This invites proportionality review.
  • Police accountability and custodial safety: Alleged assault (Royas), seizure of journalists' devices, and detention of women journalists. Proposals include a woman-led independent inquiry and CCTV preservation.
  • Press freedom and women journalists' safety: An Art. 19(1)(a) concern, plus Vishakha-style protections.
  • Institutional legitimacy of the ECI: The protests and SIR litigation turn on the CEC's conduct. The Court's willingness to hear both the Opposition's disclosure plea and a contempt plea against the Opposition shows the Court balancing political protest and judicial dignity ("nobody can browbeat the judiciary").
  • Foreigners and political activity: The action against Imran Khan raises questions on proportionality and viewpoint neutrality. The police rely on the Act's visa conditions, and NCP(SP) and Shiv Sena (UBT) leaders called it political.
  • Way forward: Publish prohibitory orders. Use time-bound, narrowly tailored restrictions. Designate accessible protest sites. Ensure independent inquiry into custodial allegations.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The right to peaceful protest is not unlimited, but neither can the State extinguish it in the name of public order. Discuss with reference to the use of Section 163 BNSS and the denotification of Jantar Mantar as a protest site."

Related topics

  • Articles 19, 21, 22, 32; Section 163 BNSS vs Section 144 CrPC; BNSS preventive arrest provisions
  • MKSS (2018), Amit Sahni (2020), Anita Thakur (2016), Ramlila Maidan (2012); Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (Art. 129)
  • Police reforms (Prakash Singh); Vishakha guidelines and POSH Act, 2013
  • Cross-reference: the SIR/SSR note (006) and the CEC immunity note (086) cover the underlying electoral controversy.

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 16 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs