BrainParrot

Why UAPA demands urgent reform

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 12 October 2026

Summary

  • Marking the second death anniversary of Prof. G.N. Saibaba (12 Oct), the author argues that the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) criminalises dissent. Its vague definitions and near-impossible bail standards let the State keep activists, scholars and journalists in jail for years without trial.
  • He says courts have not corrected the problem. The Supreme Court overturned two attempts to narrow the law, and benches treat chargesheets and delay inconsistently. He calls for an urgent rethink.

UPSC relevance: GS2 Polity: fundamental rights (Art. 21), judiciary; GS3 Internal Security: anti-terror law

Key facts for Prelims

  • UAPA: enacted 1967; major amendments 2004, 2008, 2012, 2019 (list of amendments).
  • 2019 amendment: Centre can designate individuals as terrorists under Section 35 (Fourth Schedule); earlier only organisations could be banned (pre- and post-2019).
  • Section 43D(5): bail restriction for Chapters IV and VI offences; Section 43D(2): up to 30 days police custody and 180 days to file chargesheet.
  • Seminal bail cases: Watali (2019), K.A. Najeeb (2021), Thwaha Fasal (2021).
  • Article's legal markers: "membership" of unlawful organisations is not defined in the Act, per the author. A 2011 Supreme Court bench read it as "active membership" (incitement to violence), overturned in 2023 in review jurisdiction. A Delhi High Court reading of "terrorism" clauses in a Delhi riots bail case was later declared "not to be treated as precedent".
  • Bombay High Court acquitted Prof. G.N. Saibaba of all charges in 2024. A trial court had convicted him in 2017 (life imprisonment) after his 2014 arrest on Maoist-link allegations.
  • Review jurisdiction (Art. 137) is meant only to correct errors apparent on the face of the record (per the article).

Data and details

  • Saibaba: 90% physically disabled, a decade in prison, much in solitary confinement, died soon after release (second death anniversary on 12 Oct 2026).
  • Bhima Koregaon (2018): UAPA charges against 16 scholars and activists, all jailed. Eight years later the trial has not begun and charges are not yet framed. Fr. Stan Swamy died in custody. 14 of the remaining accused got bail after years in prison, with restrictive conditions (multiple reporting conditions, travel limits). The 16th, Surendra Gadling, got bail in the case but stays jailed in another case.
  • Delhi riots (2020): UAPA charges against multiple student leaders, scholars and activists described as "intellectual architects" of riots; the author says there was no direct evidence, only vague conspiracy charges. In early 2026 the SC granted bail to five of seven appellants after more than five years in jail, but denied bail to Sharjeel Imam and Umar Khalid, and effectively barred fresh bail pleas for a year. The author says the "intellectual architect" label is unknown to law. Over six years in jail without trial (almost 10% of an average human lifespan). Khalid has published a book from prison; Imam continues his PhD.
  • Khurram Parvez (JKCCS coordinator, arrested 2021) and journalist Irfan Mehraj (arrested 20 March 2023) were granted bail in July 2026, after Parvez spent five years without trial.
  • Other names: Soni Sori (allegedly tortured in custody, acquitted of all charges), Akhil Gogoi (anti-CAA activist), Siddique Kappan (arrested travelling to cover the Hathras case, two years in jail before SC bail).
  • Inconsistency in delay: the SC did not treat five years without trial as "excessive" delay in denying bail to Imam and Khalid, while other courts held five years to be excessive (for example in the Khurram Parvez case).
  • Inconsistency in chargesheet scrutiny: some judges apply strict scrutiny to police chargesheets; others take an "eyes wide shut" approach, making bail "judge-centric".

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Special penal statutes depart from ordinary criminal procedure. The key trade-off is state security versus personal liberty. Judicial doctrine (K.A. Najeeb) holds that statutory bail restrictions do not oust constitutional courts' power to grant bail on Art. 21 grounds where trials drag on, though this relief is not automatic.
  • Vague offence definitions (for example "membership") offend the principle of legality and invite discretionary use. This is why precision and review are at the heart of reform proposals.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 Polity: fundamental rights (Art. 19, 21 and speedy trial), judicial review, rule of law; GS3 Internal Security: terrorism laws and their safeguards.

Background primer

Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA)

What it is:
India's primary anti-terror law. It departs from ordinary criminal procedure by expanding remand windows, restricting bail and empowering the executive to proscribe organisations and designate individuals.
Founded:
Enacted in 1967 primarily to target secessionist activities. Its roots lie in the 16th Constitutional Amendment (1963), which allowed restrictions on Art. 19(1)(a)-(c) in the interests of sovereignty and integrity. It was passed under the Indira Gandhi government; TADA lapsed in 1995 and POTA was repealed in 2004.
Why it matters:
Parliament's assessment that the ordinary presumption of pre-trial liberty needs modification where allegations threaten the foundations of the State.

Bail jurisprudence under Section 43D(5)

Additional context

  • The Supreme Court's 5 Jan 2026 judgment in Gulfisha Fatima v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) (2026 INSC 2; FIR No. 59 of 2020) is the Delhi riots bail ruling the article refers to. It granted bail to five of the seven appellants and denied it to Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam. The Court differentiated the roles of the accused. It held that the "prima facie true" test under Section 43D(5) is a threshold inquiry that does not involve a detailed examination of evidence. It also held that delay alone does not override the statutory bar. It allowed Khalid and Imam to renew their bail pleas after protected witnesses are examined or after one year, whichever is earlier.
  • A further Supreme Court judgment of 18 May 2026, Syed Iftikhar Andrabi v. NIA, Jammu (2026 INSC 503), takes up the interface between Section 43D(5) and Art. 21's guarantee of personal liberty. It also examines how smaller Benches apply the three-Judge Bench ruling in K.A. Najeeb.
  • Drishti IAS records that 4,690 persons were arrested under the UAPA between 2018 and 2020 with only 3% convicted. This is dated data, not the current year.
  • In a Rajya Sabha reply (Dec 2024), the Ministry of Home Affairs stated that no provision exists for support or compensation to persons acquitted under the UAPA. This is relevant to the compensation reform proposal.

Mains dimensions

  • Vagueness and legality: Terms such as "membership", "terrorist act" and "unlawful activity" have wide, undefined limits (extreme examples: sloganeering or possessing literature). This enables use against dissenters.
  • Process as punishment: Bail near-impossible plus slow trials mean long pre-trial detention. The Bhima Koregaon case has had no framed charges after eight years, and Saibaba spent ten years in jail before acquittal. The deprivation of Art. 21 happens before guilt is established.
  • Judicial inconsistency: Narrowing readings (2011 "active membership"; Delhi HC's reading of terrorism clauses) were undone by the SC (2023 review; "not a precedent" ruling). Inconsistent views on delay (five years excessive in one case, not in another) and on chargesheet scrutiny make outcomes bench-dependent.
  • Counter-view (balance): Parliament deliberately designed a stricter bail regime for terror offences (Chapters IV and VI). Courts have held that Section 43D(5) requires only a threshold inquiry. The State argues that security threats need special tools. Safeguards such as K.A. Najeeb (Art. 21 override after prolonged delay) already exist; the issue is uniform application.
  • Evidence limits: The author says the Delhi riots cases rest on conspiracy and "intellectual architects" without direct evidence.
  • Way forward: statutory definitions of "membership" and terrorist acts requiring overt acts or incitement to violence; time-bound trials and fast-track UAPA courts; compensation for wrongfully incarcerated; sanction and accountability for malicious prosecution.

Possible Mains question

**GS2/GS3, 15 marks:** "The UAPA is meant to counter terrorism but critics argue that it undermines personal liberty and due process. Critically examine the Act's bail regime and the role of the judiciary in balancing national security with Article 21."

Related topics

  • Art. 21, right to speedy trial, bail jurisprudence (K.A. Najeeb, Watali, Thwaha Fasal)
  • Art. 19(2)/(4) and the 16th Amendment; sedition (BNS replacement debate) and free speech
  • NIA Act 2008; NIA's role; NSA 1980; PMLA bail standards
  • Prison reforms, undertrial population
  • Right to protest and Art. 19(1)(a)–(c)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 12 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs