Illogical reasons
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 15 October 2026
Summary
- The editorial argues that the SIR is flawed by design. Per The Hindu's investigation, the "logical discrepancy" flags in Delhi's draft rolls (especially on family size) disproportionately hit Muslims. None of these flags relates to eligibility.
- It says the criteria were introduced midway in Phase 2 (West Bengal), flagged by ECINET software rather than the statutory Electoral Registration Officer (ERO), and carried into Phase 3 including Delhi.
- It calls on the Supreme Court to halt the SIR.
- Companion reports (same date):
- The SC agreed to "take care of" Delhi voters deleted in the SIR who are being told to file Form 6 as fresh applicants. It advanced the hearing to 28 October.
- Migrant workers from West Bengal in Bengaluru say they were flagged on "family size".
- The Opposition's plea on the SIR and CEC is to be heard on Thursday.
- Congress challenged Amit Shah's "infiltrators" remark.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324 (ECI's superintendence of elections); Art. 326 (adult suffrage; age 18; citizen).
- Section 21(3), RP Act 1950: special revision of electoral rolls.
- Form 6: application for inclusion in the roll, prescribed under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. Per the petition, it requires an affirmation of applying "for the first time". Form 8 is for shifted voters.
- Section 31, RP Act 1950: false declarations in connection with the roll are punishable with imprisonment up to one year, or fine, or both.
- Lal Babu Hussein v. ERO (1995): a name on an earlier roll has probative value as evidence of citizenship and cannot be struck off without inquiry.
- ECI's Manual on Electoral Rolls (2023) and the 2002-03 SIR are the benchmark documents. The editorial says neither provided for the family-size and similar checks.
- ECINET: the ECI's software platform. ASDD = Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate.
- Statutory ERO decision vs algorithmic flagging is the central legal question.
Data and details
- Delhi (Phase 3), editorial:
- Muslims are 13.6% of Delhi's draft rolls, in line with the 2011 Census, but 20.3% of those flagged for "logical discrepancies".
- The share rises to 30% for the five reasons linked to family size.
- Delhi (Phase 3), SC report:
- 47,56,722 electors (32.78% of the pre-SIR roll) were excluded from the draft roll under the ASDD category.
- For anyone on the ASDD list, Form 6 is the only claim route.
- The Delhi SIR case was listed for 30 October, the last date for claims and objections. The CJI advanced it to 28 October.
- The petition (Anjali Bhardwaj and Amrita Johri; counsel Prashant Bhushan and Neha Rathi) asks for a mechanism to restore deleted voters without making them apply as first-time voters. Bhushan suggested Form 8 or a new form.
- The petition calls the additional declaration form without the force of law. It also says the ECI's clarification that the form is not needed in the non-SIR period creates a parallel mechanism. The article's dating of the relevant guidelines (June 2026, October 2025, May 2026) is inconsistent, so treat the dates cautiously.
- Bihar (Phase 1): 18.4% of those deleted from the pre-SIR rolls were Muslims, in line with their population share (17.7%, 2011 Census). There was no direct or indirect religious discrimination, though the enrolment and claims phases had infirmities.
- West Bengal (Phase 2):
- The "logical discrepancies" check was introduced midway.
- 27 lakh electors were deleted after adjudication by judicial officers; 22 lakh appealed, but only 1,607 were reinstated in time for the vote.
- By September, nearly 93% of 1.26 lakh decided appeals had restored electors. The editorial reads this as large-scale disenfranchisement before the vote.
- A sample-based analysis showed a much higher Muslim share among those excluded than their population share.
- More than 20 lakh names are pending before appellate tribunals and are not part of the current enrolment drive.
- Bengaluru (Varthur-Balagere):
- Over 3,500 West Bengal migrants are "under adjudication for logical discrepancy", per the Karnataka Bengali Kalyan Samiti.
- Rafiul Mohammed has four siblings but was told that over six progeny were linked to his father.
- He took loans of over ₹1 lakh to travel repeatedly to his village.
- Settlement rent is ₹3,000-4,000 a month.
- Workers fear loss of voter-linked welfare benefits at home.
- Opposition plea (SC, Thursday): joint petition led by Rahul Gandhi, before CJI Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi, seeking disclosure of "files, agendas, minutes, notings and objections" of ECs Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi on the SIR. It also seeks an interim suspension of the SIR. Petitions on the police crackdown on protesters are listed too.
- Political exchange: Jairam Ramesh asked how many "ghuspaithiye" (infiltrators) were detected, deleted and deported, and whether the "nearly 14 crore" allegedly deprived are infiltrators. This was a reply to Amit Shah accusing Rahul Gandhi of wanting infiltrators registered. The 14 crore figure is the Congress's allegation, not an official number.
- Notably absent (editorial's argument): the flagging criteria have no basis in the Manual on Electoral Rolls (2023) or the 2002-03 SIR. In West Bengal the statutory EROs did not decide who was flagged.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Art. 326 gives the vote to every citizen aged 18 or above who is not disqualified by law. Eligibility is therefore citizenship, age, ordinary residence in the constituency and non-disqualification.
- Anything the ECI uses to exclude an elector must have a rational nexus with these criteria. The editorial says family size, a parent's age at the elector's birth and name spelling have none.
- Lal Babu Hussein v. ERO (1995) holds that a name on an earlier roll is evidence of citizenship and cannot be struck off without inquiry.
- The deeper issue is due process in a mass administrative exercise. Who decides (ERO or software), on what criteria, and with what appeal?
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Representation of the People Acts 1950/1951 (electoral rolls, Form 6, Sec. 31); ECI powers under Art. 324; Art. 326 (adult suffrage); citizenship vs electoral eligibility; natural justice in quasi-judicial decisions
Background primer
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- a focused, time-bound exercise by the ECI to update and verify the accuracy of electoral rolls through house-to-house enumeration by BLOs.
Additional context
- In its 27 May 2026 judgment, the SC held that the ECI has the power to conduct the SIR under Art. 324 read with Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950.
- It held the ECI may examine citizenship only for the limited purpose of the roll. A deletion affects the person's entitlement to be on the roll but does not declare them a non-citizen.
- Final adjudication of citizenship rests with competent authorities under the Citizenship Act.
- The Court noted that SIR decisions are subject to judicial review.
- Delhi roll figures: the draft roll showed 1 crore 45 lakh 10 thousand 299 electors, of whom 97,53,577 submitted enumeration forms. The gap (47,56,722) matches the ASDD figure in the SC report.
Mains dimensions
- Design vs intent: A stated goal of "purity" of rolls requires criteria tied to eligibility. The editorial says family-size, parent-age and spelling checks are arbitrary and correlate with community fertility patterns. This raises issues under Art. 14/15 and the principle of non-discrimination in franchise.
- Who decides: Statutory ERO adjudication was replaced in practice by ECINET flagging. This is algorithmic or administrative opacity in a quasi-judicial function, and a question of delegation.
- Burden of proof: Lal Babu Hussein says a name on an earlier roll cannot be struck off without inquiry, and the SC's 2026 SIR ruling says a deletion is not a declaration of non-citizenship. Yet Form 6 forces previously enrolled voters to affirm "first time" status and exposes them to Sec. 31 risk.
- Outcomes data as evidence: In West Bengal, 93% of decided appeals restored electors, but only 1,607 were reinstated before polling (against 22 lakh appeals). This shows the cost of delayed remedies.
- Migrants and the poor: Repeated travel, debt and loss of welfare linkage for inter-State workers (Bengaluru case). This relates to portability of franchise and social-justice outcomes.
- Institutional trust and politics: The "infiltrator" framing against allegations of mass disenfranchisement. The Opposition's petition seeks disclosure of the files, minutes, notings and objections recorded by the Election Commissioners on the SIR, which goes to transparency within the ECI. The Centre's view and the ECI's stated objective of clean rolls should be weighed alongside.
- Way forward: Halt or recalibrate criteria, publish the logic, give a dedicated restoration form, speed up appeals and use independent audits.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has been defended as a purification exercise but criticised as exclusionary. Critically examine its legal basis, safeguards and implications for universal adult suffrage."
Related topics
- Art. 324-326; RP Act 1950 (Secs. 16, 21, 31) and RP Act 1951
- Citizenship Act 1955 and the distinction between electoral eligibility and citizenship
- Principles of natural justice; the role of quasi-judicial authorities
- Appointment, transparency and independence of the ECI
- Right to protest and the policing of the SIR protests
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 15 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs