India-U.S. ties and the hurdle of American unilateralism
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 14 October 2026
Summary
- The U.S. announced on 8 October that it was suspending the Permanent Labour Certification (PERM) programme for eight global IT companies. The article names five firms as Indian: Infosys, TCS, Wipro, Cognizant and HCL. (Cognizant is in fact U.S.-headquartered, with a large India workforce.)
- The article argues that this is one in a series of U.S. actions that strain ties. The strains it cites are in trade, defence supply and technology transfer, and the U.S. approach to Pakistan.
- It concludes that India's strategic restraint is being met with American pressure and unilateralism. It says the relationship needs equality, respect and trust.
Key facts for Prelims
- PERM is a U.S. Department of Labor programme, the first step toward an employer-sponsored Green Card. H-1B is a temporary work visa for specialty occupations.
- TRUST (Transforming the Relationship Utilizing Strategic Technology) replaced iCET. It was announced on 13 February 2025.
- INDUS-X is the India-U.S. Defence Acceleration Ecosystem, launched in June 2023 (during PM Modi's U.S. state visit) and led by iDEX and the U.S. Office of the Secretary of Defense.
- A 10-year Framework for the U.S.-India Major Defence Partnership was signed on 31 October 2025 (per the article).
- The 2008 India-U.S. civil nuclear agreement is described in the article as a historic breakthrough with a commercial promise "largely unrealised".
- Operation Sindoor was in May 2025 (per the article). The "Mecca Pact" is between Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Türkiye (per the article).
- The GE F404 engine powers the Tejas fighter (per the article).
Data and details
- PERM suspension: announced 8 October 2026 for eight companies. The U.S. says they had received more than 2,30,000 H-1B approvals and over 1,00,000 permanent labour certifications since 2009. Indian professionals account for more than 70% of approved H-1B petitions annually.
- Companies the article names as Indian: Infosys, TCS, Wipro, Cognizant and HCL.
- Trade: India's trade surplus with the U.S. was $33.8 billion in FY 2025-26, on bilateral trade exceeding $140 billion. A framework for an interim agreement was announced in February 2026. Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said last week that talks had "plateaued", with little scope for give-and-take.
- Three trade irritants cited: the surplus, U.S. demands for access to India's dairy and agriculture sectors (which India cannot concede), and India's refusal to halt Russian oil imports despite extra U.S. tariffs and sanctions.
- Defence: India has acquired over $22 billion of U.S. military hardware since 2002, but co-production and technology transfer remain elusive. In February 2025 the U.S. agreed to expand defence sales and co-production in India, including Javelin anti-tank guided missiles and Stryker vehicles. The 10-year framework was signed on 31 October 2025.
- GE F404 engines for the Tejas: prolonged supply delays. INDUS-X (launched 2023) has not removed the problem of co-development and technology transfer.
- Pakistan factor: Trump has repeatedly claimed he ended the post-Sindoor conflict (May 2025), which irked India although New Delhi has avoided direct confrontation. The U.S. courts Pakistan's Chief of Defence Forces, Asim Munir. The Mecca Pact was reportedly signed with Washington's blessing.
- Technology: iCET (2023), TRUST (13 February 2025) and the 2008 civil nuclear agreement are all cited as having largely unmet promises. The challenge is converting declarations into measurable outcomes.
- Diplomatic signal: External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar's remark that the U.S. is "deliberately becoming a lonelier power".
- The article also says the PERM action is "part of a series", including ill-treatment of Indians and racist attacks on them.
Static–dynamic linkage
- India–U.S. ties rest on three pillars: trade and investment, defence and security, and technology plus people-to-people links (the diaspora and professional mobility). The article argues that all three are under stress at once.
- The concept at stake is "strategic autonomy". India wants partnerships (with the U.S., and trade with Russia) without being subordinate to any one power.
- Visa and labour-certification rules are domestic U.S. tools. They affect India's services exports and remittance flows, and so show how a partner's domestic policies can change India's economic interests.
- Defence partnerships are judged by delivery (co-production, technology transfer), not by the number of agreements signed.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: bilateral groupings and agreements; Indian diaspora; effect of other countries' policies on India's interests. GS3 – Economy: external trade; Science & Technology: defence indigenisation
Background primer
PERM and H-1B (the immigration instruments at issue)
- What it is:
- PERM (Permanent Labor Certification) is run by the U.S. Department of Labor and is the first step for employers sponsoring foreign workers for a Green Card. An H-1B visa lets eligible foreign nationals work temporarily in specialty occupations and is distinct from permanent residence.
- Founded:
- details of the programme's origin are not confirmed from a trusted source.
- Members:
- the system is administered by U.S. federal authorities. Employers must establish prevailing wages and conduct domestic recruitment before obtaining certification.
- Mandate:
- it tests whether hiring a foreign worker harms U.S. workers' wages and job opportunities.
- Why it matters:
- it is a labour-market safeguard. The current suspension is justified by alleged abuse, and the article sees it as part of wider pressure on India.
iCET → TRUST (India–U.S. technology partnership)
- What it is:
- TRUST (Transforming the Relationship Utilizing Strategic Technology) is the evolved form of iCET (Initiative on Critical and Emerging Technology).
- Founded:
- iCET was announced in May 2022 and launched in January 2023. TRUST was announced during PM Modi's visit to Washington on 13 February 2025.
- Members:
- the initiative is jointly steered by the National Security Advisors of both countries.
- Mandate:
- it keeps iCET's focus on semiconductors, AI and quantum technologies and adds critical-mineral supply chains, biotechnology, energy and space.
- Why it matters:
- to cooperate on trusted technology supply chains and to ease export-control and technology-transfer barriers. The article says much of this is still "on paper".
INDUS-X (India-U.S. Defence Acceleration Ecosystem)
- What it is:
- a defence innovation bridge launched in June 2023 under iCET.
- Members:
- led by India's Innovations for Defence Excellence (iDEX) and the U.S. Office of the Secretary of Defense.
- Mandate:
- it facilitates partnerships among U.S. and Indian defence companies, incubators, investors and universities.
U.S.–India defence framework (background)
Additional context
- The eight suspended firms were Cognizant, Infosys, TCS, Wipro, HCL, Capgemini, Microsoft and Adobe. The measure was announced by U.S. Labour Secretary Keith Sonderling with Vice President JD Vance.
- The Labour Department will not accept new PERM applications from the named firms or process their pending ones. The suspension does not cancel existing H-1B visas. The administration had not released company-specific findings.
- India's MEA publicly rebuked the U.S. characterisation of foreign tech workers as "indentured servants" after the PERM freeze. The freeze applies to PERM applications and does not by itself cancel existing H-1B visas or Green Cards.
- On trade, India and the U.S. issued a joint statement on 7 February 2026 announcing a framework for an Interim Agreement. Its terms include Indian tariff elimination or reduction on U.S. industrial goods and many farm products, and an 18% reciprocal U.S. tariff on Indian exports. India intends to purchase $500 billion of U.S. energy products, aircraft and parts, precious metals, technology products and coking coal over five years.
- On 20 February 2026 the U.S. Supreme Court held the reciprocal tariffs illegal, after which the U.S. government re-imposed tariffs. A 10% tariff on all countries was imposed from 24 February 2026.
- As of 1 June 2026, Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal said 99% of discussions for the first phase were complete. The article's report that talks have since "plateaued" suggests that early optimism has faded.
Mains dimensions
- Visa/labour measures as pressure: the PERM suspension hits the Indian IT sector's U.S. business model and its professionals' route to permanent residence. This is a diaspora and services-trade issue (Indians are over 70% of approved H-1Bs annually), even though existing H-1B visas are not cancelled (see 2b).
- Trade asymmetry: the surplus ($33.8 billion on $140+ billion of trade), U.S. demands on dairy and agriculture and India's Russian oil purchases make trade the most visible discord. The interim framework (February 2026) has not yet delivered.
- Defence: agreements vs delivery: over $22 billion of purchases since 2002, but meaningful co-production and technology transfer remain elusive. The F404 delays show the strategic cost of foreign dependence for critical components. This supports indigenisation and diversified suppliers.
- Pakistan factor: Trump's claims about ending the conflict, U.S. outreach to Asim Munir, and the Mecca Pact (reportedly with Washington's blessing) feed Indian security concerns.
- Technology partnership on paper: iCET, TRUST and INDUS-X are positive frameworks. The author says they have not yet produced measurable outcomes, and the civil nuclear deal has not yielded American-designed reactors.
- Critique and balance: the piece is an opinion argument. The article's own framing ("subservient India") should be balanced against evidence of continued cooperation (exercises, logistics and intelligence sharing). A "managed partnership" view is also possible, in which economic friction is compartmentalised from security convergence.
- Way forward: insulate defence and technology cooperation from trade disputes, diversify supply chains, tie agreements to delivery milestones, and defend strategic autonomy while engaging the U.S. on mobility and trade.
Possible Mains question
**GS Paper 2, 15 marks:** "India–U.S. relations are said to be moving from 'strategic convergence' to 'managed friction'. Analyse the factors in trade, technology, defence and diaspora issues that explain this, and suggest how India can safeguard its strategic autonomy."
Related topics
- Strategic autonomy and multi-alignment (Russia oil, Quad, SCO/BRICS)
- H-1B and immigration policy; remittances; services exports (IT-BPM)
- Defence indigenisation (Tejas, engines, iDEX, Make in India in defence) and DTTI/foundational agreements
- Bilateral Trade Agreement basics: tariffs, reciprocal tariffs, non-tariff barriers, India's farm-sector sensitivities
- Operation Sindoor and India–Pakistan–U.S. triangle
Topics: GS2Economy
All current affairs of 14 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs