BrainParrot

Ex-Chief Justice says executive’s grip over judiciary has tightened

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 11 October 2026

Summary

  • At the presentation of the book Who will judge the judges (by retired Madras High Court judge K. Chandru) at the Asian College of Journalism, Chennai, on Saturday, Justice S. Muralidhar, former Chief Justice of the Orissa High Court, said the executive's grip over appointments to the constitutional courts, and especially over the CJI's role, has progressively tightened since May 2014.
  • He argued that in practice primacy has shifted back to the executive. He also warned that for about the next 10 years in the Supreme Court, and several more years in High Courts, judges will owe their positions to the current political establishment and the collegium members who appointed them.
  • Other speakers (R. Vaigai, Sashi Kumar) spoke on the judiciary's constitutional and transformative role and on the Constitution being under attack, as the source reports.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Judiciary, judicial appointments (Collegium vs executive), separation of powers

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art 124(2): appointment of SC judges by the President after consultation (CJI mandatory). Art 217(1): HC judges (CJI, Governor, HC Chief Justice).
  • Art 224 deals with additional judges in High Courts.
  • Collegium = SC: CJI + 4 senior-most judges; HC: Chief Justice + 2 senior-most judges. Not mentioned in the Constitution.
  • Judges Cases: 1981 (S.P. Gupta, First), 1993 (SC Advocates-on-Record, Second), 1998 (Third, Special Reference), 2015 (Fourth, NJAC struck down).
  • The NJAC came via the 99th Constitutional Amendment to replace the Collegium. Article 124A created the NJAC body.
  • Names recommended by a High Court collegium reach the government only after approval by the CJI and the SC collegium.

Data and details

  • Justice S. Muralidhar (former CJ, Orissa High Court): the executive's grip over appointments to constitutional courts "progressively tightened" since May 2014, especially regarding the CJI's role.
  • His timeline: the collegium as it has worked "in the last 12 years" has transformed steadily. Primacy has shifted back to the executive. The government has steadily extended its grip over appointments and transfers of judges and chief justices of High Courts.
  • His projection: for the next 10 years in the Supreme Court and several more in High Courts, judges will owe their position to the political establishment and collegium members who appointed them. He said this "forebodes not too well" for the judiciary's future.
  • R. Vaigai (Senior Advocate, Madras HC): the judiciary must act as guardian of the Constitution and laws, and also play a transformative and empowering role.
  • Sashi Kumar (Chairman, Asian College of Journalism and Media Development Foundation): a powerful judiciary falls short in safeguarding one of the world's finest written Constitutions, which he said is under attack by the ruling dispensation.
  • The book was presented to the panellists by N. Ram, Director of The Hindu. Event: Saturday, Chennai.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The Constitution says judges are appointed by the President after consultation. Art 124(2) requires consultation with such judges as the President deems necessary, always including the CJI. Art 217(1) requires consultation with the CJI, the Governor and the High Court Chief Justice for HC judges.
  • The Collegium is a judicial creation, not in the text. It evolved through Supreme Court judgments rather than the Constitution or an Act.
  • Justice Muralidhar's claim concerns practice: formal judicial primacy exists, but the executive can influence outcomes through vetting, delay and selective acceptance. The executive cannot formally reject reiterated recommendations, but it sometimes stalls appointments by sitting on files. The claim is a former judge's viewpoint and a prediction, not an established finding.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Structure, organisation and functioning of the Judiciary; separation of powers; appointment of judges (Art 124(2), 217(1)); basic structure (judicial independence).

Background primer

The Collegium system

What it is:
A judge-led mechanism for appointing and transferring judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts.
Members:
The SC Collegium comprises the CJI and four senior-most judges; HC Collegiums comprise the Chief Justice and two senior-most judges.
Mandate:
The government may return a recommendation for reconsideration, including on national-security or public-interest grounds, but if the collegium reiterates the names, the government is bound to appoint them. The government's inputs come largely through an Intelligence Bureau inquiry.
Why it matters:
It limits executive dominance and reinforces judicial independence and separation of powers. Critics point to opacity and lack of accountability.

Memorandum of Procedure (MoP)

What it is:
An agreement between the judiciary and the government with guidelines for appointments to the higher judiciary.
Mandate:
It lays out the steps: the collegium initiates names, the Centre conducts background checks, and the Centre can return recommendations once with reservations.

National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC)

What it is:
Created by the 99th Constitutional Amendment as a six-member body: the CJI, two senior SC judges, the Union Law Minister and two eminent persons.

Additional context

  • The Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Amendment Bill, 2026 raised the sanctioned strength from 34 to 38 judges including the CJI, after an ordinance on 16 May 2026. As of 27 May 2026 the Court had 32 judges.
  • On 27 May 2026 the Collegium recommended five names for the Supreme Court: four High Court Chief Justices and Senior Advocate V. Mohana. On 28 September 2026 it recommended the elevation of further High Court Chief Justices (including those of Gujarat, Delhi and Telangana) to the Supreme Court.
  • In February 2026 the Collegium adopted a policy to transfer a prospective High Court Chief Justice about two months before the vacancy.
  • CJI Surya Kant's tenure ends in February 2027.

Mains dimensions

  • Form vs practice. Judicial primacy exists on paper (a reiterated recommendation binds the government). Executive influence operates through IB vetting, delays and pocket vetoes, selective clearance and transfers. This is the "primacy in practice" argument.
  • Both sides of accountability. Critics of the executive point to dependence of judges on government. Critics of the Collegium point to opacity, no written criteria, under-representation of women and marginalised groups, and nepotism concerns. Reform has to answer both.
  • Failed NJAC and the stalemate. The NJAC was struck down in 2015, and the revised MoP is still unfinalised. Without clear timelines and a public selection framework, both sides can exploit ambiguity.
  • Institutional timing. Collegium decisions are collective and made under changing CJIs. The Collegium's choices and the executive's pace of acceptance interact. A "10-year" claim about judges "owing" their positions is a prediction, not a fact; it needs to be evidenced by data on the pace and selectivity of clearances.
  • Basic structure. Independence of the judiciary is part of the basic structure, so any reform (a new NJAC or a Collegium-plus model) must keep judicial primacy and independence while adding transparency.
  • Way forward:
  • Finalise the MoP with timelines and a deemed-approval trigger.
  • Publish selection criteria and reasons.
  • Create a permanent, transparent secretariat for the Collegium.
  • Fix timelines for government responses.
  • Consider a broader-based commission that preserves judicial primacy.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Collegium system is criticised both for its opacity and for allegedly allowing growing executive influence in practice. Critically examine the working of judicial appointments in India and suggest reforms that protect judicial independence while ensuring accountability."

Related topics

  • Judges Cases (1981, 1993, 1998, 2015); basic structure doctrine; NJAC (99th Amendment)
  • Memorandum of Procedure; Art 124, 217, 222 (transfers), 224
  • Separation of powers; judicial independence and accountability
  • Judicial vacancies and pendency; Supreme Court strength (Number of Judges) Act

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 11 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs