Warming Himalayas demand a rethink on development
Source: The Hindu, 13 October 2026
Summary
- The author argues that the Indian Himalayan Region (IHR) is seeing frequent, severe climate-induced disasters. Long-standing calls for hazard-averse, climate-resilient development have gone unheeded.
- The 26 August collapse of ice and rock in Nepal's Langtang Himal, which became a flash flood in the Bhote Koshi valley, is presented as a warning for the whole Hindu Kush–Karakoram–Himalaya "global natural commons".
- She argues that no technology can prevent such collapses, so the focus must be on impact mitigation through regional data-sharing and early warning. She also wants a cap on high-altitude hydropower, a rethink of the Chenab-Beas link tunnel, and a moratorium on development projects until each is reassessed.
Key facts for Prelims
- Permafrost is ground or rock that stays at or below 0°C. Its melting triggers rock avalanches, landslides and debris flows.
- The Hindu Kush Himalaya (HKH) is called the "third pole". ICIMOD has eight member countries: Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, China, India, Myanmar, Nepal and Pakistan.
- NAPCC has eight missions, including the National Mission for Sustaining the Himalayan Ecosystem and the National Mission for a Green India. NMSHE is coordinated by DST.
- NMHS is a Central-sector grant-in-aid scheme for the IHR.
- The Chenab is formed by the confluence of the Chandra and Bhaga rivers at Tandi in Lahaul and Spiti, Himachal Pradesh. The Beas rises in the Pir Panjal near the Rohtang Pass.
- The proposed Chenab-Beas tunnel passes through the Pir Panjal Range, Lahaul and Spiti district (Himachal Pradesh), near Koksar village.
- Union legislative power over inter-state rivers and river valleys is in the Union List (Entry 56). The State claims water under the State List (Entry 17).
- Indus Waters Treaty 1960: eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas, Sutlej) are allocated to India. Western rivers (Indus, Jhelum, Chenab) go to Pakistan, with limited Indian rights.
- Loss and damage: the UNFCCC agenda item on compensating vulnerable countries. COP27 (2022) agreed a fund, operationalised at COP28 (2023).
- The Avay Shukla Committee arose from the Himachal Pradesh High Court case Court on Its Own Motion vs State of Himachal Pradesh. The Ravi Chopra Committee is the other expert committee cited.
Data and details
- High-mountain Asia is warming at 0.3°C per decade, nearly twice the global average (IPCC/WMO). Effects named: glacier retreat, less slope stability, weaker infrastructure integrity, threats to water security, livelihoods and ecosystems, and higher disaster risk.
- ICIMOD reports of 21 March 2026: ice-loss rates across the HKH have doubled since 2000. An author said the region is navigating a changing future "with an incomplete map".
- The Himalayan range is about 3,500 km long. The Journal of Earth System Science finds the western Himalaya warming faster than the central and eastern stretches. Night-time minimum and winter temperatures are rising at the most extreme rates.
- Nepal produces about 0.1% of global greenhouse gas emissions and is justified in demanding loss and damage compensation.
- Ice that once sat at −6°C to −20°C is now closer to −2°C, so it melts more easily.
- 26 August Nepal event:
- A 600-m-wide section of ice and rock broke from the northern flank of Langtang Himal at 5,600 m and fell 1.2 km.
- USGS recorded shaking equivalent to a magnitude 5.2 event.
- British Antarctic Survey sensors 10 km away recorded unusually high ground temperatures two days before the collapse.
- The debris landed in the Lhende Khola (a Bhote Koshi tributary) and dammed it.
- When the dam broke, an "inland tsunami" of mud and debris travelled 170 km down the Bhote Koshi valley into central Nepal.
- Hydropower: the Avay Shukla and Ravi Chopra Committees recommended restricting major projects, or subjecting construction above 2,200 m to detailed expert review.
- Chenab-Beas project: 8.7-km tunnel, Pir Panjal Range, Lahaul and Spiti, near Koksar, at 3,140 m (10,300 ft).
- Absent facts: the article says there is no technology to prevent such collapses. Only downstream impact mitigation is possible.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Cryosphere and slope stability: Mountain slopes in the Himalaya are held together by ice, either as glacier ice or as permafrost that fills rock joints. Warming weakens both, which makes mass movements more likely. These can cascade into river blockage, temporary dams and flash floods.
- Development–ecology trade-off: Hydropower, tunnels, roads and river-linking in a young, seismically active, fragile mountain system need hazard-sensitive planning. Cumulative EIA, carrying-capacity and zoning are the static tools.
- Climate justice: Nepal contributes about 0.1% of global emissions but bears the damage. That is the logic of "loss and damage" under the UNFCCC.
- Federalism angle: Water is a State subject (Entry 17, List II), subject to Union control of inter-state rivers and valleys (Entry 56, List I). This shapes who regulates high-altitude projects.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: climate change impacts, conservation, EIA, disaster management | GS1 – Geography: physical geography (Himalayas, glaciers, geomorphology), geophysical phenomena (landslides) | GS2 – IR: regional cooperation on transboundary rivers and climate justice (loss and damage)
Background primer
Indian Himalayan Region (IHR) and the National Mission for Sustaining the Himalayan Ecosystem (NMSHE)
- What it is:
- The IHR is the Indian stretch of the Himalayan arc. NMSHE is India's mission dedicated to this ecosystem.
- Founded:
- NMSHE is one of the eight missions under the National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC). It was launched in 2010 and formally approved by the government in 2014. The Union Cabinet approved the Mission document on 28 February 2014, with an outlay of Rs 550 crore for the XII Plan period. NAPCC itself was launched in 2008 by the Prime Minister's Council on Climate Change.
- Members:
- The mission covers the Himalayan States: the 10 hill States of J&K, Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh, Nagaland, Manipur, Mizoram, Tripura and Meghalaya, plus the partial hill States of Assam and West Bengal. The nodal agency is the Department of Science & Technology (DST), Ministry of Science & Technology.
- Mandate:
- The aim is to build sustainable national capacity to continuously assess the health of the Himalayan ecosystem. It also helps policy bodies formulate policy and helps States in the IHR implement sustainable-development actions. Issues covered include Himalayan glaciers and their hydrological consequences, prediction and management of natural hazards, biodiversity and wildlife conservation, and traditional knowledge societies and their livelihoods. It also plans a National Center for Himalayan Glaciology.
- Why it matters:
- The Himalayas are fragile and vital to India's ecological security. The mission document calls for an observational and monitoring network to assess freshwater resources and ecosystem health. It also calls for regional cooperation, with information exchange with countries sharing the Himalayan ecology.
ICIMOD (International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development) and the Hindu Kush Himalaya (HKH)
- What it is:
- An intergovernmental knowledge and learning centre leading the global effort to protect the Hindu Kush Himalaya.
- Founded:
- Established in 1983, headquartered in Kathmandu (textbook fact).
- Members:
- A Nepal-based intergovernmental organisation serving eight regional member countries: Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, China, India, Myanmar, Nepal and Pakistan.
- Mandate:
- Regional knowledge generation and sharing on mountain ecosystems, cryosphere, water and livelihoods. The editorial relies on its March 2026 glacier findings.
- Why it matters:
- The HKH holds the largest store of ice outside the polar regions, which is why it is called the "third pole".
IPCC and WMO
- What it is:
- The IPCC is the UN body that assesses climate-change science. The WMO is the UN specialised agency for weather, climate and water.
- Founded:
- The IPCC was set up in 1988 by the WMO and UNEP (textbook fact).
- Mandate:
- Periodic assessment reports. The editorial uses their finding that high-mountain Asia is warming nearly twice as fast as the global average.
Cryospheric hazard terms used in the article
Additional context
-
ICIMOD glacier findings: The HKH lost 12% of its glacier area and 9% of its ice reserve between 1990 and 2020. Glacier-area loss was 21% in the Ganga basin and 16% in the Brahmaputra basin, while the Karakoram stayed relatively stable (about 2% loss).
-
Snow decline: ICIMOD's 2025 HKH Snow Update called it the third consecutive year of below-normal seasonal snow. Snow persistence from November to March was 23.6% below normal, a 23-year low. Snowmelt supplies about 23% of yearly flow in major river basins.
-
Nepal event, later updates: UN-reported satellite analysis suggests bedrock beneath a glacier gave way and sent ice and rock into the Lhende Khola, a Bhotekoshi tributary. The Bhote Koshi–Trishuli corridor carries a major trade route towards Kathmandu and is lined with hydropower plants, bridges, roads and settlements. A UN briefing in October 2026 put deaths above 1,500, with 5,600 missing, and recovery needs at about $4.8 billion, roughly 10% of Nepal's GDP.
-
Chenab-Beas link: The Centre approved the Chenab–Beas Link Tunnel project in May 2026, at an estimated Rs 2,352 crore. It includes an 8.7-km tunnel to divert surplus Chenab-basin water into the Beas system. Phase 1 includes a 19-metre-high barrage on the Chandra river near Koksar village in Lahaul. NHPC is the implementing agency, and about 4,000 MW of additional hydropower is expected. It was at the drawing-board stage in May 2026. Under the Indus Waters Treaty (1960), the eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas, Sutlej) go to India. The western rivers (Indus, Jhelum, Chenab) go to Pakistan, with limited Indian rights for non-consumptive use and hydropower.
Mains dimensions
- Causes (physical):
- Warming is nearly double the global rate in high-mountain Asia, and fastest in the western Himalaya.
- Warmer ice (−6/−20°C to −2°C) melts more readily.
- Meltwater in moulins and subglacial channels lubricates the glacier base and fractures ice.
- Permafrost thaw removes the "cement" in rock walls. The Langtang collapse followed unusually high ground temperatures recorded two days earlier.
- Impacts:
- A 600-m-wide mass fell 1.2 km, registered as an M5.2 seismic signal, and sent a 170-km flood down the Bhote Koshi.
- Downstream communities, hydropower and roads are exposed, and the event shows collapses "can happen anywhere" in these mountains.
- Ice-loss rates have doubled since 2000, so the long-term risk to water security and livelihoods is rising.
- Climate justice: Nepal emits about 0.1% of global GHGs yet faces the damage. This strengthens the case for loss-and-damage finance, and India's own IHR states face similar disproportionate exposure.
- Governance and early warning:
- Technology cannot stop collapses, so the focus is detection. The article proposes high-altitude satellite and drone surveillance for cliff fracturing and permafrost thaw.
- It also proposes real-time acoustic and hydrological sensors on glacier-fed rivers, continuous monitoring of glacial lakes with engineered drainage where feasible, and a shared regional real-time data system.
- This links to NMSHE's monitoring mandate and ICIMOD's regional role.
- Land-use and zoning: Flood zoning must account for valley slope. Steeper slopes concentrate damage vertically, so infrastructure must sit much higher above the riverbed. Gentler slopes spread damage horizontally and need a different approach.
- Hydropower and infrastructure:
- Two expert committees recommended restricting projects or requiring detailed expert review above 2,200 m. The author wants a firm ban above a defined elevation.
- The Chenab-Beas tunnel (3,140 m, Pir Panjal) is called "eminently avoidable" despite a logical-looking water-diversion rationale from the western Indus-system rivers.
- Counter-view: such projects serve energy security and Indus Waters Treaty-related water-use goals, so safeguards such as cumulative EIA and slope-specific siting may be preferable to blanket bans.
- Way forward: Rigorously reassess every IHR project for environmental impact, hazard-averseness and climate resilience, and observe a moratorium meanwhile.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "Retreating glaciers and thawing permafrost are heightening disaster risk in the Indian Himalayan Region. Explain the mechanisms involved and critically evaluate the case for restricting high-altitude hydropower and infrastructure. Suggest a regional cooperation framework for early warning."
Related topics
- Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA Notification 2006), cumulative impact assessment, carrying-capacity studies
- National Disaster Management Act 2005, NDMA guidelines on GLOF and landslides, Sendai Framework
- Loss and damage (UNFCCC), COP27/COP28 fund, climate finance
- Indus Waters Treaty, western vs eastern rivers, interlinking of rivers
- Glaciers, snow-line and the cryosphere (physical geography), western disturbances
- Himalayan geology: young fold mountains, seismicity, Main Central Thrust
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 13 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs